I think there's evidence and studies on this. IIRC removing traffic lights forces people to be much more alert, reducing accidents.
Fun fact: Bhutan is perhaps the only country in the world without traffic lights!
No way this would work long-term in Germany. Maybe there wouldn't be that many more accidents but traffic would stutter, all the time, everywhere. Some safety-first drivers still don't get how roundabouts work ...
Afaict they have police officers regulating traffic instead. Not much difference in this particular discussion.
Things like that would probably break down at a certain level of crowded-ness, but it did somewhat change my view of regulation in general. I think there are a lot of cases where people will figure things out just fine if you leave them alone and count on them to be responsible, versus having a million detailed rules that are poorly enforced.
Cool! Did workers expect consequences for incidents? Did they get rewarded for lack of incidents?
Meaning, I imagine a world where there are no consequences for incidents and removing guardrails doesn’t lower incident rates because people aren’t incentivized to care?
Or you’re saying they naturally cared and removing guardrails allowed them to take ownership?
The issue with multiple dialogs is that the operator could claim that they were confused with conflicting wording and the implications of things like "Confirm" vs "Cancel" in certain contexts of use. This provides some degree of cover for moving with less care. With no dialog at all, the operator has nothing to point to but their own actions. There is nothing to hide behind.
The fact that this was also a heavily multi-lingual/cultural environment amplified the effect of poorly designed safety mechanisms dramatically.
My point is that the operator may be genuinely confused by a poor interaction model. Removing that interaction model entirely is certainly an option, but it's not clear that comparing "no dialog" vs "bad dialog" is a strong argument for "dialogs bad, better to have none" - you don't have data for the "good dialog" case, which may be better still.
Also, I was that obnoxious kid who, after asking someone a yes/no question, used to add "Yes/No/Cancel" (probably to highlight my perceived absurdity of that button).
UX Design is hard...
Kind of reminds me of parallels to not wearing a seatbelt making someone drive with more care.
In general, operator UX (HMI, human machine interface), is a an area that’s well researched and more or less standardised in recent times (ISA101). Abnormal Situation Management (ASM), Situational Awareness, automatic alarm suppression for “consequential alarms”, High Performance Graphics (basically everything grey except the stuff that matters). If your Engineers do a good job; the operators can do a good job.
Removing all interlocks sounds like a bit of a cop-out to me. Interlocks are there to prevent the mis-click pouring molten steel on peoples heads. If you have a nice boring standardized ASM HMI, operators can’t “hide behind them”. Every operation is the same.
To catch them all it logs the user out so buttons which affect the process are disabled, but now it can be annoying to be logged out after x minutes and always logging in.
Documented phenomenon:
> Risk compensation is a theory which suggests that people typically adjust their behavior in response to perceived levels of risk, becoming more careful where they sense greater risk and less careful if they feel more protected.[2]
Eventually, we tried removing the dialogs altogether and the incident rate approached zero. If you take away the guardrails completely, it radically alters the psychology and game theory around user interaction. Imagine climbing a tall building with multiple layers of protection vs having none at all.
I strongly believe in ideas like "safety 3rd". It's not that I want the humans to be maimed by the machines. Quite the opposite. The difficulty is in understanding higher order consequences of "safety" and avoiding the immediate knee-jerk satisfaction that first order resolutions may provide.