News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @11:16AM (#4636675)
"the lattice spacing imposes some additional features on the spectrum. The most striking feature... the cosmic rays would travel preferentially along the axes of the lattice, so we wouldn't see them equally in all directions. "

That assumes an awful lot about a simulation which by definition is not even in this universe. Maybe they would detect a simulation which has those features, but the assumption that it would work like that, because that's how we'd do it here and now in this 3-d space is I think a very tenuous one.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by ken on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @11:34AM (#4636776)
The article does admit this later on: "the calculations by Beane and co are not without some important caveats. One problem is that the computer lattice may be constructed in an entirely different way to the one envisaged by these guys."

Another problem I see is that a lattice might be evidence of a simulation, or it might simply be fundamental. It would seem strange, but no stranger to me than some other aspects of quantum physics.

What's the difference between a truly fundamental principle, and a principle that is fundamental in our world because it's part of a simulation? How could you tell?

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by stephengillie on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:24PM (#4637003)
I'm visualizing "lattice" the way latitudes and longitudes delineate Earth into a lattice. Except we live on a 2-sphere, which is the surface of a ball - the 3d projection of a circle.

First, some background. The problem with all simulations is that the laws of physics, which appear continuous, have to be superimposed onto a discrete three dimensional lattice which advances in steps of time.

What if the lattice revealed is a 4-sphere or 6-sphere? What would that tell us?

Edit: rewrote to address parent post...

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by ken on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:47PM (#4637134)
Only if you assume there's an inherent connection between the simulation and reality. I've written and run Conway's Life before, but because it was fun, not because it was an accurate simulation of reality.

In a world that has virtually unlimited computational power, who's to say there wasn't some teenager who got bored on the weekend and said "hey, what if I ran Simulation.app for 10 billion years of simulated time, but with only 4 fundamental forces, and 3 dimensions of space"?

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by dllthomas on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:26PM (#4637012)
Spotting a lattice wouldn't be conclusive by any means, but it would be some evidence for the simulation hypothesis, because it would be more likely in that situation than others. I... don't know how we estimate how much more likely.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Cushman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:11PM (#4636942)
That's pretty much the claim, right? Not that this will determine whether or not the universe is a simulation, but that it may determine that it is-- or at least probably is. Simulationism is predicated on the hypothesis that we could construct a completely accurate simulation of our universe in our universe, as if recursively-simulated universes are possible it becomes vanishingly unlikely that we do not live in one, so demonstrating that that's possible would be pretty important.

Personally, my money's on the universe is a simulation of itself.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by jemfinch on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:28PM (#4637026)
It's not actually a true statement to say that "if recursively-simulated universes are possible it becomes vanishingly unlikely that we do not live in one."

Yes, I've read Bostrom's paper[0], but he misses a key point: the number of rational beings in each simulated universe may decrease exponentially. If, on average over all universes, each rational being simulates only 0.5 rational beings during his or her lifetime, the total number of simulated rational beings would be exactly equal to the total number of unsimulated rational beings, making it equally plausible that we are in the root universe or one of the simulations.

The possibility that rational beings diminish in number exponentially as universes are simulated seems not only plausible, but likely given the nature of the simulations necessary to replicate our universe in all its detail.

[0] http://www.simulation-argument.com/simulation.html

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Cushman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:58PM (#4637187)
I think it might be heading down the wrong path to talk in terms of "rational beings" as atomic units rather than in terms of energy (or rather information) balance.

Remember that you do live in a simulation of the universe so compressed it fits between your ears, and it does contain many simulations of other rational actors. They're nowhere near as complex as your whole universe, but I bet they're complex enough to know that they're complex enough.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:01PM (#4637903)
I don't see how this philosophical argument is going to change anything. Each human has a rather small finite number of 'rational beings' they can handle processing at once. It doesn't recurse very well, the limit is a total. The exponential argument against simulation is unaffected.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by voodoomagicman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @02:57PM (#4637665)
Are you implying that concepts of people in your mind are themselves self aware?
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by bduerst on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @03:51PM (#4637861)
Do you think that I am self aware?

Can you predict where I am going with this line of questioning?

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by ajuc on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @03:03PM (#4637683)
You are symulating them as self-aware. And what's the difference, if you can predict their actions with high accuracy?
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by gwern on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @02:06PM (#4637475)
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by jemfinch on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:23PM (#4637997)
"The glitch arises from the possibility that the average number of people living in the preposthuman phase might be different in civilizations that produce ancestor simulations than in civilizations that do not."

