News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by AceJohnny2 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @01:49AM (#47021593)
While the current incarnation of Google Chat has indeed been steadily improving, Google has a lot, and I mean a lot, to make up for:

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/a-decade-and-a-half-... (2021, as the URL says)

And it's not just messaging. Google has a decades-long history of abandoning apps that don't make them billions, which means no-one with memory trusts them. Especially in their current "AI-everything or bust!" incarnation.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by echelon on Sunday February 15, 2026 @03:10AM (#47021950)
I don't think we should cheer on one of the largest companies in the world to build a product to get them even more enterprise stranglehold.

The praise for this monopoly is misdirected. Every single one of you, unless you're a significant GOOG shareholder, should be wanting for antitrust breakup of Google. They're putting pressure on your wages and other investments, and they're contributing to a ceiling for other startups and companies.

Google engineers are brilliant, but the corporation itself needs to be horizontally dismantled into several Googles that all compete with one another. (Not simply a vertical breakup along product lines, but rather the old-school "Ma Bell" style breakup that creates companies that then have to compete on the same offerings.)

A breakup would be good for GOOG investors too, because there's far more value locked up in the company and far too many opportunities left by the wayside.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @04:47AM (#47022428)
> I don't think we should cheer on one of the largest companies in the world to build a product to get them even more enterprise stranglehold.

Depends of how you see it. At the moment, if you want a good productivity suit of tools, you have Microsoft or Microsoft because Google is hampered by their lackluster chat client.

People would like some competition.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by jen20 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @07:14AM (#47023100)
On that basis, Microsoft are also hampered by a lackluster chat client - Teams is atrocious. Slack is pretty much the only game in town that isn't bad (and even that needs native clients, because the UI is poor and not system-integrated).
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by StopDisinfo910 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @07:36AM (#47023208)
I think I have this discussion on HN everytime Teams comes up but it really is a great piece of software for a typical office worker. File sharing is incredible. You get a SharePoint and collaborative editing in a seamless way. Video conf is great and work great with Teams compatible room booking system and room video material. The chat part barely matters. People don't use Teams to chat. It's a collaboration hub. That's what Google is missing actually.

Slack is very much developers software in comparison.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by billyboy123 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @09:11AM (#47023804)
File sharing using Scarepoint is incredible. Incredible bad, that is. Everything is stored in mssql server behind the scenes, in the most inefficient way you could imagine. Scarepoint is the opposite of seamless, number of wasted man-years on it must certainly be in the millions, if not billions. Its ”wiki” sucks. It’s bad software that not even ms themselves want to touch, that’s why many of their other server softwares have migrated away from using it.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by consuln on Sunday February 15, 2026 @09:44AM (#47024087)
Are you thinking of the AllUserData table? :) Yeah, it appears pretty abhorrent if you’re coming from a DBA background.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by DangitBobby on Sunday February 15, 2026 @11:39AM (#47025072)
Meanwhile, last time I had a video call in Teams, when I went into the call settings to change my microphone, my computer slowed to a crawl and became inoperable until the person who called me ended it. We eventually settled on a phone call. When I try to share a file over a certain arbitrary size limit, Teams refuses to do so, indicating some undesired and complicated permissions interaction with Teams and SharePoint.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by seanhunter on Sunday February 15, 2026 @02:38PM (#47026743)
Anyone who thinks Teams is great because of SharePoint is living in an entirely different universe to the one I’m in.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by jen20 on Monday February 16, 2026 @04:17AM (#47032770)
It's not though. There are seams everywhere - between Sharepoint, Teams, OneDrive and so forth. It's the worst possible approach. Fortunately the company I work at switched to Slack the day I started (co-incidentally), so I've been able to compare and contrast the two live. Slack wins for every single use case _except_ video and audio (where Zoom or Webex are the only games in town), hands down.

That's on top of the fact that the Teams client is an absolute pig, and is incapable of remembering basic things like "which of the two cameras do I want to use" and "which audio output is appropriate".

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by meekaaku on Sunday February 15, 2026 @05:18AM (#47022594)
I dont get this idea of breaking big companies up is inherently a good thing. As a non-American, I think the breakup of AT&T/Bell Labs was a mistake. The world is yet to create a lab as innovative as Bell Labs. Current Google only comes even close with their far out projects(that dont directly make money) such as their quantum computing/deepmind/boston dynamics(when google had them)

Besides, if one does break up google, you wouldnt have those divisions running.

