News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by emil-lp on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:02PM (#46545706)
Okay, who's gonna write the story

> The unreasonable effectiveness of The Unreasonable Effectiveness title?

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by observationist on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:57PM (#46546360)
Unreasonable effectiveness is all you need.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by temp123789246 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:32PM (#46546793)
I lol’d
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by nextaccountic on Thursday January 08, 2026 @05:04PM (#46547133)
"Unreasonable effectiveness is all you need" considered harmful
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by Nevermark on Thursday January 08, 2026 @05:11PM (#46547215)
Don’t let unreasonable effectiveness become the enemy of reasonable effectiveness.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by AlienRobot on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:43PM (#46548127)
A closer look at unreasonable effectivenessness.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by cbracketdash on Thursday January 08, 2026 @11:08PM (#46549939)
A rigorous study of the "unreasonable effectiveness" method.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by Qem on Friday January 09, 2026 @05:34AM (#46552307)
Why Johnny can't be unreasonably effective?
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by alberto_ol on Friday January 09, 2026 @11:55AM (#46555901)
What we talk about when we talk about the unreasonable effectiveness
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by cbracketdash on Thursday January 22, 2026 @09:54PM (#46727782)
Reasonable effectiveness: an alternative to unreasonable effectiveness
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by ggm on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:34PM (#46549770)
News at 11
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by tsoukase on Saturday January 10, 2026 @03:37AM (#46563935)
"Unreasonable effectiveness is the root all evil"
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by greenwallnorway on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:01PM (#46548282)
I did some analysis on top title patterns. Both of these make the list pretty handily: https://projects.peercy.net/projects/hn-patterns/index.html
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by tgv on Friday January 09, 2026 @06:06AM (#46552567)
Funny. You might want to do that modulo capitalization, and perhaps some other common substitutions (LLM/LLMs/Large Language Model/Large Language Models, it's/ it is, what's/what is, I am/I'm), but they change the number of words, so better opt for the shortest alternative.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by chaboud on Friday January 09, 2026 @04:08AM (#46551655)
Someone will end up writing "Scholastic Parrots"...
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by threethirtytwo on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:54PM (#46546323)
The Unreasonable Effectiveness of LLMs.

Ironically a very relevant and accurate title.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by tverbeure on Thursday January 08, 2026 @05:05PM (#46547148)
Not at all relevant in those instance because the blog post was not LLM generated slop.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by jmyeet on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:26PM (#46545994)
How about The unreasonable effectiveness title considered harmful?
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by seba_dos1 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:49PM (#46546245)
The unreasonable effectiveness of considering something harmful.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by pizza on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:44PM (#46546917)
Lies, Damned lies, and Unreasonable Effectiveness
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by rbonvall on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:21PM (#46547933)
Lies, Damned lies, and Unreasonable Effectiveness For Fun and Profit
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by flufluflufluffy on Thursday January 08, 2026 @08:03PM (#46548827)
Lies, Damned Lies, and Unreasonable Effectiveness: How Lies in Titles are Damn Near Unreasonably Effective
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by bitwize on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:47PM (#46546224)
Coming up next on Hackernews:

Why "The \"Unreasonable Effectiveness\" Title Considered Harmful" Matters

The Unreasonable Effectiveness of "\"Why \\\"The \\\\\\\"Unreasonable Effectiveness\\\\\\\" Title Considered Harmful\\\" Matters\" Considered Harmful"

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by BrokenCogs on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:48PM (#46546236)
"The unreasonable effectiveness" is all you need
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by cubefox on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:22PM (#46545938)
It's a play on the famous essay 1960 "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences".

I agree this is getting old after 75 years. Not least because it seems slightly manipulative to disguise a declarative claim ("The Fourier transform is unreasonably effective."), which could be false, as a noun phrase ("The unreasonable effectiveness of the Fourier transform"), which doesn't look like a thing that can be wrong.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by flufluflufluffy on Thursday January 08, 2026 @08:01PM (#46548813)
Also how most of the articles with this kind of title (those posted on HN at least) are about computation/logical processes, which are by definition, reasonable.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by kingkongjaffa on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#46545777)
Agreed, these kind of titles are very silly.

FTs are actually very reasonable, in the sense that they are a easy to reason about conceptually and in practice.

There's another title referenced in that link which is equally asinine: "Eugene Wigner's original discussion, "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". "

Like, wtf?

Mathematics is the language of science, science would not compound or be explainable, communicable, or model-able in code without mathematics.

It's actually both plainly obvious for mathematics then to be extremely effective (which it is) and also be evidently reasonable as to why, ergo it is not unreasonably effective.

Also the slides are just FTs 101 the same material as in any basic course.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by jwise0 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:20PM (#46545907)
Hi, original presenter here :) The beginning is FTs 101. The end gets more application-centric around OFDM and is why it feels 'unreasonably effective' to me. If it feels obvious, there's a couple of slides at the end that are food for thought jumping off points. And if that's obvious to you too, let's collab on building an open source LTE modem!
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by slwvx on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:56PM (#46546344)
If one wants to contribute to an open-source LTE modem, the best place to start may be OpenLTE: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenLTE The core of any LTE modem is software, even if it is written for DSPs or other low-level software.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by Certhas on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:46PM (#46546218)
I find it hard to parse the middle of your post. Are you saying Wigner's article, which is what all the "unreasonable effectiveness" titles reference, is silly?

