News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by WalterBright on Sunday October 14, 2012 @06:13PM (#4652813)
I'd like to see if this can be extended to re-entering from orbit. This could make space travel more practical, as there'd be less weight dedicated to re-entry vehicles.

(The only thing that needs to come back from orbit is the astronaut. The whole idea of reusable spacecraft is completely impractical, as weight is by far the biggest expense.)

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by dkokelley on Sunday October 14, 2012 @06:52PM (#4652896)
While burning off excess speed is one major concern for this approach, I've always wondered what it would take to use a balloon like this one to get past some of the tricky parts of rocketry like dealing with atmosphere and carrying extra fuel to carry the extra fuel you are carrying. If you could launch a rocket from 40km (roughly the height of the balloon), you're 25% into the minimum LEO, and ~10% of the way to the ISS. More importantly, the fuel savings from launching at a higher altitude are exponential, because each meter of altitude is one meter of less atmospheric drag (with diminishing returns) and the corresponding fuel/weight savings from not having to carry fuel to travel the first 40km.

I would imagine that the current limitations on doing something like this are related to the maximum weight a hot air balloon can lift, in addition to the untested physics and engineering of a mid-air space launch. Imagine if SpaceShipOne (which was launched at 13.3km) could be taken to 40km and then launched.

Perhaps someone with a better understanding of lighter-than-air lift physics could explain what the current limitations on this are.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by ghjm on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:24PM (#4653419)
Suppose you could use a balloon to get to LEO altitude. You're still not in orbit. Anything that actially is in orbit will come hurtling at you faster than a bullet. Most of the fuel used in getting to LEO is used to achieve orbital speed, not orbital altitude. So the question of ground launch vs space launch is really one of where your engines operate most efficiently, or if you can avoid air friction in the dense lower atmosphere, or that sort of thing. Baumgarnter was nowhere close to "10% of the way to the ISS."
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by jlgreco on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:50PM (#4653508)
A good way to sort of wrap you mind around exactly LEO means is to consider that at LEO altitudes the strength of gravity is, for most intents and purposes (9.0m/s^2 vs 9.8m/s^2), the same as on the surface. If you get up that high then let go, you are going to drop like a rock.

If you want to not fall, you have to keep thrusting straight up, which obviously is not practical. The next best thing is to try to move sideways. Sideways fast enough that you clear the horizon before you hit the ground. You have to move fast enough that when you fall you miss the earth.

Moving that fast is pretty damn hard. Any rocket capable of doing it, even if it is already "up there" is going to be far to large to practically lift with a balloon.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by tripzilch on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:16AM (#4654410)
> You have to move fast enough that when you fall you miss the earth.

So what you're saying is that there is an art, or rather, a knack to flying, and that the knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss?

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by ema on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:13AM (#4654547)
took a while to get that reference.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by tripzilch on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:05AM (#4655077)
I didn't figure I'd get downvoted for quoting Douglas Adams, though.

And it wasn't even "just" a joke, finding out there was actually a grain of truth to that classic, I felt worth pointing it out.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by tisme on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:31PM (#4657028)
I thought it was hilarious, thank you. Never figured Douglas Adams was right on that one until you pointed it out.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by dkokelley on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:48PM (#4653502)
You're right about acceleration being an issue. It's possible that altitude is negligible compared to orbital velocity. I'm not sure what you mean by Baumgartner wasn't 10% of the way to the ISS. The ISS is at 370km, and the jump was from almost 40km. Of course there are other technical hurdles to getting there, but I was only referring to pure altitude.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by phreeza on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:14AM (#4654189)
Considering kinetic and potential energy together, adjusted for weight, he was about .5% there. 6.310^7 (m/s)^2 vs 3.810^5 (m/s)^2
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by goodcanadian on Sunday October 14, 2012 @08:06PM (#4653058)
Without doing any math, I would think the main constraint is the sheer size of the balloon that you would need to lift any significant mass. That said there are some people who are proposing things like this with at least some seriousness:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_airship

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by dkokelley on Sunday October 14, 2012 @08:57PM (#4653199)
Interesting. I wonder what the theoretical maximum height/weight is achievable with current LTA materials. I was thinking that the LTA vehicle would act as a miniature space elevator, with a launch craft carrying the traditional rocket part of the way through the atmosphere, and then launching the rocket the rest of the way up and into orbit.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by wittjeff on Sunday October 14, 2012 @09:01PM (#4653209)
One of the entrants in the first X Prize competition was going to try this: http://www.davinciproject.com/beta/Technical/TechnicalFlight...
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by adastra on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:38PM (#4653473)
You've got it backwards. It is completely impractical to build an entire spaceship, and then throw it away after every launch. Reusable vehicles are the only way to get launch costs down.

You can boil the transportation cost function down to a single independent variable: flight rate. For low flight rates, the costs per flight are very high, and are dominated by the labor of the engineers who design and build the vehicles. For higher flight rates, the costs drop, and are dominated by the costs of the physical materials used to build the vehicles. And for the highest flight rates, the costs bottom out and are dominated by the cost of fuel. All current modes of transportation (cars, buses, trains, ships, and airliners) have their cost dominated by the fuel cost. Only space travel is the outlier. Why? Because we're throwing every vehicle away after a single use!

