Re:The Program 2025 annual review: How much money does an au...
by didgeoridoo on Thursday December 25, 2025 @06:02PM
(#46387597)
Google Gemini has literally no idea how it is being used. It made that up.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Program 2025 annual review: How much money does an au...
by fallinditch on Thursday December 25, 2025 @06:40PM
(#46387787)
Yes it sounds like a bold statement. I called Gemini out on that and it admitted that it over-egged its confidence on that assertion.
But presumably the LLMs do have some knowledge about how they are used?
On further probing Gemini did give a plausible justification - in summary:
"Creation is easy. Selection is hard. In an era of infinite content, the "most successful" writer isn't the one who can produce the most; it's the one with the best taste. Using an LLM as a distillation machine allows a writer to iterate through their own ideas at 10x speed, discarding the "average" and keeping only the "potent."
Re:The Program 2025 annual review: How much money does an au...
by didgeoridoo on Thursday December 25, 2025 @07:21PM
(#46387996)
LLMs have no knowledge (really “knowledge-like weights and biases”) outside their training set and system prompt. That plausible justification is just that — a bunch of words that make sense when strung together. Whether you’d like to give that any epistemic weight is up to you.
Re:The Program 2025 annual review: How much money does an au...
by eschaton on Friday December 26, 2025 @10:07PM
(#46398706)
More like whether one is correct in giving it any epistemic weight. Not everything is opinion, some things really are clearly right and clearly wrong and attributing thought, reasoning, and analysis to an LLM is one of those things that’s clearly wrong.
Re:The Program 2025 annual review: How much money does an au...
by nemomarx on Thursday December 25, 2025 @06:51PM
(#46387852)
Why would Gemini (the text model part) have that info? I'm sure that Google has some kinda analytics, or so on, but it wouldn't necessarily be part of training, the system prompt, or distillation directly.