If that is what you are saying I suggest that you actually go back and read it. Or at least the Wiki article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unreasonable_Effectiveness...

By means of contrast: I think it's clear that mathematics is, for example, not unreasonably effective in psychology. It's necessary and useful and effective at doing what it does, but not surprisingly so. Yet in the natural sciences it often has been. This is not a statement about mathematics but about the world.

(As Wittgenstein put it some decades earlier: "So too the fact that it can be described by Newtonian mechanics asserts nothing about the world; but this asserts something, namely, that it can be described in that particular way in which as a matter of fact it is described. The fact, too, that it can be described more simply by one system of mechanics than by another says something about the world.")

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by kingkongjaffa on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:09PM (#46546511)
Yeah it's silly, I don't mean it in any mean spirited way.

> Wigner's first example is the law of gravitation formulated by Isaac Newton. Originally used to model freely falling bodies on the surface of the Earth, this law was extended based on what Wigner terms "very scanty observations"[3] to describe the motion of the planets, where it "has proved accurate beyond all reasonable expectations."

So despite 'very scant observations' they yielded a very effective model. Okay fine. But deciding they should be 'unreasonably' so is just a pithy turn of phrase.

That mathematics can model science so well, is reductive and reduces to the core philosophy of mathematics question of whether it is invented or discovered. https://royalinstitutephilosophy.org/article/mathematics-dis...

Something can be effective, and can be unreasonably so if it's somehow unexpected, but I basically disagree that FTs or mathematics in general are unreasonably so since we have so much prior information to expect that these techniques actually are effective, almost obviously so.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by Certhas on Friday January 09, 2026 @03:48AM (#46551498)
I am not discussing the FT case. But as regards Wigner's article, the core thing he points out is that while we are used to the effectiveness of maths, centuries after Newton, there in fact is not any prior grounds to expect this effectiveness.

And no, this is unrelated to whether math is invented or discovered. If anything this is related to the extreme success of reductionism in physics.

As a general point of reflection: If an influential article by a smart person seems silly to you, it's good practice to entertain the question if you missed something, and to ask what others are seeing in it that you're missing.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by staticshock on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:48PM (#46546231)
It is likewise unreasonable to look down on any kind of world model from the past. Remember that you, in 2026, are benefitting from millions of aggregate improvements to a world model that you've absorbed passively through participation in society, and not through original thought. You have a different vantage point on many things as a result of the shoulders of giants you get to stand on.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by redhed on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:39PM (#46546145)
It is pretty funny to flippantly call an influential paper by someone who received a Nobel Prize in Physics 'asinine'.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by groby_b on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:50PM (#46546264)
I mean... this one's actually a pretty good paper, but we also had Linus Pauling pontificate on Vitamin C, so maybe we should cool it with the appeals to Nobel authority alone.
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by srean on Friday January 09, 2026 @07:33AM (#46553192)
He did have a very long life, so there's that.

It's not easy to separate cause and effect from direct and strong correlations that we experience.

The job of a scientist is not to give up on a hunch with a flippant "correlation is not causation" but pursue such hunches to prove it this way or that (that is, prove it or disprove it). It's human to lean a certain way about what could be true.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by metalliqaz on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:21PM (#46545920)
> FTs are actually very reasonable, in the sense that they are a easy to reason about conceptually and in practice.

ok but it's not the FTs that are unreasonable, it's the effectiveness

I think we all understand at this point that "unreasonable effectiveness" just means "surprisingly useful in ways we might not have immediately considered"

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by IAmBroom on Thursday January 08, 2026 @03:46PM (#46546215)
The HN audience is filled with the world's densest collection of literalists and nitpickers: software engineers.

Metaphorical language compels them to microrebuttals.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by w10-1 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @04:44PM (#46546932)
> Mathematics is the language of science

So, biology and medicine are not sciences? Or are only sciences to the extent they can be mathematically described?

The scientific method and models are much more than math. Equating the reality with the math has let to myriad misconceptions, like vanishing cats.

And silly is good for a title -- descriptive and enticing -- to serve the purpose of eliciting the attention without which the content would be pointless.

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by hogehoge51 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @05:31PM (#46547423)
They are still capable of being described with math, we are just not capable of doing the math, or probably better put is there is a diminishing return of doing the formalisation of those systems as our cognitive abilities are limited and couldn't reason about those models. It leaves them using very approximate models based on human language descriptions that can be reasoned about.

Which means, the language of some fields can’t be math.

However, I don’t think the original presenter was asserting those fields aren’t science, that’s an unreasonable interpretation. More so , ideally they would be use math as it is a language that would help prevent the silly argument “so, Y is not X?, or is Y only X provided Y is in the subset of X that excludes Z? “

(Even in Engineering, we hit this cognitive limit, and all sorts of silliness emerges about why things are or are not formalised)

Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by Yodan2025 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @09:15PM (#46549359)
The Antipode of unreasonable effectiveness ness
Re:The Unreasonable Effectiveness of the Fourier Transform by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday January 09, 2026 @12:01PM (#46555983)
Given how much of the talk is about the original paper the title references, and how the Fourier transform turns out to be unreasonably effective at allowing communication over noisy channels, I'd say it's a reasonable reference.