News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pron on Thursday October 25, 2012 @10:25AM (#4697750)
I'd like to offer one more partial cause. It is certainly incomplete and possibly simplistic, but let's put it out there:

Big-idea technological innovation has been led for years by the US, and for some time by the USSR as well. But the Soviet Union is gone, and there may be a cultural shift in America: going at it alone and distrust of government. The libertarian streak that has long been present in American culture seems to be taking hold of more and more people. Even Democrats seem to have a distrust of government, and some even partially accept right-wing axioms about the benefits of small government and spending cuts. But some undertakings are simply too big for private corporations, and require government funding and control. Only Americans increasingly distrust the gov't.

This sentiment is not bad necessarily, but it's becoming pervasive and might be spreading beyond just distrust of government. Americans (or, rather, well-to-do Americans, or those born to the right parents in the right neighborhoods) don't want to be a small cog in a big machine. They prefer going at it alone, or in a small team and encourage individual expression.

So this is not wrong, and it certainly doesn't apply to everyone everywhere, but it might just be one more reason in the decline of huge undertakings, that might require collaboration on a national or international scale, where talented people must be content to contribute their small part to a very large and non-individual expression.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:08PM (#4698122)
I don't think this is right. We have a bigger government than we did historically, and the past few years have led to massive increases in the size of the government.

Rather, there seems to be a change in the role of the government. At one point we wanted the government to engage in big projects. Now we just want the government to redistribute wealth and engage in irrelevant expressive acts (yay/nay gay marriage, faith based blah blah, forcing christian hospitals to pay for birth control).

But this tends to mirror changes in the private sector as well, so I imagine it's just a cultural shift rather than something government related.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by sneak on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:44PM (#4698278)
> Now we just want the government to redistribute wealth and engage in irrelevant expressive acts

This seems like a gross oversimplification.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pron on Thursday October 25, 2012 @01:38PM (#4698577)
> Now we just want the government to redistribute wealth and engage in irrelevant expressive acts

Whether or not these things are irrelevant is a personal political judgement, right? And what is "distribution of wealth" for one might be an investment in society or demand-side economics for another.

But your comment precisely demonstrates this lack of trust in government, or, the way you put it, in your fellow citizens.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 25, 2012 @05:10PM (#4699599)
And what is "distribution of wealth" for one might be an investment in society or demand-side economics for another.

It's not a moon shot, nuclear energy, the interstate highway system, or anything of the sort the article is actually discussing.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pulplobster on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:41PM (#4698258)
> the past few years have led to massive increases in the size of the government

Except, of course, that's a big lie. The "public Sector Has Lost Over 550,000 Jobs Since Mid-2009".

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:50PM (#4698313)
Expenditures are up at both the federal and state level.

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/FGEXPND

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/SLEXPND

It's true that the states chose to spend on the money increasing worker pay (http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECIGVTWAG) rather than hiring more workers, but that's a separate issue. (Call it anti-Keynesian spending during a recession.)

Historically we did things like hiring a bunch of unemployed people and having them build stuff (trails in national parks, fancy downtown landscaping, transit projects, etc). In the most recent recession, all we did was give the unemployed 99 weeks of free money.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by cube13 on Thursday October 25, 2012 @10:50AM (#4697833)
I also think it's a political issue, but not specifically because of lack of trust of the government.

I think it's lack of competition for the US as a whole. For the first time in the history of the US, the primary international problems for the US aren't developed nations that are as technologically advanced(or even more advanced). Even the biggest current competitor(China) is so beholden to US interests that they can't afford to do anything to destabilize the US economy, and they're still behind on innovation by a tremendous amount.

Also, the current military challenges that the US faces aren't things that can be solved strictly through technological innovation. It's asymmetric warfare, so there's very little incentive for the US to invest heavily into new tech.

Compare to the international problems the US faced in the 20th century. The first half was dominated by competition and warfare with the developed nations in Europe. WWI and WWII forced the US to invest heavily into new tech. The second half was dominated by the cold war, which, again, forced the US to invest resources to keep up with the USSR.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pdonis on Thursday October 25, 2012 @11:26AM (#4697961)
Also, the current military challenges that the US faces aren't things that can be solved strictly through technological innovation. It's asymmetric warfare, so there's very little incentive for the US to invest heavily into new tech.

So remotely piloted drones, small weaponized robots, and ever more precisely targeted guided munitions don't count as "new tech"?

