News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:57PM (#4671313)
If the government was serious about cutting budget deficits, it would immediately discontinue the purchase of textbooks, switch to ereaders (there's a company in Europe selling basic eInk readers for £8), make use of out-of-copyright reading material, abandon the practice of lecturers performing the exact same lecture term after term when a recording will do, partner with companies like Coursera to provide curriculums, move towards homework and exams that can be marked by a computer rather than by hand... And generally just run education in a way that reflects the technology we have at our disposal.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by wpietri on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:27PM (#4671577)
Quick tip that took me years to learn:

If it looks like a bunch of apparently smart people are behaving like total idiots, A) I could be a genius, my brain overflowing with incredible insight into the nature of the universe, or B) I could have a too-simple understanding of what they get up to, and therefore be acting like an arrogant, know-it-all jackass.

State A does happen to me occasionally, but most of the time I think I'm in state A I'm actually in state B. I've now learned to keep my mouth shut for entire minutes at a time, which helps me reduce the frequency with which people realize I'm in state B.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by narrator on Thursday October 18, 2012 @08:07PM (#4671686)
State A does not mean you're a genius. It just means that you've made an error in determining what variable the actors in a sociological phenomenon are actually trying to optimize.

Find the thing that the sociological phenomenon is most effectively optimizing and work back from there to get to B. In the case of higher education it's optimizing the benefits to all those who are benefiting from the current system and not optimizing trying to educate the most people at the lowest cost which was your meta "too-simple" understanding of your understanding.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:35PM (#4671600)
or

C) there are massive, incumbent pressure groups obstructing changes in government spending practices

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by lambda on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:52PM (#4672199)
But more than that, there are laws, that were written perhaps in part due to pressures from these groups, but in part from all kinds of other pressures, which provide a lot of inertia for the way things are done.

Whenever there's some kind of education reform, it's usually to add stricter standards, because we're always falling behind in education and feel that stricter standards will help make sure that we don't. This means that textbooks need to meet stricter standards. Which mean that there needs to be some kind of review. Which means that someone needs to pay for that review. Which generally falls on the textbook publishers, or some overworked underpaid government committee. Which means that only a limited number of textbooks go through that review, locking out anything else which might be suitable but hasn't been reviewed to determine if it meets that standard.

The standards wind up changing every few years, so the textbooks need to be updated to match.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by jamesaguilar on Thursday October 18, 2012 @09:35PM (#4671906)
Quick tip I learned: avoid false dilemmas.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by redthrowaway on Thursday October 18, 2012 @08:05PM (#4671677)
> it would immediately discontinue the purchase of textbooks, switch to ereaders

Please no. I've found that eReaders are only good for novels, where there is a linear progression from start to finish. The inability to flip back and forth through the book, have two pages open at once, and the like is a serious downside when it comes to reading reference materials on an eReader.

It's not an insurmountable problem, but it is one that the current generation of eReaders quite frankly suck at.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by tangue on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:22PM (#4672027)
I second this one. I've bought lot of technical materials (Pickaxe, some CSS3 books) on my eReader (a Sony PRS T2) and eventually bought paper editions because it was more efficient. Was I conditioned by my previous learning experiences ? Maybe, but I found that eReaders are great for looking for a specific reference of something you've already seen, but for the process of learning, there is a king of serendipity that paper provides and eReader can't. IMHO even the web is a better learning medium than ebooks for this reason.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by krichman on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:12PM (#4672119)
Thirded. I've been trying to read technical papers on my Kindle and wow is it uncomfortable. Reading a novel is an absolute delight, though.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:16PM (#4671366)
> move towards homework and exams that can be marked by a computer rather than by hand...

Pretty much all of current homeworks and exams can be. It's called standarized tests, and I'd argue it's one of the reasons education sucks as much as it does.

Except from that one, where I think a move in opposite direction is desirable, I'd love for all the changes you mentioned to happen.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:27PM (#4671406)
Multiple choice is not ideal... but at the very least we shouldn't be employing teachers to tick these papers by hand when a computer could mark the pupils' answers instantaneously .

