Its a good entertaining read and elaborates on the absurdity of evaluating law as an algorithm.
It's the intent that matters anyway. What the government has now is a stick they can hit people with (they had the stick already, now they have permission). Like speeding, if you rip your copy of E.T. you bought at Walmart and put it on the family's iPad so the kids be quiet, or by god you're going back to Winnipeg, nobody is going to be knocking on your door. However, if you start a site called www.dvdtomp4.com and offer a mail-in DVD-to-MP4 service, you could expect to receive an interesting visit at some point in the future.
> It's the intent that matters anyway.
What if I intend to sell the product of my emu-packing operation? Surely, we did our own work!
Seriously, they say there are no stupid questions but if X is impossible then "is X illegal" is probably not a productive question to ask.
The point of asking such a ridiculous question is to show the silliness of attaching __so_much__ value to what are, essentially, very large numbers.
Here's a less ridiculous question for your consideration: What if a team of Mathematicians accidentally generate a copyrighted commercial MP3 during research? Is it illegal for them to hold on to that very large number? Furthermore, is it illegal for them to publish it?
Furthermore it's a misunderstanding to say that people attach value to a 'large number', the value is in the effort it took to arrive at it and the fruits it can give in the context of society. The sequence of bits by itself is meaningless because it only becomes a song or a movie using the right interpretation & context.
I hope not! It probably is illegal considering: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_numbers.
Man, the law just isn't rigorous enough for me.