I know you mention tool support I think it's worth mentioning that if you're using the MS stack Visual Studio is really, really good.
It is, unless you come from Java (using IDEs like NetBeans or Eclipse), in which case it's kind of comparable (but different). IMHO.
In fact, if MS were ever to make .NET/C# legacy like some people seem to believe "WinRT allows horribly HTML5 apps" implies, I bet JetBrains would just bolt ReSharper onto IDEA and off we all go.
if you've ever actually used Visual Studio 2010 or above, and compared it to Eclipse, you'd realize how sad Eclipse looks in comparison. I use both at work all the time. Nothing compares to VS.
I use both at work all the time, too. I tend to prefer VS, too, but there's some points where Eclipse really shines. Eclipse's continuous build, for example, is excellent. Your tests start immediately when so requested, where VS 2010 decides to first build all of the projects in the solution. Especially once the solution gets fairly sizeable, this becomes unproductive very fast. There's workarounds, but I don't want workarounds. I just want it to work immediately.
NCrunch [1] is a great help in that regard – auto-build and auto-test in the background while you work. I just wish I had codebases that were well-tested so that I could actually use it.
Re:The future of .NET
by codewright on Sunday October 21, 2012 @02:15PM
(#4680331)
That non-Windows machines are a comparable ghetto for C# programmers really only reinforces my point.
C# has one of the best standard libraries out there (well documented, rather well designed, batteries-included, etc)
C# has a decent set of relatively modern language constructs, yet is easy enough to learn for a very large group of programmers.
C# is faster than most (but not all) languages sporting a comparable set of high-level features.
C# has excellent tool support, and was designed for enabling such tool support, making refactoring and code navigating easier than in any other language except Java.
C# has a large ecosystem and user-base, making it easy to find answers to problems and components that solve problems not covered by its standard library.
None of these items, in isolation, are special. Java arguably has a stronger ecosystem, but is a less powerful language. C++ is faster, Scheme is more elegant (according to many), and so on. But I know of no other language that has all these areas covered so well simultaneously. Scala comes close, but is arguably more difficult to learn, and lacks on the ecosystem area (not in terms of library support, but in terms of best practices and large user base). This might change, which would be lovely.
All other languages you mentioned strongly lack on at least one of the above-mentioned aspects.
I'm not saying that C# is god's gift to mankind and the only good thing out there. I'm only saying that you're dismissing it too easily.
There are sufficient people out there who really like this combination of features to support a vibrant open source community. Which is why this community exists. Why dismiss something that exists and works well?