To be honest I don't think anything can be done to the 'education system' that will drastically improve the results. The bottleneck lies with the children (and their parents) and their thirst for knowledge (or lack thereof), which is a reflection of the culture and values they grow up with.

But what we can do is save a boatload of money on costs.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by munin on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:22PM (#4671559)
we already do this.

there's software that almost every higher ed university uses in their lower division courses to administer homework electronically. it grades the homework for the instructor and populates a gradebook. it's pretty hands off.

as far as I know, they have packages like this for every lower division STEM class. I used this software as late as multivariable calculus.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:37PM (#4671606)
what about in highschool and earlier?
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by jlarocco on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:39PM (#4671613)
I don't think "marked by computer" automatically means multiple choice "standardized tests".

English homework can't be graded by computer, but subjects like math, physics, and chemistry could conceivably be checked by computer. There'd be some details to work out, such as how to "show work", but it could work.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by garretruh on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:20PM (#4672017)
At least one (and almost certainly more) company pursuing this. The service WebAssign is used in almost every science class at my high school. 90% of homework is done (and graded) via the site. However, the lack of any "show-your-work" functionality sometimes limits teachers' ability to assist students.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by SilasX on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:37PM (#4675078)
There might be a way to make manual grading scale. Perhaps set up a cooperative system where students grade others' papers in return for grading of their own papers in another subject matter. By having a larger body of graders, you could have each paper viewed by several people, and it would check that the graders agree on its score (without communicating with each other or knowing how the other evaluated it).

It's just like using TAs, except with casting a much wider net, though a lot more details would need to be worked out.

Remember, you have the advantage that grading a paper is easier than writing one (in compsci terms, the former is in P, while the latter is NP-complete).

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by DanBC on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:28PM (#4671408)
recordings instead of lecturers? I'm not sure that's a great idea.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:42PM (#4671449)
I actually find it a vastly superior format. You can rewind the bits you don't understand clearly, or when your mind wandered off. In a live lecture, you do not have that luxury. In order to get maximum value out of a live lecture, you need to pay 100% attention to everything as it is said, and 100% understand each thing as it is spoken. Two rather unrealistic expectations, especially when lectures are usually cumulative, building one topic on top of the understanding of another.

Questions are also probably better handled with an online (or offline) forum and office hours. At any rate, I was never overly convinced about the 'interactive' benefits of the lecture hall.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by astrieanna on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:34PM (#4671424)
why not? There a much better uses of class time -- students asking questions or more engaging interactive activities. Just doing practice problems in class, where the professor is there to help, is a better use of class time than lecture.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by ig1 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:54PM (#4671481)
That's a terrible idea. You want to cut educational standards to save money ?

You'll save money in the short-term but in the long term you'll destroy your economy as you won't have the highly educated workforce that will be required to be a competitive economy in the future.

We should focus on high quality education first, whether that uses technology or not.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by kiba on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:14PM (#4671537)
What about GP's post that implies cutting down educational standards?
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by ajdecon on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:27PM (#4671575)
The objection was probably the post's implication that those technologies could manage all or most courses.

> switch to ereaders

Unless they're seeing different ereaders than me, that kills most detailed and colored diagrams in science textbooks. Also makes the experience worse in many geography, history, etc. courses.

> abandon the practice of lecturers performing the exact same lecture term after term when a recording will do

Recordings don't pause to answer questions mid-stream. A chat room or forum is probably good enough for upper-division courses where students have probably learned decent learning skills, but even freshman college courses probably need a human available at some point. Suppose they could be restricted to study sections...

> move towards homework and exams that can be marked by a computer rather than by hand...

There go essays and critical thinking questions in every literature class, to start with. Also a lot of the more useful evaluations in my engineering and science courses probably couldn't be marked by a computer.

To be clear: I think Coursera and similar efforts are awesome, and are an excellent supplement to college educations. I think they could also manage partial replacement of a minority of college courses. But especially with typical college students, who are not self-directed learners, I don't think it's the kind of replacement that will help budgets much.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by pjscott on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:38PM (#4671611)
> Recordings don't pause to answer questions mid-stream.

