News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#46515263)
My favorite most annoying ad tactic is the trick slowing down progress bar. It starts off fast making it seem like it’s going to be, say, a ten-second ad so you decide to suffer through it… but progressively slows so you notice at like the 20 second mark you’re only 2/3 of the way through the progress bar, so probably less than halfway done. Murderous rage.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by xoxxala on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @12:25PM (#46515374)
Mr. Beast on youtube is guilty of that. Matt Parker of Standup Maths fame did an in-depth look at how that works. Whoever came up with that type of progress bar must hate people in general.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uc0OU1yJD-c

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by transcriptase on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:12PM (#46519581)
If you watch him on Joe Rogan’s podcast he gives a full overview of how every single tiny detail down to colors, length of scene cuts, facial expressions, language, total length of videos, time of day for release, thumbnails, sound effects, music is extensively A/B tested to not only optimize for the algorithm but for hijacking people’s attention as well. That weird creepy face with the outline and uncanny smoothing aren’t by accident. Everything is intentional because he obsessively tests anything that might give him even the slightest edge in a sea of videos. The content itself barely matters.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Tanoc on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:34PM (#46519781)
This seems like innately hostile behaviour. Not to other video creators, but to his audience. Stripping as much as he can using data and mathematics is the kind of thing engineers do to pull more out of a machine, not something you do when you're creating informal communications to other humans.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by orbital-decay on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:56PM (#46520027)
Attention engineering is how the charts are topped. Media producers knew this decades before the social media, and perfected it by the late 90's. Avoiding extremely popular stuff is just common sense if you want any real authenticity.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @09:18PM (#46521728)
Oh, but then you’re the much-maligned hipster.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by djtango on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @04:08AM (#46524207)
I introduced myself to my now wife as an accidental hipster:

- I brewed my own kombucha (I have GI issues and I am so lactose intolerant that even kefir and yoghurt would give me a reaction)

- I ride a bicycle everywhere (I exercise daily and like to stay active, bicycle is often the fastest way around London)

- I buy expensive locally farmed produce (the quality is usually night and day vs other sources)

There were plenty of other signals by which I superficially seem like a hipster but my wife would attest I'm the opposite of an actual one.

In the words of my ever wise mother "keep the good bits, leave the rest"

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by missingdays on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:37AM (#46524769)
What's the downside?
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by cardiffspaceman on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:10PM (#46529058)
If the right type of mate uses those traits to find their type of mate there’s no downside.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Saturday January 10, 2026 @02:07PM (#46568884)
I can't think of any. The upside is that people who think it's weird to not reflexively consume mass-market garbage identify themselves voluntarily, which makes it much easier to avoid them.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by latexr on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:43PM (#46521018)
> when you're creating informal communications to other humans.

What he’s creating is fame and money for himself, the fact that it’s by doing videos is incidental. That’s why he also got into ghost kitchens, a game show full of corner cutting, and a theme park in Saudi Arabia open for under two months.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @08:50AM (#46526330)
in other words his business model is fuck you pay me

at least 50 cent, who got into rap strictly for the money, made something fairly entertaining

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by zero_bias on Friday January 09, 2026 @03:04AM (#46551200)
At least 50 cent didn’t make TikTok style music with single polished part and junky rest of the song. Nowadays his goals looks almost innocent
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by aembleton on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:49PM (#46519948)
With enough humans, it starts to look like a machine
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by mxkopy on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:45PM (#46520563)
It’s basically drug dealing. Which is fine if you’re doing it for fun, but doing it to make money develops the most antisocial parts of a person
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by everdrive on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:57PM (#46520672)
>That weird creepy face with the outline and uncanny smoothing aren’t by accident.

I take your point, but I am still baffled why people find this appealing.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Retric on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:45PM (#46521033)
Novelty goes a long way, old enough YouTube video are optimized for their time period and end up looking stylized in their own ways.

Fashion swaps styles fast enough most people can’t afford full wardrobes before it changes, which by default keeps each style looking fresh.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by andrei_says_ on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @09:19PM (#46521735)
Maybe not appealing but interesting. Distinct enough from the rest of the thumbnails on the page to trigger an impulsive tap or click.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @09:21PM (#46521758)
Appealing isn’t the goal. Catching someone’s attention is the goal. (Nobody thinks the balloons on the cars at the car dealership look good but statistics prove that balloons sell cars.) Then, triggering someone’s curiosity, which is more where the copy comes in. (You can increase your click count with this one weird trick!)

