The real driver of cost is land value.
Let’s look at the inverse: I can build a house in Cleveland, Ohio, but the moment I finish construction, the house is worth less than its construction cost. The market rate of available homes in good condition is lower.
That’s why cities like Cleveland pay out a property tax abatement for people who build new homes. Essentially, because they have to, or they’ll be stuck with empty lots forever.
Let’s do an example with some imaginary math:
Pretend the wholesale cost of a middle class home (building materials, permits, labor, etc) is $200,000
Let’s say that in California it’s wildly more expensive. We’ll call it $300,000
Well, the impact of that is not really the underlying problem because that house in Cleveland costs $300k and that house in LA costs $1,300,000
The construction cost to build new is a rounding error compared to the impact of land value, and that’s because if you live in Cleveland you’re working for some steel company that’s about to shut down in 5 years.
I think this land value concept weakens a lot of what you said in your comment, especially the content that to me came across as being really typical anti-California cynicism.
Sure, there’s been plenty of bad policy, but ultimately the major cause of lack of affordability for the poor in California is that continued growth has led to land value increases, especially when many of its major cities are more geographically constrained than places like Chicago and Houston (e.g., just look at a map of San Francisco, it can’t expand anywhere). But I’ll also point out how it still might be better to be poor in a place like California (e.g., in California the median income earner pays less tax than in Texas which is more regressive).
>> The actual problem, the elephant in the room, is that California is expensive, both by popularity and regulation. This makes for an embarrassing conundrum where California is simultaneously pushing poor people out while trying to subsidize their life via social programs.
> I think your comment works by making a bold assumption that construction in California is wildly expensive than elsewhere and that it’s the major driver of cost.
I didn’t make any bold claims.
Yes, and that's the point I was making in my comment. What's driving the price gap is that you're selling to a group with a much higher capacity to pay when you're building the 2000 sf homes.
But that has nothing to do with it being unprofitable to sell lower-priced homes, it's just less profitable. The talking point makes it sound like the home builders are trying to do good things, but they're victims of the government. No, it's nothing more than a desire to maximize profit, because the folks that are looking for 2000 sf homes are high income households with kids, and they're willing and able to pay a steep premium for that house.
You believe that builders are this nefarious cabal. I don’t think this is true. Hanlons razor and all that.
> You believe that builders are this nefarious cabal.
No, calling them profit maximizers has nothing to do with them being a "nefarious cabal".
When folks come along and ask "Why can't I afford a house?" the builders don't give the honest answer "Because we're maximizing profit, and that means we don't build houses for you." Instead they say "We're trying but the government won't let us build houses for you."
I kind of feel it is the inverse.
If you can build a house for X$/sqft, you have a linear relationship. If it costs 100k _plus_ X$/sqft (for sewer, permits, etc) now you have a floor. You can sell a bigger house for 600k, or a 35% smaller house for 425k, odds are you’ll sell the bigger house quicker. I bet the 325k homes would sell like beanie babies in the 90s in places like sf.
The actual problem, the elephant in the room, is that California is expensive, both by popularity and regulation. This makes for an embarrassing conundrum where California is simultaneously pushing poor people out while trying to subsidize their life via social programs.
I don’t think it’s working.