To the best of my knowledge, R&D funding for new technology that might have military applications has, if anything, increased over the last 10 years or so.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by maxerickson on Thursday October 25, 2012 @11:00AM (#4697862)
On the other hand, many of the pilots involved in Afghanistan live and work near Las Vegas.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/digitalnation/blog/2...

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by msrpotus on Thursday October 25, 2012 @11:09AM (#4697901)
But America faces plenty of challenges that technology can help with, especially around health and food issues. Just because we don't face significant challenges due to military technologies doesn't mean that technology can't be useful in other ways.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pdonis on Thursday October 25, 2012 @11:23AM (#4697947)
But some undertakings are simply too big for private corporations, and require government funding and control.

I don't think it's the size of the undertakings as much as their time horizon. Corporate time horizons just aren't long enough to comprehend investing now in, say, a manned Mars mission in 2030. Even at a pretty low discount rate, the net present value in 2012 of resources mined from Mars in the 2030's is effectively zero to a corporate bean counter.

The problem is that government time horizons are even shorter. The TR article talks about NASA having the technical knowledge to send men to Mars; but we had that technical knowledge in the 1970's. The problem is that, since the Apollo program (which was, I think, an outlier in this respect), the US government simply hasn't had enough consistency of purpose to reliably fund ventures that last beyond a change in the party that controls the White House and/or Congress.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by Florin_Andrei on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:28PM (#4698194)
That's not surprising in a culture that equates government with evil.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pdonis on Thursday October 25, 2012 @01:34PM (#4698549)
I agree the time horizon is different in other cultures. France took 20 years to get its economy running on 75% nuclear power. China has embarked on long-term infrastructure projects.

However, having a longer time horizon is not entirely a good thing either. It's a benefit if the long-term project you pick and commit resources to is a good idea; but it's much worse than the short time horizon case if the long-term project you pick is a bad idea. (Some posters in this thread have argued that the Apollo project itself is an example of the latter.)

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by SiVal on Thursday October 25, 2012 @01:47PM (#4698616)
So, your theory is that after decades of massive federal government expansion, an important reason today's much larger federal bureaucracy is unable to accomplish what the much smaller government of fifty years ago accomplished is those darned libertarian "right-wing axioms about the benefits of small government"? Our big government can't do what it did when it was smaller because of people who think there are benefits to smaller government.

And the reason the Europeans haven't shown us how to do it, is that the fault of all those small-government ideologues who dominate political thought in Europe?

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pron on Thursday October 25, 2012 @03:01PM (#4698980)
That is absolutely not what I'm suggesting at all.

I'm not talking about the size of the government, but about the attitude towards it and other large organizations, and to one's role in society.

I'm also not blaming "darned libertarians" (I do have a lot to say about "them", but HN isn't quite the place for such discussion) for anything. I'm simply saying that some axioms of the libertarian ideology have permeated throughout American society. This leads to a changing culture, and different cultures have different accomplishments.

Which type of accomplishment is "better" or more "important" is, again, subject to personal preference, and I'm not going to debate that. All I was suggesting is that the US hasn't accomplished recently the same kind of things it had accomplished in the past, may be in part due to a shift in attitude.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by chubbard on Friday October 26, 2012 @12:01AM (#4700818)
Well you made a great original comment, but unfortunately, some of the replies want to politicize your observation trying to assign a "side" to it. It's a very social sciences observation so it's hard to prove and for some probably even accept.

I'd add as further proof to your observation was look at how even government organizations position themselves in the last decades. Remember the army of one commercials that were meant to appeal to that very individualism attitude. Military in the US is the antithesis of individualism. If you join the military you are told when to wake up, how to dress, what to do, when you'll do it, and how you'll feel about it while doing it. Chain of command is rule number one in the military. It even has processes so that individuals can't be completely responsible. It's too dangerous. But, here we have a campaign to tell you that's not true, and in fact you have autonomy because that's what our society assigns value to now.