You’re subject to it every bit as much as me or anybody else, but for whatever reason, we have different triggers than the Mr. Beast crowd. People that think they’re immune to it after having it pointed out to them are likely just less aware than most how their emotions are being manipulated by things they don’t even consciously perceive. Sales guys love people like that.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by eertami on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @06:21AM (#46525108)
If you're aware of it and think you're susceptible then you can make it impossible to be influenced by it. Ie, You can disable all 'related videos'/feeds/home page on Youtube with Unhook, and sponsored segments with SponsorBlock. I'll probably never see a Youtube thumbnail for the rest of my life, throw in Adblock and your exposure is extremely limited.

> Sales guys love people like that.

You can also easily never speak to them. I know they exist, but as a consumer I can't think of anytime I've had a sales interaction with a salesperson. I understand that some people do, and might even actively seek a salesperson - but if I go to a physical store I already know what I want to buy before I get there and the only interaction I might have is to ask how to find the thing I want.

I know it's a common argument/appeal to authority that advertising must work, because companies are still doing it - but there are economists who think that it might not[0].

[0]: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/does-advertising-actually-w...

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:22PM (#46533967)
> Ie, You can disable all 'related videos'/feeds/home page on Youtube with Unhook

This is not specific to YouTube. It’s billboards, product placement, etc etc etc.

> You can also easily never speak to them. I know they exist, but as a consumer I can't think of anytime I've had a sales interaction with a salesperson

Ok, so you make every major purchase online, probably don’t own a car, never purchased a home or lived in a city where its extremely difficult to rent without a realtor, never go out to restaurants or bars in the US where the service staff essentially works on commission in the form of gratuity… sure thing.

Thinking Sony would sell just as many products entirely based on word of mouth is absolutely absurd.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Thursday January 08, 2026 @08:09AM (#46540550)
And as an aside, conversion measurement is der rigueur in digital advertising— for obvious reasons, companies don’t publish it. It is the basis for A/B testing which uses large sample sizes to see which presentation is more likely to make people do or not do something. It’s easier than ever to tell where someone was exposed to something and the click trail they took to end up on a purchase screen. I don’t, nor have I ever worked in digital marketing, but this information is extremely easy to find. Additionally, the Freakonomics guys are no strangers to vibing their way through topics they know nothing about and mistakenly assuming their brief thought experiments and unchallenged researchers have uncovered something useful. It’s not like they’re never right, but they’re no stranger to unforced errors in their analysis and you’d be wise to not rely on them as a source.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by eertami on Thursday January 08, 2026 @09:44AM (#46541581)
I somewhat suspect our difference here is cultural divide - I've never been to the US, but none of the things you mentioned have involved salespeople in my experience in Europe.

I live in a city, have a car (bought second hand), buy things in person, go to restaurants. We have no tipping or gratuity, apartments have a fairly standard application process and often it's a previous tenant showing you around because they want you to take over their lease, unless the apartment is empty.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by GuB-42 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @09:27PM (#46521784)
It doesn't have to be appealing, it has to make you click.

Car crashes are not appealing, and yet it is something most people are tempted to look at. Many people think of dopamine as the pleasure hormone, not really, it is the motivation hormone, pleasure is one way to achieve that, but so is horror.

It makes evolutionary sense, if something horrible happens, you better pay attention, to get prepared so that it doesn't happen to you.

I don't know the details of the psychological response to Mr Beast thumbnails, and I think neither does My Beast himself, the analytics say it works and that the only thing that matters to him.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by fooker on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @08:02PM (#46521156)
Guests smoking weed A/B tested too? :)
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by foresto on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @08:47PM (#46521494)
It seems we're living a Max Headroom episode.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by jb1991 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:12AM (#46524615)
How do you A/B test on YouTube?
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by kotaKat on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:36AM (#46524759)
Youtube lets you A/B test thumbnails as a creator and see response rates, for instance.

https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/393332200/you-can-...

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @08:53AM (#46526369)
posted 12/8/2025, 11:24:26 AM

So like a month ago. How did Beast A/B test before then?

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by kotaKat on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @09:07AM (#46526501)
They give access to these features to their partners before general release, but this A/B feature has existed for quite some time now. I’ve seen various Patreon tech creators run those A/B tests and see them discuss them in their creator Discords.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by intended on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @09:07AM (#46526498)
Hasn't this been around for ages?
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by transcriptase on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:31PM (#46531307)
A small number of creators have had testing tools provided by YouTube for years.

