News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A different take on sexism in IT by arkitaip on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:14PM (#4648870)
You are seriously telling me that what made your female coworkers "deeply upset" was the idea that asking to be respected as women and not things like getting significantly less pay, sexual harassment and fewer career options? Either you are not telling the truth or this is the most ridiculous case of selective bias I've read on HN in a long time. Ask these female coworkers of yours what bothers them the most, the fight for gender equality in the workplace or getting paid less because they are women.

-----

As a woman you want respect because you are capable and smart. Not because you are a woman.

This is an really old and equally flawed argument that doesn't consider the fact that men discriminate women based on their gender not their individuality.

-----

In the course of my life I started to develop an higher and higher intolerance for topics like politically correctness and protection of minorities unless this was clearly put in general terms.

Political correctness is a weasel word designed to avoid meaningful discussions. By using it you've already made it clear that you have made up your mind on a topic that you're ignorant about.

-----

If you are an human being you need to be respected because you deserve respect like any other. I don't care if you are black, white, yellow or woman, you are an individual.

And yet you fail to see that individuals cannot fight centuries and millenia of stereotypes, biases and general ignorance.

-----

Similarly, I will not care who you are if you do something silly at work. Nothing is more offensive for you than me being too easy with you because you are part of some minority. This is, basically, a masked form of reverse-sexism, and is deeply offensive.

No one is asking you to subsidize minority stupidity, so I have no idea why you are bringing this up. Also, is this really a problem? People's work, regardless if they belong to a minority or not, are held to a certain standard and if they don't perform accordingly there are ways of remedying the problem.

-----

In general if there is a problem at the work place between individual A and B, I think it is always an error to talk about sexism, even when the root cause is some asshole not respecting you because you are a woman.

This is a very convenient way of avoiding to deal with sexism and other related issues. Imagine the guy who claims that he doesn't have issues with woman despite countless cases of harassing his female coworkers, that he just happens to have problem with individuals that always happen to be women.

-----

Trying to protect women in tech since they are women is like moving a cultural problem (the sexism) into an individual domain.

It's quite the opposite. You are so desperate to focus on individuals that you refuse to acknowledge that minority and gender issues can only be solved on higher level, i.e. group, company and society level. This is how we've managed to get things like equal political rights; centuries of organizing and fighting on higher social levels.

-----

A woman in tech has nothing less than a male in tech, as such does not need special care or protection. She needs to be respected as everybody else.

What does "less" mean? Woman are clearly more often harassed in the workplace, they get less pay, etc, so obviously something isn't working. I'm not sure that they need "special care" (nice pejorative term there) or protection by manly men, but they need to be treated equally and currently that's not the case.

-----

Another naive way to consider the problem is to think that sexism is a state of mind of men. Actually the problem is more complex than that, and a lot of women don't consider themselves or other women as capable as men.

You don't explain the complexity of the situation but you're implying that woman can be sexists too. Yes, that's obvious but doesn't change the fact that men are far more likely to be sexists and woman far more likely to be discriminated against.

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by LaGrange on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:31PM (#4648915)
"Political correctness"

I actually love political correctness, and people ranting about it always appear to me as deliberately obtuse and trying to avoid responsibility for behaving in certain ways.

Here's the thing: political correctness is not the same thing as Orwell's newspeak. It's about being recognizing that certain expressions are hurtful, and remaining conscious not only about what you want to say, but also what will be heard when you say it. It's also about the idea that the original author almost got, but not really: that maybe the divisive attributes shouldn't be mentioned when they're irrelevant (though the author is certainly wrong about gender's relevance. Yeah, it should be -- but it's not, and making gender activists shut up won't make it irrelevant). It's about recognizing that language actually shapes the social reality and the perception if certain ideas (both desirable and not) are something acceptable (there's some neat studies on how people choose their ideologies based on whether they perceive them as socially accepted).

It's really sad that the concept ended up becoming a weasel word used by bullies to say "this person just complained about me being a bully, and that makes me feel uncomfortable".

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by tomp on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:49PM (#4648969)
I'm not an American, so I might not be familiar of all the ways one ought to be politically correct, but let's focus on the one example that I do know: fat vs. overweight or horizontally-challenged or [silence].