Recordings can be paused a hell of a lot more easily than a lecture for a large audience -- the format typical for heavy-enrollment basic classes in most colleges.

I realize that googling something may fall a bit short of the ideal, but it's better than just sitting there quietly because you don't want to interrupt everyone else in a huge room. Also, those aren't your only possible options; for example, students could time their lecture viewing to coincide with the office hours of a TA, and actually be much more able to get questions answered in mid-lecture. Or you could watch lectures with a study group, and talk through points of confusion with your groupmates. Or you could [fill in the blank here!]

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by wpietri on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:33PM (#4671591)
> Unless they're seeing different ereaders than me, that kills most detailed and colored diagrams in science textbooks. Also makes the experience worse in many geography, history, etc. courses.

Agreed! Worse, in my mind, is that e-readers are good mainly for linear access of read-only text; textbooks are much better at random access and user modification. I love my Kindle, but I think it sucks for books I'm trying to study seriously. Flipping back and forth between diagrams and text, jumping back to look at previous pages, putting in bookmarks, notes in the margins: all stuff paper is much better at.

And really, the price of textbooks isn't high because they're printed on paper. It's because textbooks are expensive to create, and many markets have a small number of suppliers, giving them crazy pricing power.

And now that I think about it, textbooks are a tiny proportion of what schools spend, which is in turn a small portion of government costs. So I now regret that we've all been fooled into wasting time on a proposal that makes no sense.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by mahyarm on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:01PM (#4672096)
Replace e-ink readers with tablets, which are the price of 1 textbook. Have 12hr tutor rooms where students can drop in and ask questions they are stuck about. Tutors can be paid less then professors and are far more convenient than lectures. That along with recorded office hours with professors for the harder courses would make an experience superior to most lecture style courses.

People would have to write down their questions while watching the lectures, could probably watch the lectures with fellow students in a TV room with the tutor room right next door in the library or right in the tutor room on their tablets.

TA-level pay grade markers would mark everything.

This wont work for everything, but it will work for the vast majority of courses. One building the size of a library with a combo study hall / cafe could probably cover the needs of an entire university.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by ig1 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:24PM (#4671565)
"use of out-of-copyright reading material" rather than the best material.

"homework and exams that can be marked by a computer rather than by hand" implying that we should only test (and thus only teach) skills that can be tested by computer rather than the skills that we want students to learn. Basically you'd be wiping out essay type questions (which test depth on knowledge) in favour of multiple-choice (which test breadth).

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Steko on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:18PM (#4671549)
Recorded lectures instead of live people who can answer questions?
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:28PM (#4671582)
Recorded lectures are better. Students/pupils can rewind things they missed or didn't immediately understand, can pause to refer to source material or look things up, watch the whole thing again, even rewatch previous lectures. They can still submit questions (forum, classroom, whatever) except now they wont be holding up the whole lecture.

And logistically, what happens with 'live people' is that some people ask their own questions, which the lecturer will make some attempt to answer. It's not like a lecture format somehow provides the interactive benefits of a 1-to-1 tutorial for every student in the audience simultaneously.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Steko on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:50PM (#4672075)
"Recorded lectures are better."

Cite? You can't just base this huge claim on some hand waving about how you can rewind and pause things. You need a study showing how wildly successful a school based on recorded lectures is compared to traditional lectures before you start leading all of society down these paths.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by bunderbunder on Friday October 19, 2012 @09:42AM (#4673459)
I could get behind using old textbooks and putting them on eReaders, though. At least in a targeted manner. My math department in college kept a bookshelf full of copies of texts they had used back through the early 20th century. It's kind of amazing to see how much more clearly-written calculus textbooks were in the 1940s. And the ones of that vintage that are still in print can be had for cheap - the sticker says I bought my copy of "Vector and Tensor Analysis" by Borisenko and Tarapov (part of the Dover Books on Mathematics series) for $7.

On the other hand, a biology book that old is going to be missing a whole lot of key stuff; probably even knowledge of the Krebs cycle was too new to be reliably appearing in school texts.

