News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @08:51AM (#46476615)
Americans can delete Italy.

Venezuelans can't delete America.

Yes, a bit of a one way street.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by Lapra on Saturday January 03, 2026 @09:50AM (#46477296)
> Americans can delete Italy.

Boy, Americans really do have an overinflated sense of their power.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hearsathought on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:13AM (#46477572)
There are american military bases all over italy already...
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:12AM (#46477560)
What would actually happen?
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by saubeidl on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:36AM (#46478595)
French nukes would happen.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by Aloisius on Saturday January 03, 2026 @12:52PM (#46479465)
Mutually assured destruction is still a thing.

These hypotheticals aren't helpful though.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by saubeidl on Saturday January 03, 2026 @12:57PM (#46479523)
Exactly. That's what protects the EU from this scenario.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by Aloisius on Saturday January 03, 2026 @02:35PM (#46480621)
It limits both sides involved in a conflict from using nuclear weapons first.

As history has clearly shown, it doesn't do much to prevent conventional wars, especially involving third parties.

I don't think anyone in power truly believes that France would actually use nuclear weapons to protect Italy during a conventional war against a nuclear power when France itself isn't in danger - let alone in a war Italy started. That's a no-win scenario for France.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by saubeidl on Saturday January 03, 2026 @03:23PM (#46481139)
Italy isn't a third party. They're both EU states. French nuclear doctrine is specifically the only one with nuclear first strikes as response to conventional threats.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by solenoid0937 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @04:16PM (#46481657)
If push comes to shove, I believe France is incredibly unlikely to actually attack the US with nuclear weapons regardless of what happens to Italy.

Doctrines and policies are meaningless under pressure. Would France risk global nuclear armageddon and the near-extinction of humanity for Italy? Almost certainly not, regardless of what their "doctrine" says.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by saubeidl on Saturday January 03, 2026 @04:35PM (#46481868)
If the US attacks Italy, humanity is already lost.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by solenoid0937 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @04:39PM (#46481895)
Fully agreed. We are just discussing hypotheticals.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by Aloisius on Saturday January 03, 2026 @07:03PM (#46483220)
They are a third party. The EU isn't a country, it's an association and it's clear that solitary between member countries only goes so far.

We saw what happened when France triggered the mutual defense clause in the EU charter after the terrorist attacked. Even when they all but begged other EU states to help them, they were rebuffed.

There's little reason to believe France would behave any differently if the roles had been reversed in the especially if there was any real risk to themselves if they got involved.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by saubeidl on Saturday January 03, 2026 @07:21PM (#46483359)
The EU isn't an association, it's a Union.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hermanzegerman on Saturday January 03, 2026 @09:09AM (#46476831)
If Americans delete Italy they will be the Pariah of the world for a very long time
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @09:15AM (#46476922)
Maybe, but it's still the reason Italy can't bomb America.

The rest of the world wouldn't do anything about it either, IMO. Just like they're doing for Ukraine now.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hermanzegerman on Saturday January 03, 2026 @09:20AM (#46476976)
Hundreds of billions in support, massively increased defense spending, and hefty sanctions are obviously nothing..

Also much more people have been to Italy,or at least know the country and it's culture compared to Ukraine. So the Fallout in Public Opinion would be way worse. China would also be salivating at an Opportunity to isolate the US, and that would be one presented on a silver platter

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:00AM (#46477432)
If America decided to wipe Italy off the map, you would be happy for the UK to send some money? That would be enough?

I don't think you can impose enough diplomatic sanctions on America to make us care, and certainly not enough to make up for deleting Italy.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hermanzegerman on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:13AM (#46477571)
If you would be sanctioned into oblivion like North Korea, you would probably care at some point.

Attacking one of the world largest Western economies, would turn the other ones against you

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:21AM (#46477676)
Yeah, I would care, but like I said, don't think the Western countries can accomplish that.

I'm just talking about reality. America can do pretty close to whatever it wants.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by trinix912 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:50AM (#46478001)
China doesn't like them, Russia doesn't like them, the EU would immediately pass sanctions as it is its own territory, who else is really left? Canada and Mexico?
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hermanzegerman on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:20AM (#46478380)
Well the Canadians certainly didn't forgot all those threats about becoming the 51st State.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:11AM (#46478270)
Countries would be scrambling to team with the USA IMO. You see the same happen for obvious "bad actors" now.

There's more than four non-European countries in the world, Christ.

