Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal
by klodolph on Friday October 26, 2012 @05:23PM
(#4704329)
The point of this quote is to illustrate that even the RIAA thinks this is bogus.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal
by grecy on Friday October 26, 2012 @06:31PM
(#4704567)
I understand that in this particular case, the RIAA sided with consumers.
What I'm pointing out is that this sets a dangerous precedent for the future.
Now we (and the courts) are used to hearing what the record companies think is and is not lawful, when that has absolutely nothing to do with anything.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal
by Natsu on Friday October 26, 2012 @06:53PM
(#4704632)
Not really. They're saying that this position is so extreme that not even the RIAA agrees with it. That's a far cry from saying they're always right.
Re:United States Copyright Office: Ripping is Illegal
by philh on Friday October 26, 2012 @04:48PM
(#4704205)
It's not as if we're letting them decide the law by putting something on their website. We are letting them tell us what their interpretation of the law is.
I don't know why the lawyer was telling the Supreme Court what the record companies' interpretation of the law was, but it doesn't sound especially nefarious.
Why are we letting record companies tell us what's lawful? (and by extension, what's not)