News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously ... by oh_my_goodness on Saturday January 10, 2026 @11:58AM (#46567417)
Everyone has a different perspective, based on their math background. From the OP's perspective, this was apparently worth talking about. On the other hand, for you it's just a homework problem that belongs in an intro class.

Please try to accept that OP may not be at your level in math, and be generous about that.

Re:"Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously ... by ndriscoll on Sunday January 11, 2026 @07:56AM (#46575345)
My comment was exactly about the required math background though. Anyone who's completed an intro to proof class would find that kind of statement easy to formalize because they would have had to write similar statements for homework. That provides some context: everyone who's interested in computer theorem provers probably has some experience with proofs, so formalizing that statement should be easy for them. i.e. (for this kind of problem) it's not really "the hard part" for people who are seriously working on this stuff.
Re:"Erdos problem #728 was solved more or less autonomously ... by oh_my_goodness on Monday January 12, 2026 @08:34AM (#46588262)
I think it's reasonable to ask whether LLMs formalize theorems correctly. And I'm not sure that saying "this one is easy" answers that question.