Also, I think America can make it on its own, no help. And still be a powerhouse. You don't have to agree.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by trinix912 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:39AM (#46478628)
> Countries would be scrambling to team with the USA IMO. You see the same happen for obvious "bad actors" now.

I honestly don't see that happening. Yes, there are Hungary and Poland, but if Italy - currently a US ally - got wiped off the map for some lame reason, why would or should anyone trust their alliance with the US?

Non-EU European countries also have mixed feelings about the US (and the West in general). See Serbia for example.

> Also, I think America can make it on its own, no help. And still be a powerhouse. You don't have to agree.

Yes, I'll disagree. We once had the whole making-it-on-our-own story in many countries in Eastern Europe. There were numerous shortages of even the most basic household items like fabric softeners and coffee. Many of those countries even had some trade between each other (Comecon) but it wasn't enough and that was 50+ years ago when we weren't dependent on China for electronics and every other piece of plastic out there.

The world is now more globalized and codependent than ever. You don't have to agree with me either.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by hermanzegerman on Saturday January 03, 2026 @12:55PM (#46479507)
They would scramble if the US would be trustworthy Allies. The Problem is, that under Trump they act irrational, and unpredictable.

Also no Nation can't make it on their own in 2026 without massive losses in Quality of Life

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by stoneforger on Saturday January 03, 2026 @09:31AM (#46477092)
Public opinion is dead, what matters is policy makers opinion on controlling financial interests in the West, and what the CCP politbureau thinks. One is a mongrel divisive semi-hereditary plutocracy, the other is a reimagined empire that clearly has a long game going. I don't think anyone cares for the public at large, at least to the extent the public doesn't get any wild ideas like having an opinion and expressing it with a pitchfork.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by lisdexan on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:19AM (#46477647)
Wiping off Italy for no reason is enough to trigger a French nuclear response.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by sejje on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:35AM (#46477836)
Can it hit us?
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by vegabook on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:25AM (#46478441)
Absolutely. Submarine launched and with 10000km range it doesn’t even have to be in open seas. Now France would get obliterated too in response but we’re talking a scenario where the US has already « deleted » Italy so the game theory leans fatalistic
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by t-3 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @12:23PM (#46479173)
Modern nukes explode high in the atmosphere, so "hitting" is not very difficult. They aren't exactly precision weapons.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by ceejayoz on Saturday January 03, 2026 @05:00PM (#46482130)
They are quite precise - a hundred meters or so. Air bursts just do more damage.
Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Saturday January 03, 2026 @01:34PM (#46479953)
That would result in the obliteration of France?

You really think the French are going to sacrifice themselves to avenge the Italians?

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by lisdexan on Saturday January 03, 2026 @03:26PM (#46481160)
>That would result in the obliteration of France?

To be clear, if we are talking about a salt-the-earth level conventional bombing for pure annexation / genocide of a EU nation the French would:

1. Remind the US via diplomatic means that they have nuclear subs and the will to use them.

2. If ignored, select some non-mainland territory (PR or Hawaii) and make a ultimatum. Mention that if the US does not desist they will wipe it, but will not launch attacks on the continental US.

3. Repeat 2 until they stop or escalate.

The French would absolutely do this, the thing you propose is so beyond the pale (even now) that the only conclusion is that the French would be next.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by themaninthedark on Saturday January 03, 2026 @07:13PM (#46483286)
Hypothetical was: So if Americans don't like Trump then, say, Italy can unilaterally bomb San Francisco?

Response was: Yes, Italy could choose to do so. However, American would probably delete Italy if Italy made that choice.

So France would not be looking at the US deleting Italy for no reason.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by lisdexan on Saturday January 03, 2026 @08:06PM (#46483677)
Yes, you're right. It just that the comparison with Ukraine (invaded for no rational reason) + 'wiping out' made me think sejje was making a stronger (?) hypothetical.

I think we're have strayed too far from the point of ´might makes right' is bad, actually. GP very clearly chose Italy as an example because it's less polemic than the obvious option with a enormous manufacturing base and nukes.

Re:Venezuela's capital hit by explosions, smoke seen by anon291 on Saturday January 03, 2026 @12:04PM (#46478946)
Pariahship only really matter if you care. Look at both India and China. For the past 80 years countries cared about being pariahs because there was only one real country: the United States of America. Today, there are a handful of truly sovereign countries (America, China, India, Russia, Ukraine, Iran, North Korea) who will actually defend themselves without resorting to nominal allies .

In the normal state of human affairs, being a pariah doesn't matter as long as your goals get done