Re:He was called a 'terrorist sympathizer.' Now his AI compa...
by w1nt3rmut3 on Friday January 09, 2026 @03:31AM
(#46551365)
Being against zionism means being against the state of Israel as a whole? Is this correct? So the state should no longer exists?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:He was called a 'terrorist sympathizer.' Now his AI compa...
by skrebbel on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:08AM
(#46551650)
I think most people who say they are against Zionism, I think Paul Graham included, mean they are against the claim of many present-day self-proclaimed Zionists that the entire area is the God-given promised land for the Jews, ie all Arabs should magically disappear from Gaza, the West Bank and beyond. As far as I can tell, a sizeable minority of Israelis support this ideology.
Nevertheless, IMO it's unwise use the word like that, when you're opposed to the settlements and the genocide and so on, because "Zionism" used to just mean to want for Israel to exist at all. That means pro-Israel leaning people will always misinterpret you as saying you want the state of Israel to end and all the Jews to magically disappear. It's like waving a banner with "from the river to the sea". Don't do it! (unless you actually want the state of Israel to end and all Jews to magically disappear of course, in which case I find you exactly as deplorable as the extreme right expansionist Israelis)