http://cgi.money.cnn.com/tools/costofliving/costofliving.htm...
107,798 in SF would be 73,278 in Minneapolis
At both Sun and NetApp where I was familiar with the compensation practices there was a 'modifier' applied to bay area jobs which increased their compensation, but even with the modifier the 'net' take home pay was less than it was elsewhere.
That said, when I was at Google they had a really interesting pay practice for engineers which consists of a base salary and a 'bonus', the bonus was affected by a personal multiplier and a company multiplier. The system was designed to make it impossible to figure out what the multipliers were so basically is simplified to the old fashion 'tweak the folks we like' non-accountability that you got elsewhere but it certainly gave the impression to people that they were going to earn more money than they actually did. (And yes, it annoyed me, but Lazlo Bock the VP of HR didn't really care that it did :-) Perhaps when they did that whole 10% across the board thing they normalized things a bit (which would have been a good thing, the old system was causing good people to quit when it should have been rewarding them)
One has to distinguish cost of living for a non-saver from cost-of-living for a saver.
Look, as someone said elsewhere, this is an impossible problem. You have too many factors to figure out. Have a family? Want to own a house instead of rent? Do you need a car? What lifestyle do you maintain?
The point here is that we're trying to assess what it would cost to maintain a similar standard of living in two different cities. Food. Transportation costs. Housing. Rents. Healthcare. Forget 52" TVs and trips to Paris for the time being.
>> what it would cost to maintain a similar standard of living in two different cities.
What is would cost to maintain a similar standard of living, when spending all of your money where you live. (like most families with kids :) )Someone who saves $20k/year or spends large amounts on travel would have a much higher standard of living in SF than Minneapolis.
"I have a wife and two kids. I want to own a 3 bedroom house with a yard. I need a car, and I drive 15,000 miles a year. We eat <x> number of meals at home each week, and <y> at restaurants. We do <z> things as a family including movies. This takes up 80% of our net income."
Okay, now what would that cost in Minneapolis, and what would that cost in San Francisco? That's all we're trying to ask.
The CoL calculators, as they're usually implemented, make the most sense for people with no real disposable income beyond living expenses, but they don't make a lot of sense for Google-level salaries.
Yes. This was my point.
> you shouldn't adjust for CoL any parts of your salary that will be spent on trips/vacations, or on nationally priced consumer goods.
Indeed, the real comparison of salaries should take into account what you plan to do with the income above the CoL. To the above I would also add that the interest on the rest of your cash stash (you don't plan to spend all of it on LCDs and trips?) is pretty much independent of where you live.
Anyone from CA want to chime on what state income and sales taxes are compared to the rest of the country?
That only helps if your raise percentage exceeds inflation. Otherwise, you could actually find yourself worse off. e.g:
$100K earnings + 2%
$50K living + 3%
--------------------
$59,756K after living expenses after 30 years.
$70K earnings + 2%
$20K living + 3%
--------------------
$77,177 after living expenses after 30 years. $70K + 5% [1]
$50K living + 3%
-----------
$2.5M saved after 30 years [2]
$70K for life
$20K living + 3%
-----------
$2.7M saved after 30 years
Even a decent rate may not be all it is cracked up to be.[1] For the first 15 years, whereafter you suggest it could plateau (at around $140K, in this case, which doesn't seem unreasonable given the current market and historic income increases)
[2] Assumes all non-living expense allocated income is invested at 5%.
Sounds like you have never worked for a large defense contractor. The "standard" raise given to ~70% of the engineers last year (my last review cycle working for that company) was 2.1%.
It might be true for large populaces, or big city areas, but the difference between say, Memphis, TN and Annapolis, MD is huge.
I got a 200% pay increase when I moved, only to find that the majority of it is consumed by the housing difference.
That means you were grossly underpaid and could likely get 2x increase just by changing employer and staying in Memphis.
It's also worth noting that I switched career paths at the same time and moved from a strictly engineering role to an enterprise architecture role.
Was it hard to find enterprise architecture position in Memphis?
With that, I decided to refocus my job search and someone I'd known years prior hired me on for a security-clearance required position in the federal government at a job I'd never done (but which he thought I was qualified for). Because of the customer, my contacts, and the cost of livings increases, I was paid a salary well above the "2012 average base salary" for a Google engineer per the linked article. Before that, I had made something like $60k.
Except for some very specialized positions (SAP, EMC, etc.) in Memphis, I don't know of any engineers making much above $100,000 (though indeed $100,000 in Memphis is a very respectable salary.)
Since leaving, I've had a number of Memphis-based employers trying to buy me back into the area, but the discussion generally dies when we get into money as, at least from my anecdotal experience, wages just aren't that high around there, and the only large paying employers are those who have successfully commoditized the market (FedEx, International Paper, etc.) and aren't hiring 'rockstars'.
In summation, while I'm sure there are people making what I make or above in my field in Memphis, it is by no means as common as a six figure salary in the valley, or bay area, or in places where there are large IT-based firms that are competing for talent. Even if there were, I wouldn't really have been qualified at the time - at least mentally, having taken a job I didn't feel qualified for and making absolutely damn certain I performed well at it made for interesting times, but ultimately boosted my overall confidence a million-fold.
Edit: I would also be remiss to add that at least amongst my peers, colleagues and family, I was doing fairly well. A lot of that had to do with the TN cost of living.
In 5 years from now, your buddy Joe is making ~127.6k, you are making ~89.3k. Joe has gained 8.3k more than you GAINED, (which is greater than the difference you pay in rent) So now Joe clears ~75k/year (after tax and rent), and you are clearing ~54.7k. The gap is only going to get bigger from there as time goes on, that's only after 5 years. You've GOT to think of money in terms of percentages, not just hard dollar values, or it's going to bite you.
I guess I am really just trying to stress the fact that people all too often see money from a liner point of view, when in fact it can be advantageous to explore the exponential growth side of money as well. That's all I really want to get out there. It's a balance between basing decisions on the known present or the unknown future.
Rent typically goes up every year, so the amount you're saving versus renting increases annually, and at the end of the "limited time" you're not paying a mortgage at all.
There's life outside of Palo Alto and SoMa.
I agree that telecommute could be the right choice. But then SF vs Minneapolis comparison is getting meaningless.
Notice how the salary adjustment jives with the CNN calculator too, this is because the cola takes into account the things that people need to spend their salary on, if you buy a vw microbus and sleep in the office parking lot every night and have minimal dining needs then you will notice an absolute difference between regions, otherwise you won't, the salary variance is eaten by the cost of all he usual things people do.
What matters is the amount of cash you're left with after you pay the actual cost of living. In this model, 20k/y raise is a 20k/y raise wherever you live, assuming you've already got the monthly balance positive. Of course it's still not the perfect metric but still much better than this bullshit.