He also changes the thumbnails and titles of videos once published, sometimes up to dozen times in the first day.

He also has dozens of channels for different languages, so can test thumbnails and other tweaks with those.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by kube-system on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:24PM (#46517245)
> Whoever came up with that type of progress bar must hate people in general.

My first thought is that the person has a strong grasp of their profession and they love money. A hack like that has to have a really high value/effort ratio.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by ghostbrainalpha on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:30PM (#46519742)
I was forced to do this as a developer of Flash websites in the early 00's.

I loved making custom progress bars really fun so people didn't mind watching the huge sites download.

I HATED when they had me mess with the time so that it got to 90% really fast and then spent AGES finishing the last 10%.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by consp on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:48PM (#46520585)
We all know the Microsoft progress bars reached 99% easily and had an infinite last % in the '90s. I'm still not convinced that was by accident.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by xeonmc on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:36PM (#46520978)
Zeno’s progress bar.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by x187463 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:10PM (#46517026)
A fantastic video from Matt, as usual.

Yet another data point on why nobody should be wasting a second watching Mr Beast content. Complete algorithmically optimized garbage.

I recall Mr Beast showing up in a Colin Furze video for a few minutes and Mr Beast was very clearly incapable of being a normal person. He was obviously out of place, being in full makeup and styled, and couldn't seem to be bothered to actually engage or express real interest in the subject. I think the guy has replaced his real persona with some manifestation of the YouTube algorithm. If he's not actively making money, he's just a shell.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by climb_stealth on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:17PM (#46518920)
Luckily the recommendation system does work to some extent. I'm glad I don't get to see any of that stuff on my youtube. Opening the front page in a private view is a scary place of hyper-optimised drama and attention seeking.

It's scary imagining people getting sucked into that :/

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by physicles on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:39PM (#46520494)
If you turn off you watch history in account settings, then youtube.com is just a passive-aggressive black screen telling you to turn it back on. It’s beautiful.

When you click over to subscriptions, you see only the stuff that you subscribed to, and nothing else.

Recommendations on a video are based on you subscriptions and the current video, and nothing else.

I could never go back.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by mc3301 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:29PM (#46520921)
Fully agreed.

The day youtube disables the "turn watch history off," is the day I'll stop using youtube.

I, too, could never go back.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by andrepd on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:37PM (#46520980)
This is basically what I do in NewPipe! Just a good ol' chronological list of my subscriptions, nothing else. Ahh if only everything could be this 2006...
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @11:44PM (#46522655)
> Opening the front page in a private view is a scary place of hyper-optimised drama and attention seeking.

Huh? Opening the front page of youtube in a private view (with no existing youtube history) shows you a completely blank page.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by jasonfarnon on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:49AM (#46523052)
The blank page where it asks you to enter a search? This is a recent change I think. I want to say the last year or 2.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by climb_stealth on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @04:55AM (#46524506)
This must have changed at some point. It used to show popular videos in a private window.

You can still get a glimpse of what is out there by watching a specific video in a private window and looking at the recommendations.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Hendrikto on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @06:20AM (#46525101)
It used to be very good, but now the personalized recommendations kind of suck. Seems like they enormously regressed, and basically do the 2009 move of just shoving the last type of video you watched in your face 37 times.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @08:55AM (#46526387)
ahhh and i thought it was just me. cancelled my subscription and figured YT was just not caring anymore as a way to drag me back.

nah turns out it sucks for everyone.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by m4tthumphrey on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:59PM (#46517763)
That Colin Furze cameo was so weird.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by x187463 on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @01:37PM (#46530554)
From what I can tell, based on an excerpt of an interview with Colin, Mr Beast had a bunker-related video and visited Colin's bunker. As a viewer of Colin's channel and not Mr Beast, it seemed very strange, but makes more sense if there was a more substantial collaboration taking place in a different video stream.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by duped on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:09PM (#46518781)
They somehow got him doing a cameo on this upcoming Survivor season and it's going to be terrible.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Hendrikto on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @06:17AM (#46525066)
Mr Beast not looking like a normal person next to Colin Furze is impressive.

