News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by jmduke on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:17PM (#4670167)
This meme of 'anyone who is not a programmer is an idiot' has to stop. This is incredibly frustrating and severely undermines the level of discourse.
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by zmj on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:47PM (#4670366)
Most people are bad at making predictions. This is particularly true when they have incentives other than accuracy.

Programmers are not immune to that failure mode, but programming culture encourages data-driven decision-making and prizes empirical results.

Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by forensic on Thursday October 18, 2012 @04:43PM (#4671002)
> programming culture encourages data-driven decision-making

You have to be kidding.

Actuarial work, bioinformatics, social science. These are data-driven cultures. They actually require scientifically valid and methodologically sound data to make a claim.

Programming, on the other hand, is dominated by fashion. Language wars, methodology wars, business bullshit, buzzword chasing. Programming is not data-driven AT ALL! When was the last time a computer scientist actually did some SCIENCE? When was the last time a programmer actually ran a double blind study?

99% of programming is not data-driven whatsoever. The sweeping decisions in programming are made by corporate big wigs operating on their intuition, or are design choice (extremely subjective!) made by "architects" who, for instance, created UNIX.

Were the people who created Python, Ruby, Java, C, etc DATA-DRIVEN? What studies did they use to decide that so-and-so feature should be like this and not like this?

Programming is mostly a craft and has essentially nothing to do with being data-driven. Doing A-B tests does not mean your culture is data driven when A-B tests are like 0.1% of everything you do. And most A-B tests are methodologically unsound anyway and would be shamed out of any real social science department.

Economics, on the other hand, is an actual science with actual data that performs actual methodologically sound studies using advanced statistics. Practicing economists have to use actual valid data procured from real studies to have careers. Programmers mostly twiddle their bits around until something works. That IS NOT being data driven.

Programming is NOT a science.

Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by VikingCoder on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:01PM (#4671498)
Funny that you should say all of this in a discussion about Google...
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by rz2k on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:49PM (#4670710)
One of the most maligned professions when it comes to forecasts is meteorology. Nate Silver does and excellent job here, shedding some light on the challenges and triumphs of predicting the weather.[1]

Software engineering can involve difficult models about different scaling scenarios. Civil engineering might involve unexpected surprises about how standing waves emerge in bridge design. Financial analysis involves a forecast of the total revenue stream the company will generate between now and the end of time, and a guess about what other market players will predict about the future a quarter from now, since the stock price, too, can affect its income.

Take P/E ratios for example. Should you look at them as a sanity check, or think of them as a broad measure of the market's beliefs about the issue's future growth potential?

Regardless of where you stand, it is patently absurd to state that financial analysis is not data driven, and the decision making does not reward empirically successful results. Whether you recommend your fund bets with or against the market you get less of a say next time when you have less money left to bet, or decrease your assets under management by losing your clients' money.

[1] http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/09/why-weat...

Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by jamesaguilar on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:42PM (#4670324)
He seems to be saying, "people with idiotic beliefs are idiots." Nowhere in there are programmers mentioned or is any comparison to them made.
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by jarcoal on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:05PM (#4670447)
That's not really what he said at all.

He made the assumption that these analysts didn't do their job well, and that he in fact knows more about Google's financials/operations than they do.

The "programmer" remark jmduke made is just an assumption based on the fact that nearly everyone that uses this site is a programmer of some kind.

Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:29PM (#4670587)
That's still quite a leap when programmers are notoriously bad at predicting time scales. But prediction isn't the programmer's job.
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by jjtheblunt on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:35PM (#4670286)
I believe the meme is

"What _is_ a Wall Street analyst, and why are such considered credible?".

Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by EmergencyKnave on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:25PM (#4670211)
That's not what he said.
Re:Google Earnings Come Early; Shares Drop by jamesmcn on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:43PM (#4670339)
Nice try, analyst.