No, that's not the problem. The simulation argument essentially depends on the fact that a universe that reaches simulation-capability ends up simulating more rational beings than half of the beings that exist in the universe itself. But it's possible that the simulations themselves are so limited that they can only simulate some fraction of the universes' number of rational beings. In fact, that seems likely: it seems that any simulation of this universe which obeys the same laws as this universe must be smaller than this universe. "How much smaller?" is the glitch. The simulated universes have to be sufficiently large (as measured by the number of rational minds they ultimately simulate) to exceed an average of 0.5 simulated minds per real mind in order for the simulation argument to hold.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by fusiongyro on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @10:12PM (#4639050)
Exactly. To draw a computing analogy, in order for it to work we'd have to be able to make virtual machines that outperform the machines they're running on, and recursively. In order for it to work, each simulated universe would have to progress to the point we have in ours, and also be able to simulate getting to this point much faster than it took to get there itself. It quickly starts to sound like perfect compression or perpetual motion.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by diminoten on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @01:03PM (#4637207)
> Personally, my money's on the universe is a simulation of itself.

Does this, literally, mean anything at all? I struggle to find any significant value in having this knowledge. Are there any additional conclusions we can draw based on knowing that the universe is a 'simulation of itself'?

It just strikes me as tautological.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Cushman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @01:29PM (#4637320)
> It just strikes me as tautological.

Pretty much, yeah. There's as much value in it as in any kind of metaphysics, I guess; it makes it easier to get on with being an ape despite the creeping feeling that being an ape doesn't mean anything.

Basically-- I know that my experience of the universe is an interaction of the universe with itself, and that things I perceive also ~perceive me. I create the universe as it creates me, and the idea of "something" "real" "existing" outside of my experience of it doesn't make sense because none of those words make sense outside of my experience.

So my experience is a simulation, but what it is being simulated by is, in fact, my experience. Thus: A simulation of itself. It makes about as much sense as anything else.

In terms of pragmatic value? Eh. My view of philosophy is that the simplest reason to do something besides philosophy is most likely the best.

(I swear I don't sound like a crazy person in real life-- but despite my valediction, I love talking about this sort of thing.)

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by harshreality on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @07:20PM (#4638664)
You're talking about Plato's cave shadows and Korzybski's territorial map as mental simulations of the physical world? They might be called simulations, but in that sense, human perception is a very loose simulation of reality, only good enough for us to successfully inhabit our place in the universe and sometimes not even that (in the case of asylum inmates). The mind's simulation of reality is not a simulation in a scientifically practical sense.

I'm not willing to call the universe a simulation of itself. I agree with the idea of using the universe to simulate itself, though. Computer simulations are limited by accuracy and time, but if you assume arbitrary amounts of time, and if you don't need perfect accuracy (or laws of physics dictate safe time/space steps for the simulation), you can theoretically simulate arbitrarily complex physics for a brief amount of time. Sorry for stating the obvious with that, but I'd like to contrast the typical "computer simulation" idea with the following: I consider physics experiments to be attempts at using the universe (a small part of it) to simulate other parts of the universe. Computer simulations pale in comparison.

I got lost on this part of your comment: "So my experience is a simulation, but what it is being simulated by is, in fact, my experience. Thus: A simulation of itself."

Entertaining mental maps as simulations, for the sake of argument, I agree with the first part: mental (inner) experience is a simulation of sorts of the outer world. I don't understand the second half of your first sentence. The "what" that is providing your perception (inner experience) is your brain, right? I don't understand how you're making the connection that the brain is your experience. That seems like a lazy use of the word "is", and with a narrower replacement, the equivalence would not hold and you would not be able to claim "the universe simulates itself".

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by diminoten on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @03:59PM (#4637897)
Something existing outside of your experience is as simple as two kids in the third world playing together. The abstract concept of events occurring outside of your realm of perception shouldn't be novel or difficult to imagine - just think of the things you do when no one else is around, then reverse that notion.

Simulation, to me, means an approximate recreation. To say that your experience is a simulation leads me to wonder what you're a simulation of. An act can't simulate itself as it's not approximately itself, it is itself.

Words need uniqueness to be helpful as a form of communication, and if we call simulations anything acting like something else OR itself, then by calling something a simulation, you're just stating its existence, which I can't find a reason to do that can't be accomplished in a more direct way.

In other words, yes things exist. Let's not ruin the word 'simulation' trying to say so!

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by dmorgan on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @01:37PM (#4637364)
>Simulationism is predicated on the hypothesis that we could construct a completely accurate simulation of our universe in our universe, as if recursively-simulated universes are possible it becomes vanishingly unlikely that we do not live in one, so demonstrating that that's possible would be pretty important.

Actually it wouldn't have to be "a completely accurate simulation of our universe in our universe". A "somewhat accurate simulation of our universe in our universe" would also do for the statistical purposes of that premise. If you have recursively-simulated universes, even if they are not 100% like each other, it shouldn't change the probabilities, right?