You are not judging it just stating an observation. There is no wrong or right to it.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by chubbard on Thursday October 25, 2012 @10:49AM (#4697830)
I find this very insightful so we're talking about a modern day tower of babel. But, instead of a destruction of a common language it's a destruction of a common set of values. We stopped believing in government due to a difference in values we saw. That gave rise to a change in values of individual expression over collective work. And now we can't collectively agree so the problems we can solve are smaller because we create smaller and smaller pockets that agree.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by yesimahuman on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:14PM (#4698144)
Let's not forget that many of our parents and gradparents "regretted" working for the man and never following their dreams. That's a huge part of why I'm not interested in working at a large corporation.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by chubbard on Thursday October 25, 2012 @10:48PM (#4700613)
I'm not saying these last 40 years haven't had merit. The recession of 1982 probably was probably the symbol that put the nail in the collective view to problem solving. When Reagan turned that recession around i think the country started to believe individuals could solve these problems over government. You listen to people who were in the work force and they remember the change. My father references that in shaping his political views and he's not the only person I've heard say that. It was an important milestone and shortly after we saw the rise of me generation which evolved into personal liberty movement. And an emphasis on individual expression and thinking in our schools. And this is how we viewed problem solving required. But it also shaped us in what problems we wanted to solve because if we had a problem that didn't lend itself to this approach we didn't solve it. Questioned if it was even a problem (global warming fits this as others).

I think these are two strategies you can take. One isn't more dominant than the other. But each has their place along with pros and cons, and you have to use both over time . It just depends on the problems you face which strategy you should employ.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by lumberjack on Thursday October 25, 2012 @03:10PM (#4699011)
>But some undertakings are simply too big for private corporations, and require government funding and control.

Not only. The government is (at least supposed too) work for the benefit of society. You can expect the government to allocate billions for a project like the LHC if the science committee foresees that it's a viable scientific undertaking. You can't expect the same of corporations. Corporations are there to make increasing profits for their shareholders, period.

This is the reason why some people were upset with the vision of private enterprises replacing NASA. Sure private enterprises will bring competition, but only where private enterprises can make profit.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by waterlesscloud on Thursday October 25, 2012 @03:15PM (#4699037)
"Corporations are there to make increasing profits for their shareholders, period."

This is an overly-simplistic and ultimately quite wrong view of corporations.

Corporations exist to achieve the goals their shareholders set for them, which may include increasing profits, but it may not. That's certainly not the only goal the shareholders may set.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by lumberjack on Thursday October 25, 2012 @05:01PM (#4699562)
How did you manage to be pedantic on me? You are right. However I don't agree that it's "overly-simplistic" but I don't have statistics to back up my impression.

Also I think you are wrong when it comes to the US. In the US, corporations are legally obligated to maximize profits.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by waterlesscloud on Thursday October 25, 2012 @06:47PM (#4699966)
No, though that's a very common belief. The reality is more complicated.

The directors of a for-profit corporation have to make decisions that they in good faith believe will lead to shareholder value, and there is considerable leeway in determining what that means. It does not always mean maximizing profit, and the timeframe for the increased value can be very long.

In addition, there are a number of other forms of corporations (non-profits, Low-Profit, Benefit, etc) that can expressly put a public good ahead of profits.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by brg on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:22AM (#4705725)
I disagree that leaving funding in the hands of a single bureaucracy will lead to the outcomes you hope.

Funding for the super-conducting super-collider set in Waxahachie, Texas was cut as a direct result of the 1992 US Presidential election. The scientific community was in agreement on its advantages, but political retribution won out.

That the LHC survived was due in large part by the desire of European agencies to bring science back to Europe. That the US had failed to complete construction of their beam operations gave them an opening and and opportunity. This is the motiviation more so, I would say, than it was any desire to fund basic research in HE physics.

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by zerostar07 on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:04PM (#4698103)
Add to that another simplistic cause: the aging of the population of the West.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by eli_gottlieb on Thursday October 25, 2012 @10:30AM (#4697763)
That's a large part of it. We have a harder and harder time solving Big Problems because all truly Big problems are partly or largely social as well as technical. The more we refuse to act together or insist on purely technological "solutions", the less actually solvable our Big Problems get.
Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by pdonis on Thursday October 25, 2012 @12:13PM (#4698141)
all truly Big problems are partly or largely social as well as technical

Very true, and the TR article makes this point. However, the article doesn't even talk about how to solve the social aspects of the problems. For example, when talking about how famines are the result of political problems, not technical ones, it dismisses the political part with this comment: "famines will still occur because there will always be bad governments." What a cop out. MIT has whole departments devoted to economics and political science because it understands that intellectual tools need to be developed and applied in those disciplines just as much as in physics or engineering; why can't its magazine recognize that?

(Full disclosure: TR seemed to me to be a much better magazine when I was at MIT, so I tend to rant when I see evidence of its decline.)

Re:Why We Can't Solve Big Problems by eli_gottlieb on Sunday October 28, 2012 @07:44AM (#4708722)
Of course it doesn't talk about how to solve the social aspects of problems. That would require criticizing the current sociopolitical status quo.