News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made... by nairboon on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:50AM (#46315156)
The incentives are alright. Publishers who now start publishing too much low quality slop will lose readers (who has time to read all those low quality publications). Less readers leads to less citations, which will drag dawn their impact factor resulting in less authors willing to pay a high publication fee.

For those fields with an existing market, meaning there is more than one high quality journal, the market will provide the right incentives for those publishers.

Re:Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made... by zipy124 on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:38PM (#46315916)
For academia's sake I hope you are correct, but my experience of the system leads me to suspect otherwise, though only time will tell.

One hope might be that it incentivises institutions away from the publish or perish mind set and starts to discourage salami slicing and other such practices, allowing researchers to focus on putting out less work of a higher quality, but I suspect the fees would need to be larger to start seeing this sort of change.

Re:Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made... by hbplawinski on Thursday December 18, 2025 @04:14PM (#46318818)
I doubt that this is true except maybe for the top journals. Mid and low tier journals cater to scientists whose main incentive is to publish no matter how while moderately optimizing for impact factor (i.e. readers and citations). This lower quality market is huge. The fact that even top tier publishers have created low-ranking journals that address this market segment using APC-based open-access models shows the alignment between publisher and author interests will not necessarily lead to increasing quality, rather the opposite.
Re:Beginning January 2026, all ACM publications will be made... by nairboon on Friday December 19, 2025 @08:42AM (#46325761)
Does anyone actually read articles from those low tier journals? Many of those articles are illegible fluff pieces.

That top tier publishers create new low-tier journals for this market shows that they are very well aware of these incentives and risks. They are not flooding their top journals with low quality OA "pay to publish" articles, which was the argument from OP.