Perhaps instead educators could band together to produce open source textbooks.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Friday October 19, 2012 @01:34PM (#4674526)
Exactly. The contentions that

a) live lectures are crucial for the interactive element

b) the best, modern textbooks are necessary for acceptable education

sound reasonable but don't stand up to much scrutiny.

> Perhaps instead educators could band together to produce open source textbooks.

You would think there'd be more interest in 'spend once, solve forever' initiatives like that.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:15PM (#4671539)
Costs =/= Standards
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by aaronblohowiak on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:58PM (#4671318)
California is taking the lead in this, yet again.. http://www.clrn.org/fdti/
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by mangler on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:06PM (#4671342)
Thank you Terminator!!! We knew you'd do a great job!...
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by saraid216 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:27PM (#4671574)
Universities are not part of the government, fyi. They take money from the government, but the government's leverage consists of conditions on funding, standards for accreditation, and well... laws like this. If the changes you propose were written in law..., I think most people would agree that's a bad thing for many reasons.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by barry-cotter on Thursday October 18, 2012 @09:21PM (#4671870)
A distinction without a difference. I would be stunned to find out that more than 5% of US universities got a minority of their funding from the government , and who pays the piper calls the tune.

For my purposes state guaranteed and subsidised student loans count as they wouldn't happen without it and the restrictions placed upon which institutions' students are eligible are another example of government power over universities.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by saraid216 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:55PM (#4672088)
> For my purposes state guaranteed and subsidised student loans count as they wouldn't happen without it and the restrictions placed upon which institutions' students are eligible are another example of government power over universities.

"Power" is being used in such a wonderfully nebulous way here. The relevant power under discussion is decisions about infrastructure adoption and teaching methodologies. If you can point me to an instance where the government denied a university of students in order to keep them from adopting distance learning, I'll cede your point.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by barry-cotter on Friday October 19, 2012 @06:46AM (#4672973)
Nebulous? Sure. To be more explicit; I assume absent extremely syrong evidence that people and institutions rarely follow a pattern of pissing off those upon whom their livelihoods depend. There's a great Upton Sinclair quote to that effect but I'm on my phone. Again, who pays the piper calls the tune. Not saying there's a cabal deciding all this but ideologies need not be explicit to have power.

On an unrelated note, I don't expect to change your mind and while I'd be glad if you were to “cede the point” I do not argue with that aim in mind. Expecting to change your interlocutor's mind when you argue on the internet is the mark of a fool. This isn't lesswrong; most commenters aim to win arguments, not mote closely approach the truth. Arguing on the internet is for the rraders, the audience.

tokenadult will not be convinced by yummyfajitas that the US education system is excellent but every time he disses it yummyfajitas brings up the same excellent argument and tokenadult refuses to engage with it and makes ad hominem attacks and appeals to authority. To some people this does not seem like someone with the facts on his side.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by saraid216 on Friday October 19, 2012 @01:04PM (#4674390)
> I assume absent extremely syrong evidence that people and institutions rarely follow a pattern of pissing off those upon whom their livelihoods depend.

That's not remotely more explicit.

> On an unrelated note, I don't expect to change your mind... [snip]

So basically, you're using me as a foil. I understand. Fuck you.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by tzs on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:25PM (#4671396)
What about advanced courses? Almost nothing in an advanced math course, for instance, can be computer graded by current technology, or even technology reasonably on the horizon. For instance, in a number theory course, how would you handle grading a problem like "Prove that every prime number has a primitive root"? Would you dumb down the course to match the limits of grading technology?
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:34PM (#4671423)
No need to impose these ideas unilaterally. The ideal situation is to have hands-on, qualitative (for lack of a better word) tuition where there is no technological alternative.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by scarmig on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:06PM (#4671339)
All of those ideas are certainly good things. But even if they managed to decrease the eduction budget to $0, that wouldn't make a dent in government deficits (in the USA, at least, and I suspect elsewhere). They're driven primarily by unfunded entitlement spending and to a lesser extent by the military budget.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by dkokelley on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:25PM (#4671398)
I think you are confusing the federal and state governments. The federal government spends most of its budget on defense and entitlements. Only a smaller portion goes on to education (usually in the form of grants and subsidies to the state). Education happens at the state level. For example, California's proposed budget for 2012-2013 (http://www.ebudget.ca.gov/pdf/Revised/BudgetSummary/SummaryC...) spends $50 of the $141 billion total budget on education (k-12 and higher education). Compare that to the < 2% ($72 billion) that the US federal budget will spend in the department of education. (Note: Consider that California alone spends 5/7ths of what the federal government will spend on the department of education this year).

