News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How well do you know C++ auto type deduction? by 1718627440 on Monday December 15, 2025 @10:25AM (#46275689)
I think IDEs are a moving target. Do you consider syntax highlighting to make something an IDE? Macro expansion? Autocomplete? intellisense-like based on full text search? based on a parser? based on the compiler? Is Kate an editor or an IDE? It has LSP support.

Having syntax highlighting makes me slightly faster, but I want to still be able to understand things, when looking at a diff or working over SSH and using cat.

Re:How well do you know C++ auto type deduction? by pjmlp on Monday December 15, 2025 @11:39AM (#46276776)
Nope, that is a programmer's editor.
Re:How well do you know C++ auto type deduction? by 1718627440 on Monday December 15, 2025 @02:50PM (#46279511)
I agree, but that means, that even complete integration of the compiler does not make an IDE. So the only distinguishing feature I can think of is startup time /s .
Re:How well do you know C++ auto type deduction? by addaon on Monday December 15, 2025 @03:12PM (#46279880)
An IDE, by name, integrates the development environment. Depending on target, development lifecycle usually includes writing code, generating binaries, pushing those binaries to the target, executing on the target, and debugging on the target; so an IDE includes editing, compiling, linking, device/JTAG drivers, and debugging, in my mind. I suppose for platforms without cross-compilation the device drivers vanish, and for languages without compilers and linkers similar; but at a minimum, development means both authoring and debugging code, and so an IDE must provide an integrated view of the debugging process.
Re:How well do you know C++ auto type deduction? by 1718627440 on Monday December 15, 2025 @03:22PM (#46280026)
Then that distinction doesn't match the original claim, that readability of unlabeled code doesn't matter, since we now have IDEs, as this is an orthogonal matter according to your definition.