News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by halostatue on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @01:31PM (#46436356)
> The whole decision seems like a joke to me and a lost opportunity to set a decent design standard.

That would require that the individuals involved actually have taste. Instead, as with everything else from this administration, it's a toot on their favourite dog whistle.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @02:27PM (#46436948)
Donald Trump and, frankly, those around him in general are what poor people think rich people are like, but I wouldn’t exactly be one to claim that the design language used by the Biden Administration, like switching to Calibri, are very tasteful either. In leftist popular culture there is a love for modernist style architecture, minimalism, and a disrespect for building beautiful things that cost a lot of money or time. Rightwing circles have their own problems here too, to be fair.

But mandating Greco-Roman architecture by the Trump administration for federal buildings was actually a huge win for taste and design. Though unfortunately many people have become confused about what good design is or the reason to choose that architecture style can’t be overcome by their distaste for President Trump or his administration, which is very arguably deserved based on their conduct, speech, or mannerisms.

When we take away formality or tradition from governmental institutions you take away pieces of civilization and governmental authority that we, really can’t afford to lose. When government buildings are designed to look like shit, for example, one might come to believe the government is shit too (Democrat or Republican run) and the next thing you know you’re running red lights or flipping off the court because the document they sent you in the mail doesn’t look scary and official.

Secretary Duffy was right too about airline travel. Well, there is another to unpack there. Flying is lame compared to rail unless you’re flying across the country, and being shaken down by the TSA is undignified and thus people dress to meet the lack of dignity and respect the government shows them at the airline terminal.

But he’s not wrong.

When you put more care into how you dress you instinctively put more care into how you treat others and how you dress impacts how others treat you. I’m not suggesting a mandate or anything, but I’ll fly in a suit and tie easily and comfortably all day long over stained sweatpants and bringing my comfort dog on to the flight to annoy everyone. Dress how you want, but if you can’t take care of the basics I’m not sure where else you think society is going other than downhill in a fashion.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by jfengel on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @02:59PM (#46437314)
I do find it faintly ironic that Sort Of Greek Or Roman Or Something architecture was the villain in Ayn Rand's novel.

Living here in DC I don't especially mind Federalist Architecture, even though it does look like somebody saw some photos of Rome and Athens and kinda mashed them together. But I don't love insisting that a 19th century view of the second century BC must forevermore be the only possible taste.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @04:05PM (#46437993)
If you have another architectural style for western civilization which bases its institutions on Greece and Rome, I’d be interested in learning more about it. It’s not necessarily about a 19th century view of 2nd century BC architectural concepts (which itself is a bit of a farce of a comment) but more so about anchoring the longevity and legitimacy of governmental institutions to a historical heritage.

Similarly I wouldn’t recommend, say, that the Afghani people or Mongolia for example build federalist or Greco-Roman style architecture for their government buildings as it wouldn’t make much sense and wouldn’t have any basis in their history.

There’s also some science to it and we know the asymmetrical buildings and buildings which make entrances and other expected features hard to find cause measurable levels of stress and anxiety in the observer. Hostile architecture.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by donkeybeer on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @02:07AM (#46442084)
Because its not real. He is completely right its a 19th century cargo cult of classicism. Its a modern anachronistic mashup of various old styles, I can bet if you asked an actual Greek or Roman era expert they will say these buildings combine elements 500 600 years apart.

I like how it looks but its also lazy and cheesy, I can't blame people who think we need more styles.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:35AM (#46445650)
You’re missing the point. The styles aren’t meant to be 1-1 matches of Greek or Roman architecture, they’re rather good attempts at building and designing our governments buildings which that they harken to where our legal and cultural traditions hail from. That’s why the Capitol looks the way it does.

I’m not sure how that’s lazy or cheesy. I’m certainly open minded to other styles but they need to be rooted in western civilization. Otherwise you wind up with silly things like replicas of the Eiffel Tower in weirdly designed and inappropriate little French mockup towns, or you wind up with the lowest common denominator - Wal-Mart and strip malls.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by donkeybeer on Thursday January 01, 2026 @12:14AM (#46451506)
Its literally in the name, neoclassicism. All I am saying is why did you say its "farcical" that its a modern view of an old style?

I think it is a lazy copy paste of old tropes. I know because I can see these tendencies in myself too. I like some old styles and if I had my way I could keep listening to newer bands that replicate this style my whole life. But the thing is, without the original inspirational fire behind the style its just a nice copy.

I see you had dissed on brutalism some time before, I really don't understand why. I feel at least in some ways brutalism is a non-pastiche manner achieves things like the imposing sense of grandeur and power of classical architecture.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by redwall_hp on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @03:46AM (#46442481)
> If you have another architectural style for western civilization which bases its institutions on Greece and Rome, I’d be interested in learning more about it.

Carolingian architecture didn't just cargo cult, they literally pilfered Roman columns and integrated them into anachronistic designs. If I recall my art history class correctly, the columns from Charlemagne's Palatine Chapel were "repurposed" (looted) from a Roman temple. [1]

This is also an example of architectural skeuomorphism: designing something in a way reminiscent of an older thing, to borrow the associations people have with it. In this case, Roman authority.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palatine_Chapel,_Aachen#/media...

