News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by rsynnott on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @12:46PM (#46515713)
Cost; touch interfaces are cheaper.

Though also I would wonder if bad market research was a problem. I bet if, 10 years ago, you showed someone a traditional VW interface, or a touchscreen thing, they'd go "oh, cool, touchscreens". They might feel differently if they actually _used_ the thing, but if you skip that bit of the research... It's fairly common that companies make changes based on what customers _say_ they want, because customers are not necessarily good at realising what they _actually_ want until they experience it.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by AlotOfReading on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:43PM (#46516620)
It's not just that touch interfaces are cheaper. It's that you can decouple the interface design and feature set from the manufacturing schedule and shorten the overall development.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by rtkwe on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:14PM (#46517087)
While I get that I also think it's a bit odd because how much has actually changed about the basic required set of buttons needed to operate a vehicle in the last 20 years? Most of the differences I see are down to trim levels and companies already had the solution to that with panels that weren't on the main cluster of dash controls. My low trim Golf has a couple obvious panels near the shifter where different optional things would live; seat heaters etc.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by maximilianthe1 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:49PM (#46518476)
I guess, that only new things are: 1) driving assist things 2) drive mode select (sport, comfy, etc) 3) and HUD change (trip a, trip b, etc) 4) voice command button 5) regen braking control (EV only)

1 may be one the same button as cruese control

2, 5 may be on shifter knob panel

3 and 4 are the only new buttons on steering wheel

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by rtkwe on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:13PM (#46518847)
1 is all over the place depending on what your car has; my wife's car has lane keeping and blind spot monitors and those live in a knockout panel down and left of the steering wheel.

2 I've usually found in the buttons near the shifter

3 I'm not sure what you're referring to? If it's the little screen generally between the speed and battery/rpm display those controls are usually on the steering wheel in my experience.

4 Steering wheel, in every car I've seen it in and that's often standard across the models

5 This one I've only had one experience with and that's my wife's Kia Niro EV and those are on what would be shifter paddles in a car with a gear box.

The number of buttons on steering wheels between my decade old gas Golf and my wife's few year old Niro EV are shockingly similar though presented and arranged differently. Both have 4 buttons and two directional pairs (audio control for skipping on one, volume on the other, cruise control speed on another and one dimension of the hud paging on the last) though the Niro has the pairs as rocker switches that can click for one extra button I suppose.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:06PM (#46518741)
Also you can use the same touchscreen for different vehicles and the manufacturing of that is always the same or if there is variation it is over smaller numbers of parameters: maybe a bigger or a brighter touchscreen.

I think of an initiative GM had, I think circa 2000, to standardize branding across all their vehicles and notably use the same buttons from the bottom of the line compacts up to flagships like the HUMMER, Cadillac, and the GMC Suburban. Sensitized by media coverage whenever I looked at these buttons sitting in a GM car or looking through the windows I felt that it diluted the higher end brands.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by themafia on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:13PM (#46518850)
You could integrate the buttons into the touch screen controller. They don't need to connect to physical relays in the device to activate functionality, they can be every bit as "soft" as the touch screen itself, but actually provide haptic feedback on use.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by AlotOfReading on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:37PM (#46520983)
Couple of issues with that. One is that good haptic UI is difficult and auto OEMs are not "technically capable", to put it mildly. Also, some did. GM experimented with a haptic feedback touchscreen called "CUE" in the Cadillac brand about a decade ago. It was a disaster. The feel was terrible, customers hated using it, and the screens became extremely fragile. VW phased their own attempts out after some nasty unintended acceleration lawsuits.

Automotive hardware is extremely difficult to get right. Buttons are a solved problem. Touchscreens are getting there. Everything else is a gamble in an area where failures have huge risks. OEMs don't like those. We'll probably continue seeing haptic feedback on things like wheels and shifters, but haptic touchscreens seem to be on the way out these days.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by peaseagee on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:56PM (#46516801)
That's one of the ways in which it is cheaper, yes. The touchscreen choice was made rationally, we just disagree on our priors ;-)
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by tremon on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @06:17PM (#46534643)
All it takes is standardizing the connector between the dashboard controls and the actuator/sensor network to decouple the dashboard design from the car electronics. I don't see how a touchscreen would be essential to achieve that?
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by neogodless on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:55PM (#46518585)
Everyone: I never wanted a screen

Also Everyone: I will never buy a car without CarPlay / Android Auto

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CarPlay (March 10, 2014)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_Auto (March 19, 2015)

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by jhallenworld on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:23PM (#46519004)
They only want the screen for the stereo and backup camera, not anything else. It's easier to update a car from 2004 say to have Android Auto than to fix one made in 2024 that doesn't have it. $400 aftermarket stereo from crutchfield..

