The stated goal of patents is not a moral imperative to protect inventors, but rather an economic hack that is meant to incentivize invention for the benefit of society, only benefitting inventors as a side effect. The fact that it is achieving the opposite of its goal means that an ethical discussion is worth having, but mostly irrelevant (see also: the Drug War).
If you tried to abolish intellectual property the main opposition wouldn't be parties whose main motivation would be a genuine concern that you'd be de-incentivizing invention for the benefit of society, but rather parties who have a vested interest in the current system for their own benefit.
E.g. trademark law supports the existence of the advertising industry, by creating protectable brands through restrictions on speech. Most web companies wouldn't exist in their current form if there wasn't a tremendous incentive for companies to build up those protectable brands through advertising.
As it turns out, one can make an argument that copyrights/trademarks can be reformed, but patents cannot. The difference is that no one can accidentally "trip" over a sensibly defined copyright or trademark, whereas patents are intrinsically a legal landmine -- people can and often do accidentally infringe.
Second, you can accidentally infringe on a trademark, and can be prevented from using a trademark even if you came up with the term independently.
Third, there is no reason why you couldn't add an "independent invention" defense to patent.
Fourth, you have no basis for your claim that people "often" accidentally infringe patents.
- Second, I am not referring to trademarks as presently defined.
- Third, requiring someone to prove their innocence violates one of the most basic principles of ethical justice.
- Fourth, it is irrelevant to this discussion how often it is, but clearly, 40,000 software patents filed per year constitutes a lot of opportunity for infringement. If you are doing something meaningful and interesting, you are likely violating a patent. But again, this point is not essential to the main issue.
I don't think I follow what you're trying to say. My point is that whether something can be accidentally infringed or not is a weird criterion to use to separate ethical and unethical restraints on free expression. We create civil liability for lots of things that happen on accident. I think the ethical discussion, if there is one, centers on whether these restraints on free expression or valid in the first place.
> Second, I am not referring to trademarks as presently defined.
You said that trademarks/copyright could be distinguished from patent based on accidental infringement. You could define trademarks in a way where accidental infringement didn't create liability, but you could define patents that way too. Neither are defined that way presently.
> Third, requiring someone to prove their innocence violates one of the most basic principles of ethical justice.
I'm not sure what 3rd grade reading level principles of ethical justice you're talking about. We require defendants to prove certain affirmative defenses all the time, generally in cases where something is unlikely to have occurred without wrongdoing. E.g. if you kill somebody in self defense, you're obligated to at least present evidence that it was in self-defense. And of course we're talking about civil litigation here, not criminal litigation. "Innocence" is the wrong terminology.
> Fourth, it is irrelevant to this discussion how often it is, but clearly, 40,000 software patents filed per year constitutes a lot of opportunity for infringement. If you are doing something meaningful and interesting, you are likely violating a patent. But again, this point is not essential to the main issue.
I'm not the one who said that people "often" accidentally infringe patents, you were.
The dichotomy between civil and criminal is irrelevant. You don't get to burden your fellow citizens with arbitrary hoops to jump through and also call yourself ethical. An ethical person leaves others alone unless these others violate your basic rights. And if they do, then the burden is on you to prove they did, not on them to prove they didn't.
So the burden of proof principle applies here, as it should everywhere else in the law. Of primary concern here is the burden of proof that advocates of patents have on proving that the alleged patent violator deserves to be interfered with, blocked, fined, etc. They have not met this burden. Ergo they do not have an ethical right to enforce patents.
It is very relevant. What is "ethical" in the context of civil and criminal cases is very different. For example, in criminal cases a conviction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. A lesser standard is considered unethical. In a civil case, the bar is lower--proof by a preponderance (simple majority) of the evidence.
> You don't get to burden your fellow citizens with arbitrary hoops to jump through and also call yourself ethical.
"Affirmative defense" does not mean that defendants are picked at random and forced to prove they didn't do anything wrong. It means that defendants must make a credible evidentiary showing in defense after the plaintiff has already presented evidence suggesting wrongdoing.
Whether you make something an affirmative defense or an element of the case in the civil context isn't about ethics, it's about statistics. So long as granted patents aren't trivial (and that's a separate issue), it's unlikely that someone would infringe on it accidentally. Given that, there is nothing unfair about making the defendant present evidence about why that unlikely accident did in fact happen. The plaintiff still bears the burden of proving that, however.
This is not evidence for your contrary stance, it's merely repeating the status quo: "For example, in criminal cases a conviction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. A lesser standard is considered unethical. In a civil case, the bar is lower--proof by a preponderance (simple majority) of the evidence."
You're playing an absolutely ridiculous game of "hide the ball" here. In your head you clearly have some specific assumptions about what is "ethical" but you're not forthcoming with those assumptions. Instead, you claim I'm being dishonest for not divining the hidden rules you've laid out in your own head.
I'm going to guess you're some sort of libertarian or possibly anarchist, playing the usual game of implicitly arguing from a non-mainstream value framework without acknowledging that to be the case, then getting upset at people for not acknowledging your unstated unconventional beliefs.
And in fact, no patents are legitimate. Worse than that, most people's concept of "legitimate" is not legitimate. What most people seem to have banned from their thinking is anything close to resembling a ethical argument. Just because something is legal, does not make it ethical. That reverses the true order: what inherently flouts the ethical underpinning of law must not be made legal. E.g., one should never legalize rape, to make rape legal does not change the fact that it is unethical to make rape legal.
But typically, whenever you try to offer anyone an ethical argument concerning patents, it goes straight over their head. They've been conditioned to think that whether patents are legal or not is an entirely pragmatic decision having nothing to do with ethics but only with economics. And so the mayhem continues...