The parent's ideas for reforms are most applicable to state governments, since that's where most education spending happens. California is also in a pretty bad spot economically, so if it were possible to drastically reduce the cost of education (without impacting the level of service), it would significantly help our state's finances.

[Disclaimer: California is the largest state economy, and the relative education budget will vary between states.]

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 18, 2012 @09:42PM (#4671930)
As of 2010, we spent $1,038B on health care, $955B on pensions, $898B on education and $848 on defense.

The deficit was $1,293B, so education spending was a big chunk of it.

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/piechart_2010_US_total

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by peterhajas on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:12PM (#4671352)
Which company is making e-Ink readers for that cheap?
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:17PM (#4671370)
txtr http://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/txtr-beagle-8-kindle-rival-...

Not sure about all the details but the gist is you can make these things cheaper by stripping out some of the features that the Kindle has: built-in battery, wifi, 3G, lots of controls on the device.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:20PM (#4671382)
I'd love to get my hands on e-ink displays for < £8; I'd put them to great use. A replacement screen for Kindle costed me around $45 two months ago.
Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by asdfs on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:55PM (#4671483)
Same. It's unfortunate that there's seemingly no way to obtain e-ink displays directly from the manufacturers.

I don't know how txtr is managing to obtain such a low price point, though. 4GB of flash, a CPU, RAM, the display, the case, manufacturing costs, a bluetooth radio, and two AAA batteries seems extremely difficult to obtain for < $13. This is not including the price of manufacturing and shipping.

EDIT: Ah, I see. They've got their own book store, so they're hoping to recoup costs on that.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by polshaw on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:48PM (#4671466)
No one ..start of 2013 you will be able to get it with a mobile contract in the UK.. so not 8gbp and who knows why they banded about that figure then. Future looks bright, though.

FTA;

"The catch

You won’t be able to get the txtr beagle as a standalone product just yet. Instead the plan is to distribute it as an accessory on smartphone mobile phone contracts.

I can understand why txtr is taking this approach, after all it's reliant on a smartphone for transfers, but I'm still disappointed that txtr isn't brave enough to launch the product on its own.

Txtr hope to bring the product to the UK at the beginning of next year but were unable to comment on which mobile phone operators were in the pipeline to offer the device with their contracts."

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by wpietri on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:35PM (#4671601)
Excellent question.

Amazon's Kindle is being sold basically at cost. Amazon has incredible power to make suppliers dance, and they've spent years bringing the price of the Kindle down. So I don't think it's possible to make a decent e-reader significantly cheaper than the Kindle without subsidies.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by rubidium on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:37PM (#4671431)
Before you rage against the machine, a simple question wasn't answered in the article.

Could Coursera just apply to offer their services in the state of Minnesota? I mean, unless it is a terribly difficult process, I don't see the big deal here.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by ef4 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:02PM (#4671502)
> I mean, unless it is a terribly difficult process, I don't see the big deal here.

It quickly becomes a big deal as soon as other jurisdictions start doing the same thing. If I was Coursera I would definitely not want to go down that path. It takes away the key benefit of being on the web, which is the elimination of geographic barriers. Better to just be transparent and let your users see the absurdity for themselves.

Keep in mind that there's absolutely zero evidence that this regulation has any benefit. Clearly many other states are not enforcing this kind of law, and yet they're not demonstrably any worse off. This looks to me like a classic licensing scam: it probably got passed with the support of incumbents who wanted a higher barrier to entry.

Re:Minnesota Gives Coursera the Boot, Citing a Decades-Old Law by darkarmani on Friday October 19, 2012 @11:41AM (#4674005)
Why? They just solved the problem with a ToS update. Now it is in the hands of the voters.