That guy is so over the top that I cannot bear watching his videos, despite them theoretically being exactly up my alley. I like tinkering videos, I like his ideas, and the high-quality results, but I hate his mannerisms.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by hermitdev on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:26PM (#46531228)
Every time see Mr Beast (I don't watch any of his stuff, just accidentally see promos on Prime sometimes), he reminds me of Homer Simpson's forced smile in the Simpsons' espiode "Re-Nedufication" [0].

[0]: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/c8/84/8e/c8848e81afa88a42bd4d...

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by drcongo on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:26PM (#46516381)
Not the only thing he's guilty of.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @08:56AM (#46526391)
explain
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by drcongo on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @12:55PM (#46529818)
It's all a scam.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by cons0le on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:15PM (#46517092)
MrBeast is a hack, but its worth pointing out that all "progress bars" are bad design. You could make the same complaint against most of the progress bars in MsDOS. There was never a consistency in timing so you can never really use them to gauge how much time is left.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Vegenoid on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:21PM (#46517190)
We’re not talking about a measure of computational progress here. We’re talking about visually representing how much time has elapsed out of a fixed duration. This is exactly where progress indicators shine, the total time for the thing to happen is perfectly specified in advance.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by dspillett on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:15PM (#46517999)
The difference between a lot of OS/app progress bars for IO (and sometimes CPU) operations and these timers, is that the total length of time for a lot of IO operations is often unknown with any accuracy so you have to use a heuristic to guess the current % done.

For instance: when reading/writing/both many files of differing sizes on traditional drives there is an amount of latency per file which is significant and not always predictable. Whether you base progress on total size or number of files or some more complicated calc based on both, it will be inaccurate in most cases, sometimes badly so. Even when copying a single large file on a shared drive, or just on a dedicated system with multiple tasks running, the progress is inherently a bit random, the same for any network transfer. Worse are many database requests: you don't get any progress often because there is no progress output until the query processing is complete, and the last byte of the result might arrive in the same fraction of a second the first does¹. The same for network requests, though IE (at least as early as v3) and early versions of Edge did outright lie² there to try make themselves look faster than the competition.

The progress bars in videos are a different beast (ahem): the total time is absolutely known, any inaccuracy is either a deliberate lie or gross incompetence.

--------

[1] I once worked on a system that kept logs of certain types of query so it could display a guess of how long things were going to take and a progress bar to go with it, but this was actually more irritating to the users than no progress display as it would sometime jump from a few % directly to done or sit at 99% for ages (in the end the overly complicated guessing method was replaced by a simple spinner).

[2] It would creep up, getting as far as 80%, before the first byte of response is received. This also confused users who thought that something was actually happening when the action was in fact stalled and just going to time-out.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by JadeNB on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @08:05PM (#46521194)
> [1] I once worked on a system that kept logs of certain types of query so it could display a guess of how long things were going to take and a progress bar to go with it, but this was actually more irritating to the users than no progress display as it would sometime jump from a few % directly to done or sit at 99% for ages (in the end the overly complicated guessing method was replaced by a simple spinner).

In the Tiger era, the OS X start-up progress bar worked this way—it kept track of how long boot-ups would take, and then displayed its best guess based on that.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by andy99 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:36PM (#46519814)
Many progress bars or other indicators lie, and the incentive is always to make it look good at the beginning, so that’s what we end up seeing most, whether it’s these ad ones (which thankfully I’ve never seen) or installers or especially something like Uber that always lies about how quickly someone is coming to make it appealing and then stretches it out. Even the thing in your car that tells you how much range you have left before refuelling (except it starts showing more than you actually have). I think in all cases it’s probably possible to give a more realistic estimate but it’s counter to the goals of whoever designed it.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by btown on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:33PM (#46517384)
As a full mea culpa, I once implemented this years ago for an open-source project (non-ad-related) that could have an unpredictable number of steps with unpredictable timing. We went with an algorithm that would add a % of the remaining progress on each status tick, so, while it would inevitably decelerate, at least users would know that the processing wasn't just frozen.

