News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by noosphr on Thursday January 15, 2026 @06:54AM (#46631223)
Even the people who understand the scale don't understand the purpose.

The Chinese grid isn't renewable or non-renewable. It's built to keep the lights on for anything short of a thousand year catastrophe.

Their 2060 plan has enough non intermittent base load that they can run the whole country off it for a decade.

That half of your grid capacity is there 'just in case' is something no one in the west can wrap their head around. China building out massive solar and wind farms isn't because wind and solar are the future. It's because they can tick off their 30 year plan 25 years ahead of schedule and focus on the hard parts next.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by movedx on Thursday January 15, 2026 @07:16AM (#46631404)
I feel like energy is the most critical aspect to any economy and military. It's the beginning of anything and everything you want to achieve.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by kccqzy on Thursday January 15, 2026 @06:22PM (#46640894)
It totally is. I don’t remember where I heard it from but there’s a saying that all poverty is energy poverty. Not enough food for your citizens? That’s because you don’t have enough energy to run the Haber Bosch process for fertilizer production.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dfee on Thursday January 15, 2026 @06:31PM (#46640976)
short of the defense of energy infrastructure, of course.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by siscia on Thursday January 15, 2026 @08:35AM (#46632309)
What's the hard part?
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by noosphr on Thursday January 15, 2026 @09:02AM (#46632673)
Nuclear build out, wires and transformers.

China has been building 5% extra nuclear capacity every year for the last 30 years. On target for making up 24% of their energy mix in 2060.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dalyons on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:24AM (#46634947)
Everything I’ve read says their nuclear share is actually declining y/y, due to the crazy growth of renewables. I think that target is out of date?
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by subroutine on Thursday January 15, 2026 @04:30PM (#46639616)
If they build out wind and solar first then yes, the nuclear share will have declined year over year.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dyauspitr on Thursday January 15, 2026 @08:24PM (#46641882)
Declining because they’re building out everything else so rapidly. I believe they have 30+ reactors being actively constructed right now.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dalyons on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:31PM (#46643012)
Sure, I’m just pointing out that 24% share of power being nuke by 2060 is never going to happen now. Renewables got too cheap, and it’s not “on target”
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by noosphr on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:50PM (#46643095)
If I have zero wives yesterday and one today, by next week I will need a new house for all my new wives.

Like I said in the original post:

>Even the people who understand the scale don't understand the purpose.

>The Chinese grid isn't renewable or non-renewable. It's built to keep the lights on for anything short of a thousand year catastrophe.

Only capitalists are so penny wise and pound foolish to bet their civilization on the lowest bidder while hoping the inevitable doesn't happen in the next quarter.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dalyons on Friday January 16, 2026 @12:27AM (#46643295)
I agree with you, china is building risk mitigation in a way that no one else is, and it will serve them well. However, in this thread I’m solely replying to your comment on the “24% nuke by 2060” plan. That particular plan is not going to happen any more, nuclear is not competitive enough, even for china.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dyauspitr on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:11PM (#46649726)
I disagree. They’re not going to go the battery energy storage route, instead they will just fill in intermittent gaps in renewable electricity production with nuclear as they ramp down coal.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by _aavaa_ on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:21PM (#46649868)
But where is the evidence to back up this 4D chess move? They have been failing to meet their nuclear roll out plans year after year? Why would they magically hit a ridiculously high goal of 24% by 2060?
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dyauspitr on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:30PM (#46650020)
4D chess? This is not some memery. They’re essentially building out aiming for a 100% redundant capacity. Renewables and coal are much faster to build, nuclear takes longer (7 years for standardized ones, 10 for newer kinds).
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by jacquesm on Thursday January 15, 2026 @09:41AM (#46633165)
Climate change, and having an abundance of energy allows a country to offset some of those challenges.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by bobson381 on Thursday January 15, 2026 @09:21AM (#46632919)
Weathering the knock-on effects of ecological overshoot, probably. It's going to be interesting.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by phtrivier on Thursday January 15, 2026 @04:56PM (#46639909)
Demography. They're soon going to run out of "young" workers, which mean they have to invent the robotics of the 2100s to ensure the few remaining people will have machine to harvest crops and wage wars.

Also, they're soon going to run out of women, so they need to perfect artificial wombs.

The few remaining party elites will want to live practically forever, so biology will be on the programs once fusion and robots have been cracked.

And it doesnot even seem like china will make ussr-level mistakes.

Our only hope for beating China, at this point, would be to recreate an "opium wars" situation where the whole population becomes dumb and stop caring. (A bit like what tiktok and X are doing to use at the moment, but with much more social control.)

