News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by javajosh on Friday October 26, 2012 @06:40PM (#4704595)
Wow. It's finally clear. Content creators are against phase-shifting because it threatens their distribution mechanisms. Consumers want phase-shifting because it makes consuming media an order of magnitude better.

The ideal solution would be for content creators to offer a DRM-free copy of their wares, and for consumers to not abuse this open-ness. But, it seems that consumers will abuse it: given a choice between a $30 BluRay of "The Avengers" and torrenting it for $0, lots choose the later (not the least of which is to avoid the pain of ripping the movie later).

I wonder, though, how bad the abuse would be if the service was really easy to use, and priced correctly? Why would I bother with bittorent if I had a really nice service that let me stream/download movies for a few bucks apiece?

Additionally, I personally wouldn't mind one bit if a subset of the data was encrypted with my public key, making it hard (but not impossible, of course) to share it. Combined with a some creative steganography to identify the targeted user, you have about a secure, enforceable system as is humanly possible.

There is a privacy concern here, of course - the seller can individually identify people who've bought their movie. But that's going to be a problem whenever information is bought and sold. Note that this privacy protection is relatively easy to get around even today, as law-enforcement can request credit card records and itemized purchase information from the retailer. The difference is that now you would require a target and to make effort to get at this data, whereas in this new system, it's right there. If this worries you, either don't purchase data or purchase it in person with cash.

Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by Zakharov on Friday October 26, 2012 @07:02PM (#4704654)
According to the article, content creators are fine with phase shifting.

"And the RIAA and the MPAA agree with you. In 2005, their lawyer (now the Solicitor General of the United States) assured the Supreme Court that “The record companies, my clients, have said, for some time now, and it’s been on their Website for some time now, that it’s perfectly lawful to take a CD that you’ve purchased, upload it onto your computer, put it onto your iPod.""

Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by wmf on Friday October 26, 2012 @07:41PM (#4704741)
Do you have specific criticisms of the iTunes store, PS3 store, Xbox store, etc.? People keep talking about legal downloads like they're a theoretical concept...
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by javajosh on Friday October 26, 2012 @10:21PM (#4705108)
I do have knowledge of the iTunes store. Unfortunately, it's content is saddled with DRM that prevents me from watching it where I want and how I want. It's data that forces me to use iTunes, of which I am not a fan. It's data that prevents me from sharing music with my friends, even on a temporary basis (e.g. the equivalent of a mix-tape).

Additionally, I have a Nook and while I like the device, the DRM means that I really don't own those books, and I'm not excited by the idea of B&N yanking my books (or worse, editing them behind my back). I'd like to keep my own copy that didn't rely on their reader, but without breaking the law and stripping the DRM, I can't do that.

Honestly, I'm not sure if there is a reasonable solution that gives consumers the convenience that they want, and the rights-holders the revenue they deserve. If this can't be done, then it may turn out to be the case that "selling information to consumers for profit" was a passing fad of the late second millenium.

Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by theevocater on Friday October 26, 2012 @08:39PM (#4704900)
Have you ever lived somewhere other than the United States? They are in fact a theoretical concept in many places.

Services like netflix, spotify and pandora are also just as rare and they usually have extremely reduced libraries outside the States.

Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by wmf on Friday October 26, 2012 @09:22PM (#4704985)
Given that this is a thread about US copyright law, I thought we were talking about the US market. I guess it's turned into generic copyright griping thread #4,702.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by nitrogen on Friday October 26, 2012 @11:20PM (#4705239)
With the global nature of the Internet and the universal human desire to participate in culture, it's difficult to discuss US copyright law without considering the international effects thereof.

There will always be more "copyright griping thread[s]" until the arbitrary and artificial barriers to universal cultural participation and consumption are torn down, until a Fringe fan in Mombasa can watch and participate in discussion about the latest episode at the same time as someone in Memphis.

Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by nitrogen on Friday October 26, 2012 @08:34PM (#4704894)
Still waiting for that iTunes client for Android...
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by wmf on Friday October 26, 2012 @09:19PM (#4704978)
OK, the Google Play store.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by nitrogen on Friday October 26, 2012 @11:17PM (#4705230)
My point is that it's somewhat inaccurate to say that legal content is easily accessible when there are exclusive deals, fragmentation, delays, revoked content, time-limited access, DRM, etc.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal by javajosh on Friday October 26, 2012 @06:43PM (#4704604)
And if content creators can't win a steganography war on a 2 gigabyte battlefield, then they deserve to lose.