That’s not what my point was about though.
Fil-C of course can't magically fix your incorrect program. It never had any defined meaning, but the compiled executable does something and Fil-C will ensure that if the thing it does involves say, a use-after-free at runtime now it exits reporting the error, but it can't fix the fact it's nonsense, that's not their purview.
There's no point in hoping that somehow Programming Languages will overturn Mathematics. I mean, I can't blame you for trying, Bjarne Stroustrup is a professor and still seems to think that should be attempted, but it's futile. We're definitely talking "Why can't I extinguish the sun with water?" level thinking.
Obviously I can't speak to your own experience but for me certainly Rust is easier than C++.
Maybe you misunderstood my point?
Getting rust to a more complete state would be overturning mathematics here, as you note you can’t have both soundness and completeness.
What I say does not require overturning mathematics, ie allow unsound programs to compile but have different methods of catching them, both statically or dynamically.
The problem isn't directly with C++ choosing "All correct programs compile" but instead with the resulting incentive structure. Programmers want their program to compile.
In Rust the incentive is to improve the compiler, allowing more programs (all of them correct) to compile as with the NLL changes.
But in C++ the incentive is to loosen the requirements, allowing more programs (some of them incorrect) to compile, as with Concepts Lite in 2020.
They are doing the same to C. With gcc 15 all warnings are treated as errors.
"But, all my dependencies!" Fork them and fix the warnings. Flow the changes back upstream. Use your fork if they're not accepted. Don't buy libraries that compile with warnings, or demand your vendor fix them.
I've been writing c/c++ for a long, long time. The bugs that actually bite you are almost always logical and have little to do with things like a borrow-checker, ask cloudflare.
Exactly right!
I would bet that the more time you spend fighting the programming language and compiler, the less you are thinking about complex logic.
This is really the important distinction between C++ and Rust.
In my opinion, it seems easier to complement the former to catch issues afterwards (like this article) than it is to design a language that does not require you to jump through hoops to get something correct to compile.
I hope programming language design progresses to a state that makes my point invalid, but the “bro rust is easier than C++” gaslighting culture does not help.