Re:Pirate Bay Founder Held In Solitary Confinement
by icebraining on Saturday October 20, 2012 @10:22PM
(#4678679)
There's obviously a difference between the indefinite ability to copy content and reselling a single used good.
For physical things, sure, but for digital goods, that's not so clear. A P2P network that automatically lent (copy+delete local) files would require only a very small number of bought copies, if the client could request a copy, play it and then release it immediately.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Held In Solitary Confinement
by TheAmazingIdiot on Sunday October 21, 2012 @01:39AM
(#4679090)
What moral right do creators have that they feel they can restrict music/movie/book/artwork as if the world still follows pure scarcity economics?
I also acknowledge that creators should be justly compensated for their works that I intend to use.
Re:Pirate Bay Founder Held In Solitary Confinement
by davidw on Sunday October 21, 2012 @01:42AM
(#4679100)
> I also acknowledge that creators should be justly compensated for their works that I intend to use.
There are a fairly limited number of ways that that can work:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#The_free_rider_prob...
I do think that filesharing should be legal, but the arguments you're making are losing ones. I think the real reason behind it relates to the purpose of copyright: http://zacharyalberico.com/day/2012/01/24
Apologies about linking to my own blog - but I wrote it up there so I don't have to rewrite it everywhere.