It was a compromise that let us focus our limited attention on the things our project could uniquely do, without needing to refactor or do fast-and-slow-passes to provide subtask-count estimates to the UI. I'd make those same choices again, in that context. But in an ad context, it's inexcusable.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by layer8 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:46PM (#46518440)
If the only purpose is to show progress and you don’t known the total number of steps in advance, it’s better to show information about the current step and/or substep. Otherwise when your processing actually freezes, the UI would still happily show an advancing progress bar. That’s worse than even just showing a spinner animation or similar.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by btown on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:09PM (#46519555)
If it froze and ceased emitting ticks, it wouldn't advance any more - but the larger point is well taken!
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by SoftTalker on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:56PM (#46517727)
I've done something similar with a progress bar back in the early days. The task needed to do 10 things, so when each one completed the bar would move 10%. So the bar indicated completion in terms of things that needed to be done but not really in terms of time. It was quick and dirty and we had higher priorities but someone insisted on a "progress bar" so that was the easiest thing.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by layer8 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:42PM (#46518390)
That’s perfectly acceptable, in particular if you also display “step x of 10”, so the user knows the bar doesn’t indicate time.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Groxx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:19PM (#46516264)
I'm fond of the ones with a fake close button, so tapping it just launches the ad's site. Instant uninstall and 1-star.

(Yes, I know it's mostly the ad's fault, but there's no practical way to punish them directly. So force apps to pick better-behaving networks.)

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:11PM (#46518808)
As a sometimes designer, i don’t think there’s any distinction between punishing the ad and the company. The company bought the ad, probably directed its creation, and decided what its criteria was for success. 1-star away as far as I’m concerned.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by josephg on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:51PM (#46519382)
I feel the same way about newsletters.

“Hey you bought socks that one time! Want more socks??” -> Unsubscribe.

“Hey it’s your weekly sock news! What’s new in socks!” -> But I unsubscribed! Haha no, you only unsubscribed from the “product releases” list. Not the “weekly news” list or our 10 other fabulous mailing lists!

-> Report all emails from this domain as spam. May god have mercy on your soul, cute socks.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by rkomorn on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:58PM (#46519438)
This is exactly something I hate about the current state of things.

Interacting with a company/organization immediately turns into a lifelong "legitimate relationship" that supposedly entitles them to contact you forever and ever.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by brewtide on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @08:28PM (#46521359)
Recently bought a GE oven. It had a minor problem and had a few service appointments. Not a huge deal, life moves on.

Meanwhile, near immediately, they would love a review! They want Participation in OUR new oven.

It's overwhelming, and most frustrating is it seems 'communication' is rapidly become a one way st.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by jdwithit on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @11:48PM (#46522682)
I "love" the ones that randomly decide to reactivate literally years after unsubscribing and never interacting with the business again. The other day I randomly got an email from a yoga studio I once bought my wife a gift card from. We moved and neither of us has been there since 2021. Why on earth am I suddenly getting spam 5 years later. I get similar messages from hotels many years later too. Sometimes ones I didn't even end up staying at, just browsed. You can sense the desperation through the monitor.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by hylaride on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @04:37AM (#46524393)
I now militantly use apple’s “hide my email” function for this reason, though it doesn’t really work when you “need” to give your email address in person (I have a “junk” email address that’s normally turned off on my devices for those people)
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by nemomarx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @04:27PM (#46519051)
I think they mean they leave a 1 star review on the app that was displaying the ad, who probably didn't directly do any of that.

They did work with a bad ad network though so it's a valid enough reason to complain imo.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:10PM (#46519570)
Yeah, good call, but I honestly have no problem with that 1-star either. They can’t say “well we just opened the garbage conduit and pointed it at your face… we didn’t actually MAKE the garbage.” Those ads are part of their app experience, now. They published it, so they’re ’re responsible for it. If it sucks I give it a sucky rating.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Groxx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @06:16PM (#46520235)
Yep. There's no other way to maybe-convince them to get a different ad provider, because they're the ones that chose it (probably because it paid the most).
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by immibis on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:23PM (#46516334)
IME it's a real close button but the ad opens the thing when it closes, regardless of how it closes.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Groxx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:13PM (#46517063)
No, I mean there are ads with a "close button" in the corner, and then a few seconds later the real close button will appear and it'll weirdly overlap it. Because the first one was fake, just part of the image asset of the ad.

They're very very clearly click-fraud tricks, and most platforms will ban them if they're caught. But by clicking on the ad, it closes the ad, and there's no way to go back and report them, nor incentive for ad-viewers to do so. By design, IMO.

The whole industry runs on scams like this, there's no incentive for large platforms to proactively block any of them because they lead to money moving through them, where they can extract their rent. They only move against the most egregious, to keep fraud at the same barely-acceptable level as all the others.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by mbirth on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:20PM (#46518074)
> The whole industry runs on scams like this

Wasn’t there an article here a few days ago about Facebook specialising in hiding such malicious ads from testers and law enforcement to maximise gains?