If there are far more opportunities left by the wayside, some one is going to out compete them, ie Slack and Teams

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by michaelt on Sunday February 15, 2026 @05:46AM (#47022734)
> As a non-American, I think the breakup of AT&T/Bell Labs was a mistake.

With the benefit of hindsight, the break up was performed in the most ineffective way you could possibly imagine.

Take a national monopoly, and convert it into seven regional monopolies, which don't compete on price or service? Then let those monopolies merge back into three companies?

Countries that addressed national telecoms monopolies with local loop unbundling and similar policies seem to have ended up with much more competitive markets.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by direwolf20 on Sunday February 15, 2026 @07:21AM (#47023138)
The Bell breakup is the only reason we have communication technologies newer than $2/minute telephone calls or (for the same price) Telex.

Bell had one good side, that was Bell Labs. How was it funded? By overcharging the whole country for communications, pocketing 90% of the profit, and using the last 10% to find ways to lower costs to provide the service — cost decreases that would not be passed onto customers.

It was even worse than it is right now with the regional internet monopolies.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by usefulcat on Sunday February 15, 2026 @10:53AM (#47024682)
> The world is yet to create a lab as innovative as Bell Labs.

That was entirely accidental. There's absolutely no guarantee that any given monopoly will produce anything remotely like Bell Labs, and I don't believe that a monopoly was required to do what Bell Labs did.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by xnx on Sunday February 15, 2026 @05:47PM (#47028554)
Google has come pretty close. Who knows how long it would've been before someone else came up with Attention is all you need.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by keeda on Sunday February 15, 2026 @06:17PM (#47028771)
And yet they sat on transformers until OpenAI kicked off the AI boom by actually productizing that research in ChatGPT. Though it's possible they were just being cautious, my uncharitable view is that they knew this would disrupt their highly lucrative ads business, which is always the problem with monopolies.

Also you're overlooking other top-notch corporate research institutions like Microsoft Research, which arguably are more "Blue Sky" in the sense they are not constrained to any current product lines.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by compsciphd on Monday February 16, 2026 @09:53AM (#47035763)
IBM Research when IBM was basically a monopoly was also an innovation machine.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by waffletower on Monday February 16, 2026 @05:03PM (#47040944)
> The world is yet to create a lab as innovative as Bell Labs.

This comment is as if "Attention is all you need" was never written and never funded by Google, and the cascade of related research that it inspired inside Google alone isn't considered either. The other Google accomplishments mentioned seem to be filtered to earlier than 2018 as well.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by codethief on Sunday February 15, 2026 @09:20AM (#47023869)
> https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/a-decade-and-a-half-... (2021, as the URL says)

This article never fails to crack me up! Arstechnica.com at its best.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by htrp on Sunday February 15, 2026 @09:54AM (#47024166)
i think google meet duo is finally being deprecated in favor of another solution

https://support.google.com/meet/answer/15226472?hl=en

Google Duo was upgraded and rebranded to Google Meet in 2022. However, the legacy calling experience (previously known as Duo) was still available. Now, these legacy calls are being upgraded to Meet calls, which contain expanded features like cloud encryption, live captions, in-call chat, stackable effects, and more. To use the new Meet calling experience, update your app to the latest version. As users move over to Meet calling, some of the legacy calling features will no longer be available. In addition, any reference to what was formerly known as Duo will now show “legacy.” From September 2025, legacy calling will be replaced with Meet calling.

Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by flopsamjetsam on Sunday February 15, 2026 @03:20PM (#47027152)
Such a great article. I love a good postmortem. I also had no idea of the chequered history of Google's messaging apps. I'd heard some of the names before, but being an iMessage and WhatsApp user, I'd just stuck with those mostly.
Re:OpenAI Should Build Slack by waffletower on Monday February 16, 2026 @04:57PM (#47040882)
It seems that the Messages (iMessage) product manager(s) have never even seen Slack. So difficult to go from such a fun product at work to bland and awkward for the rest of my connected life. Seems completely backwards.