News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by NewsaHackO on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:14AM (#46664971)
Is your argument that the quotes by the researchers in the article are not real?
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by taormina on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:21AM (#46665007)
What quotes? This is an AI summary that may or may not have summarized actual quotes from the researchers, but I don't see a single quote in this article, or a source.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by famouswaffles on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:35AM (#46665075)
Why are you commenting if you can't even take a few minutes to read this ? It's quite bizarre. There's a quote and repo for Cheeseman, and a paper for Biomni.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by WD-42 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:44AM (#46665114)
There is only one quote in the entire article, though:

> Cheeseman finds Claude consistently catches things he missed. “Every time I go through I’m like, I didn’t notice that one! And in each case, these are discoveries that we can understand and verify,” he says.

Pretty vague and not really quantifiable. You would think an article making a bold claim would contain more than a single, hand-wavy quote from an actual scientist.

Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by famouswaffles on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:07AM (#46665231)
>Pretty vague and not really quantifiable. You would think an article making a bold claim would contain more than a single, hand-wavy quote from an actual scientist.

Why? What purpose would quotes serve better than a paper with numbers and code? Just seems like nitpicking here. The article could have gone without a single quote (or had several more) and it wouldn't really change anything. And that quote is not really vague in the context of the article.

Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by inferiorhuman on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:21AM (#46665279)
Credibility. Why would I bother reading AI slop put out by a company who makes money off by convincing people to pay for AI slop?
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by inferiorhuman on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:39AM (#46665100)
Conflict of interest is a thing. The researchers could be AI hallucinations. The quotes could be too. Or the researchers could be real and intentionally saying things that are untrue. Who knows.

What is interesting is that HN seems to have reached a crescendo of AI fanboi posts. Yet if you step outside the bubble the Microsoft and Nvidia CEOs are begging people to actually like AI, Dell's come out and said that people don't want AI, and forums are littered with people complaining about negative consequences of AI. Go figure.

Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by simonw on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:19AM (#46665271)
Most people aren't software developers. The HN audience can benefit from LLMs in ways that many people don't value.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by bpodgursky on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:45AM (#46665116)
Are you accusing Anthropic of hallucinating an MIT lab under the MIT domain? I mean they literally link to it https://cheesemanlab.wi.mit.edu/
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by NewsaHackO on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:51AM (#46665149)
Honestly, it doesn't even seem they read the article, just came in, saw it was pro-AI, and commented.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by famouswaffles on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:47AM (#46665128)
You know things have shifted a gear when people just start flat out denying reality.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by inferiorhuman on Sunday January 18, 2026 @12:50AM (#46665141)
Anthropic puts out plenty of AI slop. I'll wait for a human who doesn't have a financial interest in propping up Anthropic to review the slop before passing judgement.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by falloutx on Sunday January 18, 2026 @04:30AM (#46666257)
And if you go to that site, the researchers say nothing about using Claude, or any LLMs for that matter.
Re:How scientists are using Claude to accelerate research an... by catlifeonmars on Sunday January 18, 2026 @02:54AM (#46665723)
The point is to look at who is making a claim and asking what they hope to gain from it. This is orthogonal to what the thing is, really. It’s just basic skepticism.

Even if the article is accurate, it still makes sense to question the motives of the publisher. Especially if they’re selling a product.