News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by beedogs on Monday October 22, 2012 @09:16AM (#4682965)
It amazes me how the concept of "non-scarce" goods being a one-for-one substitute for physical items only seems to work in one direction in this brave new world in which we are unfortunately inhabiting, too.

If she'd been caught torrenting those same books in the US or a growing list of other countries, she'd face fines and court fees. Her Internet browser could be diverted to "anti-piracy education" sites; perhaps one day, she could be disconnected altogether.

Yet Amazon is allowed to arbitrarily remove those very same files with no explanation.

Pretty mindblowing how severely copyright has been perverted from its original intent.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by smithzvk on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:19PM (#4683860)
The one-way nature is exactly the crux of the matter. In a purely chaotic world where people do whatever was in their best interest in the short term, everybody would infringe on copyright whenever they wanted a book (or whatever "non-scarce" commodity) and the content producers would do whatever nasty tricks they felt would stop this from happening, including distributing your book in a form that can only be accessed via computers that you don't truly control and "reserving the right" to cut you off from what you "purchased".

We, fortunately, do not live in this world. However, from the standpoint of someone that prefers to purchase books, movies, and video games to promote these arts, it seems that the entities "selling" the content to me are more eager to head down that chaotic road than I am. That's not to diminish the fact that there are many rampant copyright infringers that have already happily moved down that road and could care less about long term benefit. It's just that I am not one of those people, and I don't deserve to be hit with the crap-storm that you intend for them, particularly when there is no evidence that they feel any of that storm at all.

So I long ago decided on a solution, just do what feels right. Buy from whatever distributor you like (I tend to stay away from Amazon, competition is always good) and then circumvent whatever DRM they place on it (for instance, go to one of those places of ill repute and get the book in an accessible format). It's not perfect, but it sure as hell is better than playing the game they set up.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by icebraining on Monday October 22, 2012 @07:06PM (#4686007)
Companies add DRM because people pay for DRM-ed content. Stop giving them incentives* and they'll stop.

Buyers, not pirates, are doing this to themselves.

* (this doesn't mean 'pirate'. Buying physical copies or just abstaining are valid alternatives)

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by pi18n on Monday October 22, 2012 @09:49AM (#4683082)
I'm one of the ones to leap out of the woodwork and shout that copying is not theft, so it's only fair that I point out this; torrenting is a massive copyright violation, as you are basically republishing the content. What Amazon did in this case is not against copyright, and the user had no claim to copyright of that work anyway.

Make no mistake; I disagree with the humongous damages leveled against torrenters and I would be dead set against allowing an ISP to redirect or disconnect a user.

But Amazon doing something they claimed rights to in their ToS and sharing a copyrighted work via torrent are quite different.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by smacktoward on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:04PM (#4683768)
The user had no copyright claim on that work, but he/she did have a reasonable expectation that a "purchased" good was hers to dispose of as she saw fit after completion of the sale, within the confines of the law. What people are objecting to is Amazon's redefinition of the rights of the seller at the expense of the rights of the buyer.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by _delirium on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:18PM (#4684536)
It's also interesting how similar this is to the previous round, a century ago: the first-sale doctrine arose precisely to put an end to shenanigans publishers were trying to pull where they claimed they were only "licensing" a copy of the text to the person who purchased the dead tree. It reasserted the property rights of the purchaser, which companies now are trying to erode with the same "just licensing" shenanigans.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by dredmorbius on Monday October 22, 2012 @07:23PM (#4686064)
Citation needed.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by _delirium on Monday October 22, 2012 @07:30PM (#4686098)
On which subject in particular do you want pointers to additional reading?

(I'm going to assume that for basic background information, such as the history of the "first-sale doctrine", you're as capable of using Google and Wikipedia as anyone else.)

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by dredmorbius on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:26AM (#4686774)
If you know, it's simple enough to provide a pointer.

Are you referring to Bobbs-Merrill Co. v. Straus (1908) later codified into 17 USC 109?

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by chris_wot on Monday October 22, 2012 @10:02AM (#4683142)
I feel that I need to point out that at no point did anyone accuse the lady in question of torrenting pirated content. In fact, that's part of the problem. Amazon refuse to say anything about why they took their action.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by speleding on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @06:35AM (#4687436)
Yes. But as an aside, it's a good thing she lives in Norway and will have easy access to the pirate bay to get her books back.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by beedogs on Monday October 22, 2012 @10:03AM (#4683148)
I'm not really arguing whether one action is any better or worse than the other; seeding a pile of ebooks isn't really something for which any valid defense can usually be given.

