I feel like apparmor is getting there, very, very slowly. Just need every package to come with a declarative profile or fallback to a strict default profile.
This is why my daily driver is https://qubes-os.org
>And today this is.. not sufficient. What we require today is to run software protected from each other. For quite some time I tried to use Unix permissions for this (one user per application I run), but it's totally unworkable. You need a capabilities model, not an user permission model
Unix permissions remain a fundamental building block of Android's sandbox. Each app runs as its own unix user.
Android sandboxing works in spite of the underlying security model, not because of it. It's also really selinux that does a lot of heavy lifting.
Re:The browser is the sandbox
by goodthenandnow on Monday January 26, 2026 @09:17AM
(#46765907)
Subthread from a while ago where I wrote some details on how Android sandboxing architecture uses Linux’s primitives:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40676309
Re:The browser is the sandbox
by nextaccountic on Tuesday January 27, 2026 @08:11PM
(#46789695)
I really want a desktop distro that is based on Android but can run normal desktop apps, fully isolated by default
Can Binder run on desktop, with some non-mainline kernel? Is someone maintaining such kernel with up to date patches?
Re:The browser is the sandbox
by nesarkvechnep on Monday January 26, 2026 @08:41AM
(#46765517)
There's FreeBSD's Capsicum. It's a full-blown sandboxing mode and capability framework. Unfortunately, Linux didn't adopt it and chose chaos.
Re:The browser is the sandbox
by mike_hearn on Monday January 26, 2026 @05:13PM
(#46772326)
Yes but systemd is a full blown sandboxing system, and he said the two working in concert.
And today this is.. not sufficient. What we require today is to run software protected from each other. For quite some time I tried to use Unix permissions for this (one user per application I run), but it's totally unworkable. You need a capabilities model, not an user permission model
Anyway I already linked this elsewhere in this thread but in this comment it's a better fit https://xkcd.com/1200/