For cleanly surfacing errors, overcommit=2 is a bad choice. For most servers, it's much better to leave overcommit on, but make the OOM killer always target your primary service/container, using oom-score-adj, and/or memory.oom.group to take out the whole cgroup. This way, you get to cleanly combine your OOM condition handling with the general failure case and can restart everything from a known foundation, instead of trying to soldier on while possibly lacking some piece of support infrastructure that is necessary but usually invisible.
Taken from a SO post:
# Create a cgroup
mkdir /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/my_cgroup
# Add the process to it
echo $PID > /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/my_cgroup/cgroup.procs
# Set the limit to 40MB
echo $((40 \* 1024 \* 1024)) > /sys/fs/cgroup/memory/my_cgroup/memory.limit_in_bytes
Linux is so beautiful. Unix is. Systemd is like a person with makeup plastered 1" thick all over their face. It detracts, obscures the natural beauty, and is just a lot of work for no reason.have you checked what your `vm.overcommit_ratio` is? If its < 100%, then you will get OOM kills even if plenty of RAM is free since the default is 50 i.e. 50% of RAM can be COMMITTED and no more.
curious what kind of failures you are alluding to.
Thanks for the tip about vm.overcommit_ratio though, I think it's set to the default.
In fairness, i don't know what else general purpose software is supposed to do here other than die. Its not like there is a graceful way to handle insufficient memory to run the program.
But in practice, I agree with you. This is just not worth it. So much work to handle it properly everywhere and it is really difficult to test every malloc failures.
So that's where an OOM killer might have a better strategy than just letting the last program that happen to allocate memory last to fail.
You can and maybe even should disable overcommit this way when running postgres on the server (and only a minimum of what you would these days call sidecar processes (monitoring and backup agents, etc.) on the same host/kernel), but once you have a typical zoo of stuff using dynamic languages living there, you WILL blow someone's leg off.