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by komali2 on Friday January 16, 2026 @09:17PM (#46654654)
> Our only hope for beating China, at this point, would be to recreate an "opium wars" situation where the whole population becomes dumb and stop caring. (A bit like what tiktok and X are doing to use at the moment, but with much more social control.)

Might be more accurate to say that the PRC has successfully done an opium wars situation to the USA with e.g. fentanyl precursors.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by Workaccount2 on Thursday January 15, 2026 @10:00AM (#46633468)
People worship China for being "green focused".

The reality is that they don't have a good source of fossil fuels, and energy independence is a core necessity.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dalyons on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:23AM (#46634912)
And thank god they have this incentive alignment! Chinas greentech buildout and export is the only thing with a chance of getting us out of this climate mess. Imagine how fucked we’d be if they had their own oil.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by protocolture on Friday January 16, 2026 @12:25AM (#46643283)
>And thank god they have this incentive alignment! Chinas greentech buildout and export is the only thing with a chance of getting us out of this climate mess. Imagine how fucked we’d be if they had their own oil.

IIRC that list of companies that polluted the most on the planet, 1 and 2 were Chinese state owned entities. China Coal and China Petroleum from memory.

OFC they are dwarfed IIRC by the US Military.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dalyons on Friday January 16, 2026 @12:50AM (#46643389)
sure. But today china is the #1 producer of solar panels (80% of global production capacity), #1 producer of wind turbines (40%), #1 producer of batteries (~80%), #1 producer of EVs (75%).

Noone has done more for global clean energy, and its not even close. Sure they polluted a lot up until now, but honesty who cares about the past, times change fast.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by protocolture on Friday January 16, 2026 @02:17PM (#46650797)
Oh I dont care so much. Its more that:

A. Where would we be without China, well with a significantly reduced problem. But they are doing their part and doing it well.

B. That list gets used as a bludgeon against free enterprise and a great deal of the entities on the list dont represent free enterprise.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dahart on Thursday January 15, 2026 @10:20AM (#46633728)
The trend is clear that if we keep using fossil up, then soon nobody will have a good source for it. And it’s clear that for geopolitical reasons in addition to environmental reasons, energy independence will be a core necessity everywhere on earth. It’s handy that the sun is sending us enough energy, directly (solar) and indirectly (wind, hydro), that nobody has a good reason not to be “green focused” and phase out fossil fuels for energy. Any country that leads and shows the rest of the world that it can be done deserves applause.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by chaostheory on Thursday January 15, 2026 @10:48AM (#46634251)
Who is going to pay for it? Even when it was cheap, solar uptake was low except in Texas. EV adoption is still poor outside of California. Then there’s the issue of a K Shaped economy. Outside of our bubble in Silicon Valley, a lot of people can barely afford necessities let alone go green.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by triceratops on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:04AM (#46634565)
China isn't "going green" to go green. They're doing it because it's cheaper.

The elites are pinning us to fossil fuels and driving up the cost of necessities.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by dahart on Thursday January 15, 2026 @12:57PM (#46636464)
You might be confusing consumer purchasing choices with the national energy policy and infrastructure we were talking about. Going green personally is only more expensive to consumers in places where our country isn’t building and offering green power by default. EVs are a bit of a different topic. But what difference does it make when fossil fuels run out? Left unchecked, sooner or later market forces will make oil much more expensive as it becomes scarce, and eventually there is no choice. Yes we might be decades or even hundreds of years away from that, but in the big picture that’s not far away, and it doesn’t matter because the eventuality is obvious. Eventually there will be no such thing as non-renewable energy. Might as well start now.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by reeredfdfdf on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:47AM (#46643707)
Solar panels are being built like crazy in really poor developing countries like Pakistan, simply because it's cheaper than the alternatives. If they can afford it, average American surely should too.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by ahartmetz on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:02AM (#46634514)
They have a large coal mining industry.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by Workaccount2 on Thursday January 15, 2026 @11:11AM (#46634694)
And consume 50% of global coal production.

But coal is the worst fossil fuel from a practical stance. It's really only good for energy generation. You can't really power tanks or warships with it.

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by ahartmetz on Thursday January 15, 2026 @02:15PM (#46637634)
Oh, you can convert coal to liquid fuels if you have to. Germany produced low single digit millions of tons per year during World War 2.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bergius_process

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_proces...

Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by eunos on Friday January 16, 2026 @06:15AM (#46645273)
Something something Black cat or white cat, doesnt matter as long as it catches mice.
Re:Photos Capture the Breathtaking Scale of China's Wind and... by ramesh31 on Thursday January 15, 2026 @04:11PM (#46639377)
>That half of your grid capacity is there 'just in case' is something no one in the west can wrap their head around.

It sounds like the typical wastefulness of central planning to me. That overcapacity comes at a great opportunity cost for development elsewhere in the economy.