News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French tax on startups by snippyhollow on Saturday October 20, 2012 @08:40AM (#4676930)
I'm tired of this BS being spread by ppl who didn't even read the finances law in question (at least bullet points). It's not true, the 60% tax rate comes from the creation of a new bracket in the income tax and the treatment of selling your startup as income. To attain 60% you 1) need to sell for more than 150k 2) count all the acquisition money as instant revenue 3) do not intend to invest. And in fact, you have decreasing income tax if you sell assets you were bound to for 2 years (5%) and increasing up to 40% (on the 45% income tax...) for 12 years and more. If you invest 80% or more of the amount you earn, you don't have this tax, the same if you sell to retire... And don't even get me started on the "auto-entrepreneur" status which is a joke (that needs to end).
Re:French tax on startups by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 20, 2012 @09:57AM (#4677069)
VCs make nearly all their returns off a few big hits. So on the big hit, they will certainly:

1) make > 150k.

2) Sell out instantly, or at the very least in chunks considerably bigger than 150k. Even if they do sell out in 150k chunks, that will drastically reduce their returns - returns = log(outcome/investment)/t, so increasing t will lower returns.

3) Return the funds to investors.

Sounds like this law will, in fact, cut returns by roughly 50%. Or maybe 30% if the exit takes a long time.

Re:French tax on startups by fab13n on Saturday October 20, 2012 @12:28PM (#4677437)
VC are companies, not people, so what they earn is counted as benefits, not revenue. Moreover, in their P&L, they can subtract the L from their P, and average their money streams over several years.

There are legitimate issues with this law:

* it creates a lot of gratuitous bureaucracy and complexities, where you need to apply to some byzantine exceptions to the exception to the common law to keep a decent share of the wealth you produced; this kind of unproductive BS drives genuine entrepreneurs crazy and disincentivize them, probably more than the tax bracket in which they fall;

* it creates a very legitimate sense of insecurity among small businesses;

* it sends an overall message that France is not a startup-friendly environment, and that if you can help it, you should rather incorporate in another European country.

This last message is, unfortunately, very true: both the corporate and political French elites come from the same few schools, mostly ENA; so politicians have many executive friends in the private sector, but they all only worked in huge companies. They wish that the next Google would appear in France, but they can't realize that Google-like wealth creation never comes from dinosaurs on the scale of AT&T or GM (or Orange, or Peugeot). Moreover, this cluelessness is shared by conservatives and liberals equally.

Re:French tax on startups by ovi256 on Saturday October 20, 2012 @12:46PM (#4677495)
There is no conservative/liberals differenciation in France. All French senior politicians and civil servants have exactly the same life trajectory, are educated in the same school, ENA, and share the same values. There is a lot of opportunist movement from a party to another, showing that party ideology has zero weight.

PS: you may bring Nicolas Sarkozy as a counter-example. He, indeed, did not go to ENA because he failed to graduate from IEP Paris, which is a prerequisite.

Re:French tax on startups by dllthomas on Saturday October 20, 2012 @11:16AM (#4677252)
Institutional VCs will likely be able to account for the income such that they are, at least on paper, re-investing a good portion of the income.
Re:French tax on startups by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 20, 2012 @11:28AM (#4677276)
No. A VC fund invests each dollar precisely once and then attempts (over the next 10-15 years) to return those funds to investors when they cash out.

Maybe VCs in France will completely restructure their business to avoid this massive tax (presumably incurring lower returns in the process). Or maybe they will just invest outside France. Either way, this is not a small problem for them.

Re:French tax on startups by dllthomas on Sunday October 21, 2012 @01:21PM (#4680146)
Money is fungible and people are creative; My expectation is that, in the middle-run, that they will be make this no more than a small problem for them.

What are their investors doing with the money? If they intend to pile up a bunch of dollars and swim in it like Scrooge McDuck, then yes, that pile might shrink as a result of this law, but I expect that represents a relatively small fraction of institutional VC money.

As the parent said, if they sell to retire, the income isn't taxed so highly; if they sell to cash out of this investment and put (at least 80% of) it into something else, then the money is being reinvested, and hopefully can be handled as such in the accounting.

Re:French tax on startups by VSerge on Saturday October 20, 2012 @09:11AM (#4676982)
I did read the article 6 of the finances law on which my article comments. I'm unsure you have. I am sure however that you neither read my article, or any of the many explaining why this 60% top bracket is significant, ie for investors who are an essential part of the startup ecosystem, and make their money only on a few big hits with large payouts.
Re:French tax on startups by snippyhollow on Saturday October 20, 2012 @08:46AM (#4676941)
Let's be clear: I'm not agreeing with the government's policy (at least it's now not blatantly racist): I'm not agreeing with everything in the proposed tax scheme, I'm not agreeing with the entirety of the distribution of the spending, and I'm not agreeing with their lack on direction. I'm also not agreeing on bullshit being spread by a group of clueless persons on Facebook and being spread by rudebaguette and the like for clicks. If you want to tell tall stories, good for you, it can be interesting, you'll have plenty of stories to count because the combinatorics are gigantic, but don't call yourself a journalist. /rant
Re:French tax on startups by rdbgtt on Saturday October 20, 2012 @03:19PM (#4677978)
Thanks Gabriel Synnaeve for the great comment - it's a great example in how it's always cool to be for something, as long as you clarify that your not for it "the same way everyone else is."

The "bullshit" that we spread on Rude Baguette cites sources, so if you have a problem with the way they're being talked about, that's called a "spin." We also wrote that "bullshit" about 36 hours after the creation of the #geonpi fan page, because we felt the "bullshit" was worth talking about.

I don't think the blogger her, who also write for RB, is calling himself a "journalist," writing in the blog of his startup's website - at best he's expressing his opinion.

PS: ending a comment with "/rant" doesn't make it any more justified - although thanks for clarifying that it was written with no forethought, afterthough, or thought at all.

Yours Rudely,

-Liam Boogar Editor @ The Rude Baguette