News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:04PM (#4637913)
If your video delivery company isn't already supporting user-transparent alternatives to Flash at this late date, you should probably be looking for a different video delivery company.

It looks like Brightcove does support mobile (at least they claim to) so what's the big deal? Can't they just deliver different content for the new IE, the same way they are presumably already doing for the other non-Flash platforms?

I'd be royally pissed if they told me it was my responsibility to get my site whitelisted with Microsoft.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by Rabidgremlin on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:08PM (#4637925)
Its all about the DRM. Flash is the only viable way of streaming with enough protection that keeps rights-holders happy :(

Video on the web would be a lot simpler if DRM/content protection would die die die...

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by wwweston on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:27PM (#4638022)
> Flash is the only viable way of streaming with enough protection that keeps rights-holders happy :(

Silverlight seems to work out for Netflix.

> Video on the web would be a lot simpler if DRM/content protection would die die die...

Let's say it did. What web standard (particularly that IE10 implements) makes it relatively easy to implement even non-protected streaming?

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by wmf on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:34PM (#4638058)
What web standard (particularly that IE10 implements) makes it relatively easy to implement even non-protected streaming?

HTML5 (video tag), H.264, and (coming soon) DASH.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by okaramian on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:52PM (#4638131)
Only progressive delivery if you're talking about IE10.
Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by w1ntermute on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:30PM (#4638034)
> Silverlight seems to work out for Netflix.

Silverlight doesn't run on Android or iOS either, so I don't see how it's an improvement over Flash in this regard.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:34PM (#4638061)
Silverlight doesn't run in IE10 Metro either (Or Windows Phone).

http://www.geek.com/articles/news/internet-explorer-10-metro...

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by okaramian on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:33PM (#4638052)
So, having teams rewrite everything for a different proprietary framework because people "don't like Flash" is somehow a viable alternative?
Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by threedaymonk on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:20PM (#4637984)
I'm not even convinced that these supremely ignorant "rights holders" really exist, except in scary tales handed down from one generation to the next. I mean, surely they don't think their "protection" is actually working, do they? Have they never been on the internet?

RTMPE was cracked years ago (the handshaking consists of little more than sending an HMAC of a magic string and the player file)[1].

It's all just obfuscation. Putting a transparent layer over the video and obfuscating the file name will achieve the same effect, that is, preventing casual downloads. That's all they've got at the moment, even with Flash "DRM".

1. http://lkcl.net/rtmp/RTMPE.txt

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by PeterisP on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @05:12PM (#4638216)
They do exist; and the rules basically amount "use a whitelisted DRM solution or don't get our content".

A solution that you believe to be good and secure but that they haven't validated can't be used; and that validation takes significant time and money.

And you can't really force your terms on DRM unless you are Apple - even multinational cable companies (that have been distributing the same content on cable for decades) have the same problems for any IP-based transmission, even for them the content providers have all the trumps, and any changes can be negotiated (paying a lot for removing each restriction) only with the next round of content deals every 3-5 years or so.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by Rabidgremlin on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:34PM (#4638067)
Oh they exist believe me... Working with a local broadcaster you run into all sorts of things like:

1) You didn't buy the streaming rights

2) You can only put it on line X days after broadcasting it

3) You can only keep it online for X days

4) All data packets sent to user must be transient, encrypted and not cacheable (that's a fun one to try get right )

5) etc etc etc

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by objclxt on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:23PM (#4637996)
"I'm not even convinced that these supremely ignorant "rights holders" really exist, except in scary tales handed down from one generation to the next"

I do some work in the mobile space around rights protected video. Trust me, they exist. Particularly if the content you're handling isn't on public release yet.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by objclxt on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:21PM (#4637991)
Yes - the problem really lies with the rights holders here. Because when constrained by the restrictions put in place by content holders you're really faced with two options for mobile DRM video: use Flash (which few devices support, and none well), or use a native app (Netflix, etc). But since it's rather unlikely a DRM solution through the <video> tag is going to be supported by all (any?) browser vendors, the buck really does stop with the rights holders.
Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by stephengillie on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:21PM (#4637987)
This is just because html5 doesn't have a way of hiding the video stream from the html source, right?

Hasn't anyone figured out how to proxy it, or only allow a connection to the hosting server if the browser has a specific cookie, or some other way of obfuscating the video's URL?

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by wmf on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:31PM (#4638041)
I'm sure there are JS-based obfuscation techniques, but Hollywood's approval process is probably highly political. So developing fake HTML5 DRM costs X, but getting it approved may cost zero (if you're Steve Jobs), 10X, 100X, or infinity.
Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by cjbos on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:38PM (#4638084)
HBO and pretty much any major Network all have iOS apps.

HLS streaming can be protected, you can encrypt the chunks and decrypt on the player. Ironically enough for my previous job I built a HLS prototype solution that did exactly this... in the Flash Player.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by jiggy2011 on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:44PM (#4638107)
Did you find that approach to be effective at all?

If you are decrypting on the player then the decryption key must be on the clients device. What is to stop them grabbing the key from memory and ripping the stream anyway?

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by cjbos on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @05:02PM (#4638174)
Yeah, it was just a prototype to protect live video streaming on Android devices... Performance was pretty bad and so the frame rate was pretty low. I think it would work decently for desktop Flash. JW Player have a HLS plugin for Flash which is pretty good, a lot more fleshed out than my prototype ended up being.

Apple do something similar http://developer.apple.com/library/ios/#documentation/Networ... this approach is more secure than what we de (Restrict access to the manifest file and have Flash request the current key when needed at runtime).

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by jiggy2011 on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @05:12PM (#4638222)
I can see that that could work on a locked down iOS device but a rooted android phone would surely be able to access to manifest file and make a copy of the keys and stream contents.

After all you only need one device to copy the stream and re-stream DRM free to others.

Re:Mobile version of IE10 won’t run Flash by default by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:41PM (#4638101)
> HBO and pretty much any major Network all have iOS apps.

What does that have to do with anything?