News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Icelanders vote to base new constitution on crowdsourced ... by AnthonBerg on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:43PM (#4684010)
Icelander here. The headline is completely false: "Icelanders approve their crowdsourced Constitution."

We Icelanders voted in a NON-BINDING referendum, where the first question was "yes / no, I want / do not want the proposals from the public constitutional congress to be used as the basis for a parliamentary referendum for a new constitution". It is then explicitly stated on the voting card that the proposals may change in the process of being worked into a parliamentary referendum for a new constitution - which then again must be approved not once but twice by two separately elected parliaments (i.e. voted through in parliament, parliament dissolved, voted in again, and the referendum approved again there).

Headline is FALSE and misleading.

— edit: that said, I support the establishment of a new constitution, and I like a lot of things in the proposals. There are also some things I do not like. The proposals need work to become fit to be a constitution, that's for sure.

Re:Icelanders vote to base new constitution on crowdsourced ... by drivingmenuts on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:52PM (#4684067)
Have the results been published where non-Icelanders can read them?

This sounds like a fantastic idea, but it would be problematic in the US, I think. My opinion is that we're too large a population and too disengaged/disenfranchised for it to be truly representative. Perhaps a bit too polarized, as well.

Re:Icelanders vote to base new constitution on crowdsourced ... by saraid216 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:14AM (#4686859)
Yeah, it wouldn't work in the US. I'd like to see it thrown out as a hypothetical to see how people would react, though.
Re:Icelanders vote to base new constitution on crowdsourced ... by legitsource on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:22PM (#4685322)
Which proposals are controversial to the general public there?