News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by stuartjohnson12 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:05AM (#46575875)
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/rarcxjGp47dcHftCP/your-llm-a...

Hi author, this isn't personal, but I think your AI may be deceiving you into thinking you've made a breakthrough.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by usefulposter on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:36AM (#46576092)
Fascinating. Searching https://hn.algolia.com for "zenodo" and "academia.edu" (past year) reveals hundreds of similar "breakthroughs".

The commons (open access repositories, HN, Reddit, ...) is being swamped.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by stuartjohnson12 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:50AM (#46576189)
Since OpenAI patched the LLM spiritual awakening attractor state, physics and computer science is what sycophantic AI is pushing people towards now. My theory is that those things tend to be especially optimised for deceit because they involve modelling and many people can become confused between the difference between a model as the expression of a concept and a model as in the colloquial idea of "the way the universe works".
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by cap11235 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:53AM (#46576217)
I'd love to see a new cult form around UML. Unified Modeling Language already sounds LLMy.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @10:08AM (#46576351)
'The Church of UML' does have a certain ring to it. But that’s exactly the trap I’m trying to avoid.

The reason JTP focuses on the 'Ghost'—the traces of what the model rejected or what was lost in translation—is to prevent exactly that kind of cult-like devotion to the output. A cult forms when you forget the model is just a map.

I’m not interested in worshipping the map; I’m interested in ensuring that when the machine draws it, we can still see the ink on our own hands. If we can't see the delegation, we can't see the deceit. That’s the 'sovereignty' part of Cognitive Sovereignty.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by amarcheschi on Sunday January 11, 2026 @10:13AM (#46576395)
it's all ai allucination, in a subreddit i once found a tailor asking for how to contact some professors because they found a breakthrough discovery on how knowledge is arranged inside neural networks (whatever that means)
[dead]
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by stuartjohnson12 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:24AM (#46576014)
In the essay I linked, there are some instructions you can follow to test out the idea under "step 1". It's really important to follow them exactly and not to use the same ChatGPT instance as you're talking to about this idea so we can test with an independent party what is going on. I'd be curious what the output is.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:53AM (#46576214)
I took the challenge. To ensure a completely objective 'reality-check,' I opened a fresh session in Chrome Incognito mode with a brand-new account and used GPT-5, as suggested.

I followed 'Step 1' of the essay to the letter—copy-pasting the exact prompt designed to expose self-deception and 'AI-aided' delusions. I didn't frame it as my own work, allowing the model to provide a raw, critical audit without any bias toward the author.

https://chatgpt.com/share/6963b843-9bbc-8001-a2ea-409a5f6dd6...

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by stuartjohnson12 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:54AM (#46577341)
Awesome - now read it really closely and compare it to the version of reality in your OP. And DON'T paste it or this comment into your normal ChatGPT instance and ask it to respond. Really just think for a moment on your own.

> The goal: replace vague legal and philosophical notions of “manipulation” with a concrete engineering variable. [...] formally define the metric

What's the conclusion? Is this a "concrete engineering paper"? Has anything been "formally proved"? From your link:

> The math is conceptual, not formal.

> This is serious, careful, and intellectually honest work, but it is not conventional science.

> The project would be strongest if positioned explicitly as foundational theory + open design pattern, rather than as something awaiting “validation.”

> it is valid as a design pattern or architectural disclosure, not as experimental systems research

Be careful before immediately dismissing this as just imprecise language or a translation issue. There's a reason I suggested this to you.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @12:08PM (#46577489)
You are right. This isn't a scientific paper in the conventional sense. It is a proposal of a framework for the co-evolution of AI and humanity. My intention from the beginning has been to bridge the gap between abstract agency and concrete engineering. I am simply trying to bring this Constitution for human agency into the light, utilizing whatever platforms I can to ensure it is discussed.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by stuartjohnson12 on Sunday January 11, 2026 @01:11PM (#46578025)
This is a huge break from the original post you made - take a step back and compare the two. The LLM is tricking you again into thinking that it wasn't trying to make a claim about the world. In the original post, the LLM was causing you to use language like "quantify", "formal proof" and "concrete engineering" to describe what you'd come up with and position it as a mathematical/computational/engineering idea. It wasn't that.