My point is that there's clearly a very large amount of effort being expended protecting the ever-expanding rights of content owners, and -- near as I can tell -- zero effort being spent protecting content purchased by honest consumers from being taken from them without justification or recourse.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:23PM (#4683880)
"seeding a pile of ebooks isn't really something for which any valid defense can usually be given"

How come? If you seed a pile of ebooks (let's assume it's a very big pile that contains a good chunk of books humanity considers important) than you're helping our culture spread. It is in fact very important for books to be massively copied in order to survive future catastrophes: whatever they come in form of nuclear winter, totalitarian copyright regime or cultural degradation and neglect.

I have my torrent of 20G of compressed ebooks and I feel very prepared for a digital nuclear winter.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by awj on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:53PM (#4684779)
Yes, I'm sure "stockpiling against the need to re-create society" is much higher on most people's list than "I don't want to pay for the things I want".
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Monday October 22, 2012 @03:26PM (#4685003)
I don't care about that. For most of that books, their authors are already dead; most of them are also forgotten to the point of being out-of-print.

Your comment will be justified if the stockpile was smaller and more hit-driven, but 20G is a nice cultural pill you will have difficulty arguing about.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by VMG on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:04PM (#4684411)
Don't forget to share Hollywood blockbusters and AAA video games. The rebel alliance is counting on your support.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Monday October 22, 2012 @03:36PM (#4685048)
Hollywood blockbusters and AAA video games are disgusting as a concept; most are also lousy and boring as an implementation of that concept.

So good news, I'm not pirating blockbusters, but bad news for you, I'm not paying for these either.

No food for your thick sarcasm.

What do I do? I support independent efforts while torrenting oldies and classics. You can say that latter is piracy, but I don't care and their authors don't care either, and I could not care less about "rights holders".

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Monday October 22, 2012 @06:10PM (#4685814)
I enjoy how my comments get a few upvotes and then slowly sink. It is somehow nice to "suffer" for truth.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by mejari on Monday October 22, 2012 @07:44PM (#4686134)
Maybe it's because you feel the need to use holier-than-thou language like "No food for your thick sarcasm." and "It is somehow nice to "suffer" for truth."
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:16AM (#4687056)
Well, my analogy is: I made a story where I come to a forest and pick berries and mushrooms, and then the next commenter comes and tells me that he's sure I also come to private toilets and steal the precious shit to eat. First, I am not stealing shit, and second, I don't usually eat shit. This is plainly offensive so I had to "brace myself".
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by jcmoscon on Monday October 22, 2012 @01:53PM (#4684342)
Seriously 20g? I bet you didn't read all of them!
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by jessaustin on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:09AM (#4686851)
Not yet. Other than reference materials and favorites "worth rereading", shouldn't most of the books in one's possession be those one hasn't yet read? When you're done with it pass it on to the next reader!

Well that's how it works for physical books; I'm not sure about electronic ones.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by beedogs on Monday October 22, 2012 @06:30PM (#4685896)
While I think your reasoning is noble, even commendable, I don't think it would hold up well in a civil case.

For the record, I'm in favor of this sort of "cultural hedging" as well, but I don't think it's something that most people would even think to do.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:02AM (#4687029)
Well, so sue me.

I was just arguing with books seeding "not being really something for which any valid defense can usually be given" If I should have read it as "any valid defense IN COURT can be given", then again, so sue me. But it's pretty easy to defend the morality of this case.

Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by beedogs on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:56AM (#4687322)
I'm with you on the morality of it.
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @06:09AM (#4687358)
And in the times when I can torrent a whole library of culture-defining books (whose authors mostly either passed away or no longer care), the book selling industry should reconsider the question: what exactly are they selling? What is their place to contribute to the society? Is it only about pushing vampire books by living authors while withholding vampire books by deceased authors?
Re:Outlawed by Amazon DRM by pi18n on Monday October 22, 2012 @11:50AM (#4683680)
I mistook your comment for saying they were roughly equivalent, I didn't get that you were pointing out the expanding rights for corporations vs. contracting rights for individuals. Please accept my apologies, I do believe that what you are talking about is one of the most important problems we have to address in the coming years.