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:36AM (#46445657)
Yea great example and really cool building. Too bad we don’t build nice things anymore. It’s a shame our oligarch class is so uncultured and stupid.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by gorgolo on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @04:49AM (#46442770)
I don’t mind the overall point of your argument, but it’s funny to see a claim that Americans have more reason to use Greco-Roman architecture than a Middle Eastern country. Classical Greek art actually took a lot of influence from the Middle East, and I believe Alexander actually reached te area around Afghanistan (and a Hellenistic kingdom existed there for a while), unlike America.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @08:30AM (#46443901)
Well I wouldn’t argue Afghanistan is part of the Middle East culturally or geographically, but even if you did want to argue that, Alexander came and conquered that area for a little bit and then left. It wasn’t ever really culturally Greek.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by gorgolo on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @05:17PM (#46448935)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greco-Bactrian_Kingdom

But the main point isn’t whether afghanistan is Greek; it’s not of course. The main point is that it’s funny to hear an American argue that the US has more of a claim on Greek architecture than Afghanistan.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by anthk on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @08:17PM (#46440231)
As an European, seeing modern American airports with Greco-Roman architecture makes the environment tacky as hell. As something from Las Vegas.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @11:00PM (#46441117)
As an American I think they’re tacky too. That style of architecture for an airport doesn’t make sense really. Well. I bet it could be pulled off. But the “architects” designing the airports are the same people designing Greco-Roman architecture on disfigured American McMansions.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by anthk on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @07:45AM (#46443638)
Art Decó, on the other hand, would look pretty Americana and elegant for your buildings. It's basically the classical American city depiction for Europeans (noir movies, Superman, old comic strips from newspapers...)
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @08:32AM (#46443915)
Yea I don’t mind Art Deco at all. I think the car company Cadillac, which is based in the Detroit area, which is in my mind where I think of as the home of that style (even if it’s not), started including Art Deco as part of their design language and I think it’s a good use.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by enaaem on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @06:03AM (#46443163)
I prefer the protestant restrained aesthetic. Spiritual over material. Governmental buildings should be tastefully humble. It is a signal that the government is a servant of the people.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:39AM (#46445691)
What’s an example that you’re thinking of? I think this can make sense - I mean if you have a town of 5,000 people and a government office there or something you probably don’t need a big, giant, building (unless that’s the message you’re trying to send). It’s also impractical from a cost-standpoint.

Federal buildings though should have gravitas and signify importance. If they don’t, and/or we think the government isn’t important, I’ll take my tax dollars back, thank you very much.

You can liken this to how western countries are leaving Christianity. Who can believe in God when you drive a Jeep to your mega church next to Costco and everyone is wearing sweatpants? (I’m not particularly spiritual but I see the problems here)

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by enaaem on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @01:55PM (#46447093)
In Europe, Protestant churches are generally built much more humble than Catholic ones, because they are built with different philosophies in mind. (I am not familiar with American churches, so no comments there)

Similarly, I prefer government buildings to go for a similar route. It doesn’t mean that buildings have to ugly or small. But similar to Protestant churches it can humble, functional and elegant at the same time.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by potato3732842 on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @09:16AM (#46444229)
The leftists think trump is a dictator. The right thinks trump is an irresponsibly spending warmonger. And everyone thinks the entire damn government is rife with all sorts of bad things.

What Trump and Friends(TM) are doing here is basically stylizing the government to mimic things people associate with legitimacy since that's in short supply to the government these days. Serif fonts that harken back to when documents were for serious things and handwriting was the less formal format. Greco-roman government buildings and other "antique-ish" styles that subtly imply the legitimacy of the institution therein always has been and always will be.

Likewise I would bet a lot of money that over the next 20yr we don't see many/any 1920s-60s government buildings renovated to remove that aesthetic because people associate those decades with government that seemingly was functional.

Your last paragraph has it totally backwards. The government puts on this huge stupid show of looking big and important and fancy in order to distance itself from the fact that at the end of the day it's an organization that's fairly capriciously deploying violence.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:31AM (#46445604)
Well, to encapsulate your point here - you don’t believe in the legitimacy of government so of course any attempt by the government to legitimize itself you’d find disagreeable. Is that right?
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by potato3732842 on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @01:07PM (#46446633)
Legitimacy isn't a binary, especially not across a nation of many millions.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by ericmay on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @01:17PM (#46446727)
Sure but now I don’t know what you’re talking about or what point you’re trying to make.
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by potato3732842 on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @01:33PM (#46446873)
Projecting an image of legitimacy behooves the government because it makes everything they do (and there is almost always someone who loses dearly whenever the government does something) that much less likely to be resisted. Government is always pushing at the limits of its authority or at least going right up to them so just "seeming" a little more legitimate in the minds of as many people as possible pays back because at the margin that turns into a bunch of fights you don't have to fight, all the work you don't have to do to justify your actions, the appeals that aren't filed, etc, etc.

Think about how HN just takes whatever the EPA says at face value vs scrutinizing ICE. Every office, department, etc, etc, aspires to get the EPA treatment from as much of society as possible. Acting the part is part is part of that.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by techblueberry on Friday January 02, 2026 @06:03PM (#46470593)
> In leftist popular culture there is a love for modernist style architecture, minimalism, and a disrespect for building beautiful things that cost a lot of money or time.

Which leftist popular culture? I mean sure, there was bauhaus, but it’s not like banks are putting up neo-gothic office buildings, they’re putting up spires of glass.

Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by pseudohadamard on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @06:16AM (#46443217)
Nah, it's just the US reinventing the German Antiqua-Fraktur dispute from more than a century ago, where only Fraktur was appropriate for expressing serious Germanic ideas. A sans typeface is un-German... ahh, un-American!
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by mananaysiempre on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @02:34PM (#46447477)
Of course, a couple of decades after that, Fraktur was declared too Jewish and thoroughly eradicated, killing among other things the sole remaining independent strain of Latin-script handwriting (other than the dominant one invented as a book-copying aid by the Italian humanists, thus “italic”).
Re:Calibri Wasn't Fit for the State Department; Neither Is T... by pseudohadamard on Friday January 02, 2026 @09:29AM (#46465066)
Wasn't it mostly Hitler's personal dislike for it? That and the fact that readers in the greater Reich (the bits outside Germany) wouldn't be familiar with, or able to read, Fraktur