News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That's not how email works by renewiltord on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:41PM (#46799751)
Tracking pixels don’t even work with Gmail because Google fetches them out of band. It doesn’t reveal open rates.
Re:That's not how email works by gweinberg on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @02:05PM (#46800076)
True, but HSBC thinks you read the email, because somebody fetched the tracking pixel, right? The irony is that HSBC and others who use this kind of thing probably aren't in the least interested in when or how many times you open the email. Whoever came up with this idea (probably) really did think it was (just) a pretty good way of figuring out if they have your correct email.
Re:That's not how email works by wrs on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:57PM (#46799964)
They do work for the inferred purpose here though, assuming Gmail only downloads them when the email is successfully delivered to the mailbox (and thus the address is valid).
Re:That's not how email works by extraduder_ire on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @04:38PM (#46801935)
IIRC, google limits their opening of remote images if they're unique per email or from less reputable sources.

They also send you an email back saying your email wasn't delivered after a few days or hours, so there's little benefit in using the tracking pixel to determine if an address exists.

Don't know if they fetch images from emails sent to non-existent addresses, but I would if I were to design such a system.

Re:That's not how email works by jldugger on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @03:02PM (#46800776)
> Gmail because Google fetches them out of band. It doesn’t reveal open rates.

"Our open rates have skyrocketed! send more emails!"

Re:That's not how email works by CGMthrowaway on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:53PM (#46799907)
Same with Apple Mail
Re:That's not how email works by mike-cardwell on Thursday January 29, 2026 @03:53AM (#46807510)
Apple's system doesn't work. At least not for everyone. https://www.grepular.com/Apples_Protect_Mail_Activity_Doesnt...
Re:That's not how email works by Almondsetat on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:59PM (#46799983)
I mean, they still work in some way. If you use tracking pixels to see if an email was read, I agree with you that this break the functionality. But if you just want to see if the email exists, then the fact that google fetches them (and triggers the parametric URL) still tells you something
Re:That's not how email works by bummy_commenter on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @02:12PM (#46800150)
It would be better if google also fetched tracking pixels in emails sent to addresses that do not exist.
Re:That's not how email works by renewiltord on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @05:12PM (#46802304)
So, why use a tracking pixel for that? Just send an email. e.g.

    $ head -n 100 /dev/random | md5sum
    a6cc1b7c09ccb122cb066c89e16b3140  -

And that yields an instantaneous error message https://i.imgur.com/twHhIU3.png that reads "Address not found. Your message to [email protected] was not delivered because the address could not be found".
Re:That's not how email works by philipwhiuk on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:53PM (#46799906)
What do you mean by 'fetches them out of band'?
Re:That's not how email works by CGMthrowaway on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:53PM (#46799913)
It downloads them and stores in serverside cache before you ever open the email
Re:That's not how email works by nkrisc on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @01:59PM (#46799984)
Frankly the best outcome as it makes them useless.
Re:That's not how email works by philipwhiuk on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @05:12PM (#46802308)
That does mean the email address exists though which was what HSBC was questioning.