That said, I don't fully agree with the main premise:

>if recursively-simulated universes are possible it becomes vanishingly unlikely that we do not live in one

Sounds to me somewhat akin to the faulty "ontological proof of the existence of God" ("Anselm defined God as "that than which nothing greater can be conceived", and then argued that this being could exist in the mind. He suggested that, if the greatest possible being exists in the mind, it must also exist in reality. If it only exists in the mind, a greater being is possible—one which exists in the mind and in reality.").

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Cushman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @01:54PM (#4637432)
It bears some similarities to the ontological argument, but it's not fundamentally grounded in ontology. It's based on the hypothesis that simulation is possible, which is testable in some sense.

Say we cook up a little Earth simulator, and it spontaneously generates a perfect being with both agency and omniscience. That would be a fair bit of evidence for the ontological argument, yes?

That's also why I say "completely accurate". A really rigorous argument relies on recursive simulation, since creating a simulation that couldn't be the universe isn't very strong evidence. (I'm typing on one right now, in fact.) If we make a completely accurate simulation, we can skip the step of proving that we can make a simulation of it, because we already did.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by sp332 on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @02:11PM (#4637489)
Anselm's ontological argument isn't faulty, it's just not very useful. It just claims that things that "really" exist are greater than things which exist only in our minds. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontological_argument#Anselm As you can see the implications are pretty weak. Maybe we should go find the greatest thing that really exists and declare it to be God.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by ktizo on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:29PM (#4637032)
"if recursively-simulated universes are possible it becomes vanishingly unlikely that we do not live in one"

That depends on the probability of a given universe or simulated universe to contain a simulated universe, and what limits there are with the complexity in space and time on each recursive simulation. I suspect that thermodynamics saves us here.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Cushman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @01:10PM (#4637238)
It gets a bit metaphysical, but consider how many more possible universes there are in a universe which is likely to generate a recursive simulation than in one which is not.

That is, the probability that the probability of being in a simulation is high in a given possible universe is, itself, high, ad infinitum, if simulation is possible, hence again why being able to simulate our universe is an important point of evidence.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by mbateman on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @11:31AM (#4636755)
Strongly agree. Equally tenuous is the converse idea: that if we did detect some features of the physical world that were also apparent in a simulated lattice, that the best explanation for this is that we exist in a simulation.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by jamieb on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @04:04PM (#4637914)
The world used to be flat, but fortunately They migrated to a bigger server just before we had developed the mathematics to prove it, so now we all think the earth has always been round. Now that They can see us talking about it, expect Them to fix the cosmic-ray bug before we can test it. I can practically see the JIRA tickets.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by robbiep on Thursday October 11, 2012 @12:55AM (#4639466)
The old school mystics discovered some flaws in the rules as well, hence the transmutation of materials and levitation... However now they hot-patch and perform roll-backs... Which we see as deja-vous
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by Yhippa on Thursday October 11, 2012 @12:57AM (#4639473)
I agree. Just be sure to file them here: http://blogs.atlassian.com/2012/09/hr-developer-jira-real-li....
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by tlb on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @03:07PM (#4637697)
Their abstract starts, "Observable consequences of the hypothesis that the observed universe is a numerical simulation performed on a cubic space-time lattice or grid are explored." They're not saying that's how it works, but since that's one of the few ways we can imagine simulating the universe, it's reasonable to look for its signature.

I've always thought there must be better ways of simulating the universe than starting a 3D CA at the big bang and running it forward a few billion years in femtosecond increments until something interesting happens.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by herdrick on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @04:36AM (#4663621)
If the computer were fast enough, that'd be the easiest way to do it.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by codeflo on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @11:37AM (#4636787)
I agree, but actually, it's not even possible to draw a uniform 3D grid through the universe because of the curvature of spacetime. So even if the universe is a simulation, I don't think it could possibly work the way they describe and show the kind of artifact that they measure.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by rayval on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @12:52PM (#4637165)
Yes, it's possible that a simulation would use a non-uniform lattice-like data structure. Maybe something like a quad-tree (with appropriate dimensionality) where the granularity of the structure varies according to the local density of data.

Granted, such a data structure would need to be expressed in a coordinate system, which itself defines a grid or matrix. But can't coordinate systems use non-uniform representations? (analogous to floating-point)

Am neither physicist nor CS person, so not sure all of this holds together, just wondering.

Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by gfodor on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @02:25PM (#4637539)
Be sure to email the physics PhDs who published this paper to let them know of this flaw you have found.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by codeflo on Wednesday October 10, 2012 @02:51PM (#4637637)
Be sure to leave it at that snide remark and not actually explain the flaw in my reasoning, so that I can avoid learning something.
Re:The Measurement That Would Reveal The Universe As A Compu... by gfodor on Thursday October 11, 2012 @02:11AM (#4639672)
The point was you made a claim not a question. As snide as my remark might have been, you're insulting the people who did this research by being so matter-of-fact'ly dismissive of their work based upon a very basic observation that they surely must have considered.