Not to mention, any launch vehicle must have a capsule able to withstand re-entry anyway, to handle high-velocity launch aborts, so you might as well use it for an actual reentry later.

And to answer your original question, you could conceivably survive reentry from orbital velocities using a very large ballute:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballute

But it would probably need to be so large as to be impractical.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by WalterBright on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:25AM (#4653757)
Take a hard look at the shuttle. Most of it - the weight, the complexity, the cost - comes from trying to bring it back intact. Wings, landing gear, hydraulics, flight control systems, etc., is all there solely to bring it back.

All that extra weight means a much bigger rocket is needed to push it up, it means you've got far, far less payload, and you're still stuck in low earth orbit only.

Weight is so expensive I don't think the economics can ever pan out for reusable rockets.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by zrail on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:38AM (#4653792)
Most of it comes from a series of awful compromises with the military. The Air Force wanted it that big so they could put up and recover very large classified cargos from various places, iirc in less than one orbit.

Also, if the shuttle had actually been used as much as intended the cost wouldn't have been nearly as much.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by adastra on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:47AM (#4653813)
You can make a reusable launch vehicle that's economical. You can also make one that is incredibly expensive, if its poorly designed. The two are not mutually exclusive.

Kind of like how most cars are cheap on a per-use basis, but it would be insane to use a formula-1 racecar as your daily driver.

That's basically the shuttle. In fact, it's worse. More like putting that F-1 engine in an 18-wheeler sized truck, only doing 2 trips to the grocery store per year, and having the ferrari racing team's engineers and mechanics rebuild the engine and replace the tires after every trip.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by WalterBright on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:37AM (#4653917)
>You can make a reusable launch vehicle that's economical.

I find that difficult to believe, given the enormous extra weight that will be necessary.

Look at the Apollo rocket, with that teeny tiny capsule on top of that massive thing. The capsule was the only thing that came back, and that whole massive rocket was needed to push that little capsule to the moon.

Now add wings, landing gear, etc., to the capsule, and imagine how much bigger the Saturn V would have to be.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by adastra on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:53AM (#4653940)
Wings aren't the only way. Both Elon Musk (SpaceX) and Jeff Bezos (Blue Origin) are pursuing reusable launch vehicles that land vertically by gimbaling and throttling the rocket engines.

This isn't wishful thinking either -- both have already done some initial low altitude VTVL tests. Videos here:

http://www.engadget.com/2012/09/22/spacexs-grasshopper-verti...

http://www.blueorigin.com/updates/updates-2011-11-17-video-o...

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by goodcanadian on Sunday October 14, 2012 @08:00PM (#4653042)
The main difference is that the skydiver started with a velocity of 0. The astronaut in low earth orbit is going to be starting with a velocity of something like 28,000 km/h.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by WalterBright on Sunday October 14, 2012 @09:33PM (#4653289)
Right. But the atmosphere is exponential, so the idea would be to have a high drag/mass for the start, to slow you down before compression heats things up.

A capsule is small and heavy, so it'll have enough inertia to push up the compression and hence reentry heat.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by tisme on Sunday October 14, 2012 @06:14PM (#4652815)
How are you going to get rid of the horizontal velocity component?
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by pferde on Sunday October 14, 2012 @07:49PM (#4653008)
You simply jump to the east. :)
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by ChuckMcM on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:55PM (#4653524)
Yes and no. So when you are in orbit you're travelling around the planet at a high rate of speed. You have to dump all of the kinetic energy related to your zipping around in order to head down to the ground. Typically something like the shuttle uses orbital manuevering rockets to decelerate such that the orbit becomes eccentric and intercepts the atmosphere. Then when the atmosphere is entered it bleeds off still more energy by colliding with air (which creates a tremendous amount of heat). Once that energy is dissipated it glides down to the ground.

For parachute jump from orbit, first you'd want to dump as much of your velocity as possible while still being outside the thicker part of the atmosphere. You could do that with a retro rocket, or my favorite is a conductive tether tied to a resistive load. In the latter case you use the fact that you're moving through Earth's magnetic field which generates a current in a conductor that is at an angle to the magnetic flux. If you ground short that conductor then it pushes back against the flux much like a shorted motor pushes back against you trying to spin it when its terminals are shorted.

It is entirely unclear to me if you can dump enough energy that way but you can certainly dump quite a bit. Once you are into the upper atmosphere there are a variety of ideas from what are essentially streamers to hypersonic parachutes to slow you further.

If you can't dump enough energy then you won't be able to avoid being crisped by the heat generated by your re-entry shock wave.

Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by philwelch on Sunday October 14, 2012 @10:26PM (#4653424)
But you need a spacecraft to get an astronaut back up anyway. I don't know; I guess you could launch large capsules that were just space station components and add them on to your space station with every launch.
Re:Skydiver shatters world record with 24-mile leap by WalterBright on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:29AM (#4653769)
Exactly, without all those wings, landing gear, flight controls, hydraulics, etc., you've got weight avaible to spend on payload. Remember the "pay" in payload, it's the point of the mission.

The only things that need to come back are the astronauts.