My main objection with the idea that saying that someone is fat will hurt their feelings or make them feel bad is that no, it will NOT make them feel bad - rather, it will make them feel worse, because they must already feel bad. If someone is fat and they are ok with it, they wouldn't be hurt if I was pointing it out. It's just like I wouldn't be offended if someone called me a man, or European, or short/not tall, or geek, because I'm ok with all of those.

Therefore, based on personal reflection, I believe that people that get offended by saying they are fat are people that don't like being fat. But in that case, they should be shamed, in other words encouraged to do something about it, to make a positive change in their lives! I find the idea that I should limit my own freedom of speech just so that other people can continue living in ignorance, ridiculous.

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by JoachimSchipper on Saturday October 13, 2012 @01:09PM (#4649032)
> [fat people] should be shamed, in other words encouraged to do something about it, to make a positive change in their lives!

Have you considered all possible alternatives and decided that this was the best thing you could possibly do for them? Or was it just kinda convenient to do what you've always wanted to do anyway?

Or, trying another tack, replace "fat" by "nerdy".

> I find the idea that I should limit my own freedom of speech just so that other people can continue living in ignorance, ridiculous.

Fat people pretty much all know they're overweight. Freedom of speech means specifically freedom from your local government censoring your speech; it doesn't mean you can be as offensive as you want without being called on it.

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by LaGrange on Saturday October 13, 2012 @02:07PM (#4649175)
Well, lets start with the fact that your personal reflection is bunk, and I'm not an american as well, but culturally aware enough to know that the european stereotype of Americans being really politically correct is actually present in an american "Europeans are politically correct" version. Also, "horizontally-challenged" is not something that really happens. Actual political correctness is either saying "overweight" when it's relevant, or keeping it to your own damn self when it's not.

Now, to the personal reflection — people might rationally know that it's no-one's business how much they weight, but still be aware of the societal perception of their looks. They might be still healthy people, and they would be happy with their looks, but the reaction of society to their looks makes them feel bad anyway, and one of such reactions is using expressions such as "fat".

As for "shaming" == "encouraging," it's just not true, to avoid harsher statements. In fact shaming is extremely discouraging to people, is mostly done without awareness if the person being shamed can or wants to actually change the state that caused shaming, and is just done to boost egos of people doing the shaming. It's only use is in discouraging extremely unwanted behaviors – such as, for example, shaming people whose looks don't conform to your particular standards of beauty. Oh, and "positive change" might be actually a load of bunk as well.

And, finally, as to the "keeping in ignorance" remark, it's an extremely ignorant remark. For one, the "if irrelevant" is important here. My doctor can still tell me that the recently acquired extra load on my joints is probably contributing to my knee issues, interestingly enough without using the expression "fat slob", and people can talk about oppression of people of color in general or blacks, or immigrants in general or Mexicans in specific, depending on how specific the issues in question are. The words become "incorrect" when either used for no reason (why did you need to mention the race of a person doing that annoyed you on the street, for example?), or using the words that are racial slurs used specifically to offend.

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by tomp on Saturday October 13, 2012 @08:09PM (#4650163)
I'm not running around calling overweight people fat and offending them... It's rather neutral, really. Simply, when describing people, I might say blond, if the person is blond, or I might say fat, if the person is fat.

Maybe if we all start saying what we think, either fat or overweight (I prefer fat because it's shorter), and stop putting so much pressure on the issue, the society would be a much better place to live. For fat people and others that live "unconventional" lifestyles.

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by zerostar07 on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:28PM (#4648904)
Just wanted to remind you that this post was about sexism at work, NOT about sexual harassment.
Re:A different take on sexism in IT by saraid216 on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:30PM (#4648911)
I wish I could draw you a Venn diagram. There'd be a circle that's labelled "sexism at work" and a circle labelled "sexual harassment" and there'd be a bloody overlap between the two circles.
Re:A different take on sexism in IT by zerostar07 on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:37PM (#4648929)
Well the article is obviously about the rest of the venn circle. Sexual harassment is a crime not restricted to the IT community.
Re:A different take on sexism in IT by baxrob on Saturday October 13, 2012 @03:21PM (#4649409)
Some candidates in these ten pages: http://thisisindexed.com/category/women/ ?
Re:A different take on sexism in IT by ktizo on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:44PM (#4648955)
Here, I made one.

( sexism at work { [ professional golf ] ) sexual harassment }

Re:A different take on sexism in IT by baxrob on Saturday October 13, 2012 @03:07PM (#4649370)
Thank you! Well said, arkitaip.