Now that you got some outside input, it's reframing it for you as an abstract philosophical/legal/moral concept, but the underlying problems are the same. The reason it's talking to you using high level abstract words like "concept" and "proposal" and "framework" now is because the process you just went through - the "step 1" - beat back its potential to frame the idea as a real model of the world. This may feel like just a different way to describe the same idea, but really it's the LLM pulling back from trying to ground the concept in the world at all.

If you're continuing to talk to the LLM about the idea, it's going to try and convince you that really this was a moral/theory of mind discovery and not a mathematical one all along. You're going to end up convinced of the importance and novelty of this idea in exactly the same way, but this time there are no pesky ideas like rigor or testability that could falsify it.

If you ask ChatGPT about this comment without this bit I'm writing at the end, it'll tell you that this is fair pushback, but really your work is still important because really you're not trying to write about engineering or philosophy directly, but rather something connecting these two or a new category entirely. It's important you don't fall for this because exaggerating the explanatory power of pattern recognition is how ChatGPT gets you. Patterns and ideas exist everywhere, and you should be able to identify those patterns and ideas, acknowledge them, and then move on. Getting stuck on trying to prove the greatness of a true but simple observation will lead you to the frustration you experienced today.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @06:59PM (#46581914)
The repository logs make it clear that this framework was conceived as a "constitution" long before this conversation ever took place.

I didn't "retreat" to the idea of a framework because the scientific argument failed. On the contrary, I designed the engineering variables specifically to give that framework "teeth." My goal isn't to prove a "simple observation"—it is to provide a functional architecture for human agency that conventional science, in its current state, is failing to protect.

https://github.com/daiki-kadowaki/judgment-transparency-prin...

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @07:19PM (#46582074)
One last thing: make no mistake. I didn't start with an algorithm. I built the algorithm out of necessity, purely to ensure that my 'Constitution' would never be dismissed as mere empty theory. The architecture exists to give the vision its teeth.

But I’m done now. I’ve realized that having a meaningful dialogue with the world at this stage is harder than I thought. I’ve planted the seeds in the network. Now I’m walking away. When the future unfolds exactly as I’ve predicted, just remember this moment.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by thunfischbrot on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:24AM (#46577055)
That’s not too bad and mirrored some of the feedback in this thread. Tldr: interesting idea, more worthy of a blog post or a thread in one of your favourite online communities, rather than a paper.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by durch on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:19AM (#46575982)
If you have a few minutes I invite you to check what we're doing over at Open Horizon Labs, its exactly the type of thinking we have around the current state of the world. Apologies I feel like I'm stalking you in the comments, but what you're saying absolutely resonates with what I've been thinking, and what I've been trying to build, and its refreshing to finally feel that I'm not insane.

https://github.com/open-horizon-labs/superego is probably the most useful tool we have, but I'm hoping that we can package it and bring it to the people, as it does make all these LLMs orders of magnitude more useful

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @09:58AM (#46576257)
No apologies needed—I'm just glad to find I'm not the only 'insane' person here. It's easy to feel that way when obsessing over these problems, so knowing my ideas resonate with what you're building at superego is a huge relief.

I’m diving into your repo now. Please keep me posted on your progress or any new thoughts—I'd love to hear them.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by judahmeek on Sunday January 11, 2026 @06:33PM (#46581703)
> as it does make all these LLMs orders of magnitude more useful

That seems like something that should be really easy to prove statistically.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @07:01PM (#46581931)
As for "proving it statistically"—you're looking for utility, but I'm defining legitimacy. A constitution isn't a tool designed to statistically improve a metric; it is a framework to ensure that the system remains aligned with human agency. I am not building an LLM optimization plugin; I am building a benchmark for human-AI co-evolution