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Groxx on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:38PM (#46518340)
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by mbirth on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:00AM (#46524537)
And here's the HN discussion about it:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46446838

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by transcriptase on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @10:42PM (#46522264)
Yes. Basically the internet version of the Volkswagen emissions scandal.

  if(testdetected == 1)
  ecm.lowemissions
  else
  lmao.fuckyouregulators
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by red-iron-pine on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @09:00AM (#46526434)
the difference is that the average rube and/or average lawmaker have some basic understanding of how cars work.

petrol goes in, toxic gas comes out, so make toxic gas less.

most of them have 0% understanding as to how data mining works or how online ads (and scams) function

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by immibis on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @04:00PM (#46532671)
It was about advertising for scams, not tracking. That's easier to understand than a car.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by jordwest on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:37PM (#46516530)
A common trick is that the first click on the X will go to the ad, but if you return and click the X again it will close, gaslighting you into thinking you just misclicked the first time.

Another trick that I’ve noticed on the Reddit app is that the tappable area is much larger for ads than normal posts. If you tap even near the ad it will visit the ad

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by DrewADesign on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @05:14PM (#46519604)
Also making the hit area smaller than the close graphic itself is a popular one.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by flexagoon on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @08:47PM (#46521503)
This is usually against ad network rules, so if you're willing to go out of your way a bit, you can screenshot those ads and report directly to the ad network
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by kaoD on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @02:56AM (#46523754)
QA is something an employee should do, not me.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by kotaKat on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:38AM (#46524774)
Difficulty is when you don't know what ad network it is, the app hides the ad network they use, and refuse to disclose who it is.

You got served an ad from "one of our partners". That's all you'll get to know, and there's no mechanism to even report the app's shitty behavior to Google or Apple (and they don't care when the app becomes too large, either).

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by Groxx on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @07:38PM (#46535431)
Which is often not possible because clicking an ad generally closes the ad. And there's no incentive for users to report, by design IMO.

They could have a separate ad-reporting UI in every ad-running app (so you can report stuff later), and they could reward valid reports by skipping all ads on their network for a month or something, but doing that would reduce fraud, and that means reducing their profit. So none of them do it.

I'd say they probably need an oversight committee with teeth, to strongly punish every single violation (so the networks develop functional defenses), but they'll probably just VW-emissions-fraud their way around it.

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @11:47PM (#46522676)
I'm not sure that is mostly the ad's fault. Hitting a target on a touchscreen is hard to do. This seems like it's the phone's fault first to me.

(If you're using a mouse, forget what I said. But I haven't run into an ad where the close button didn't close it... if you were able to click the close button.)

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by wsc981 on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @11:56PM (#46522739)
On iOS I have seen ads with very small close buttons, so clearly intended to cause people to miss-click. Buttons should be 44x44 pixels, it’s recommended in the human interface guidelines [0].

——

[0]: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by oneeyedpigeon on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @12:30PM (#46515472)
There's also the tactic of having different ad behaviours during the same video. The first will be a 30s unskippable ad, the second will be a single skippable one, the third will be 3 ads, one of which you can skip, etc. It's ok on a mobile or if you're at your desk, but if you're watching from a distance it gets really annoying...
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by qwertox on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @12:47PM (#46515727)
Kind of like a genius idea. Though there should be a special place in hell for app owners who want this in their app.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by hiccuphippo on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @03:31PM (#46518234)
The Windows file copying progress bar prepared me for that one. I don't trust progress bars anymore.
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by mrbonner on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @01:58PM (#46516825)
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by wumms on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @02:13PM (#46517060)
Reminds me of Setup.exe
Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by andrepd on Tuesday January 06, 2026 @07:35PM (#46520965)
Uber (and many other apps probably) do a similar thing. A completely deceptive progress bar that's basically an animation that's AB tested for lowest perceived wait, rather than being an actual progress bar in any sense of the word!

Everything is trying to scam you nowadays jfc

Re:Vienam Bans Unskippable Ads, Requires Skip Button to Appe... by laurieg on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @03:20AM (#46523897)
The positive version of this is clocks in escape rooms. You set the countdown timer to be slightly faster for the first 45 minutes and slightly slower for the last 10, so that people get more of a taste of time pressure towards the end and a higher chance of a "photo finish" which makes for a great fun story.