I would say that 2005 was peak car, except 2000 is slightly better because they had not yet gone nuts with serialized components.

(another reason is that direct inject fuel injection hadn't taken over yet, it's a disaster)

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by CGMthrowaway on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:19PM (#46519643)
Screens are mandatory, because backup cameras are now mandatory.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by gambiting on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:34PM (#46520439)
Sure, but no one said the screen has to be size of an ipad glued to your dashboard. My 2022 Volkswagen e-Up has a reverse camera and it's shown on a display maybe 2 inches large. And it's perfectly usable, I actually really like how minimalistic that is. There's no "infotainment" of any kind either, it's just a simple radio/bluetooth selection screen when the camera isn't in use.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by CGMthrowaway on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:07PM (#46520768)
The size regulation is based on viewing angle. For a tiny car like e-Up you are seated very close to the screen, so it can be smaller. For larger cars, you are seated further away from the dash and the screens must be proportionally larger.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by al_borland on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:09PM (#46520170)
I want CarPlay for the PIM integrations (contacts, calendar, phone, etc). That’s about it.

If the music from my phone could controlled by big thunky buttons, that would be great. I get upset with CarPlay and its touch interface all the time.

There is also the issue that I simply don’t trust the car companies with my data. They have proven they can’t be trusted with it, and CarPlay is a way to get a lot of that data isolated (I hope).

I’m fine with a display for some things, a backup camera demands it, but I want to control it all with tactile controls, not touch.

[dead]
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by neogodless on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @07:15PM (#46535233)
Don't mistake my snarky "people contradict themselves" post for my opinion :)

I love and prefer buttons. (I also demand Android Auto, though my car didn't have it initially - it was later added through a major software update.)

We all love screens but in a car, I think that buttons are better for the interface for climate, wipers, signaling, drive modes, cruise control, headlights, 4WD selection, volume, radio stations... while Android Auto and Apple CarPlay are excellent for navigation and other entertainment.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by snovv_crash on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:28PM (#46516403)
No, 10 years ago everyone was complaining that their BlackBerry was faster to type on than an iPhone (or maybe that was 12 years ). I don't think touchscreens being a pain to use is a new revelation.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by rsynnott on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:59PM (#46516857)
That’s nearly 20 years ago. Approximately no-one had a blackberry 10 years ago.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by eichin on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:34PM (#46517395)
To align this more precisely - 2015 was the year of the Blackberry Priv (I used one for a couple of years) and, being an Android phone, felt like kind of a last gasp for Blackberry.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by razakel on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:11PM (#46518810)
They've still got QNX.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by Izkata on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @10:27AM (#46527473)
The KEYone was 2017 (I had this up until 2023 or so) and the KEY2 was 2018.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by alistairSH on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:03PM (#46516911)
They might feel differently if they actually _used_ the thing

That has to be a big part of it... especially if the customers' reference point is modern touchscreen cell phones (high quality displays, fast, etc).

But, the touch screen in my Honda is NOTHING like my iPhone. It's slow. It's not a good display. The software package is lackluster. It has a "apps" page, but there's no app store for crying out loud!!!

At least the screen is only for radio stuff and a few car monitoring things. The HVAC is still manual buttons.

Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by bregma on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:26PM (#46517272)
What customers say they want is a faster horse.
Re:VW is bringing physical buttons back to the dashboard wit... by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:14PM (#46520819)
I think that second issue is definitely a thing with kitchen appliances, where having a touch interface, or phone app, is initially seen as "oh hey this is the next generation cool thing" when consumers are buying.

Then they get it home and find the app is crapware full of ads and nags, or the touch screen is impossible to use unless your fingers are as dry as the sahara or such.