News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by alyx on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:46PM (#4619570)
To be fair, the guy who owns that site did mention that it wasn't meant to be picked up by HN and was still in the early stages of development.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by philwelch on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:48PM (#4619575)
If it's accessible on the public internet and asks for something as secure as API keys, that is when you should worry about security, not when it's "meant to be picked up by HN".
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by alyx on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:54PM (#4619595)
Fair, but in any case, the ultimate responsibility still lies with the user's judgment.

Maybe if there was a service promised but not rendered, could you place full blame on the developer(s).

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by shardling on Saturday October 06, 2012 @10:43AM (#4620638)
What exactly does "ultimate responsibility" even mean here?
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by philwelch on Monday October 08, 2012 @02:23AM (#4625725)
It's not a matter of assigning blame, it's a matter of not delivering a shitty service to your customers.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by adgar2 on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:30PM (#4619682)
Exactly. When you go to provide your information to a website, you need to consider "what are all the possible outcomes of this?" We can't use the reputation of the providers of a service as a proxy and thus have zero information about what to expect. Since you almost never have the source code for the website you're giving your information to, using your logic, just never give your data out. Right?
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by kooshball on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:50PM (#4619582)
I have mixed feeling about this.

On one hand we all want to move quickly, get users, add new features, etc etc.

On the other, security issues like this are just so vital that nothing else really matter if your data is not secure. It's especially true for a BACKUP SERVICE that promises ridiculous stuff like "99.999999999%" uptime on the frontpage.

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by smeagol on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:12PM (#4619638)
we're incredibly sorry about all of this.

honestly, this was all accidental. it was a pet project we started to toy with Glacier and a week later i accidentally hit the Like button sending a ping to my friends on FB. bless my friends for being so influential i guess. shame on us for using Rails carelessly.

if you have any experience with startups, you'll know that 99% of the things you launch go nowhere--this project was no different. we honestly thought our site was of absolutely no consequence. we're truly thankful so many people found it useful, but trust me we're sorry there was a hole.

however, just to be clear:

- about 20 accounts were exposed, including me and my buddy - i emailed all of them, and wiped out the credentials - they quickly responded (i saw the updates come in)

thankfully, AWS is designed for such situations. with a few clicks, people deactivated their credentials (both IAM and main account) and regenerated new credentials. the fact that all the early signups were techies who know their way around AWS really saved us.

one more thing: the correct quote is:

"Glacier is built for durability of 99.999999999%"

also: i agree with ryan--don't trust 10-minute old startups :-)

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by adriand on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:20PM (#4619660)
Classy response. Now here's your chance to take lemons and make lemonade. Clearly your pet project is something that people find really interesting and useful. So it went public before you intended and had some security flaws: oh well, that's in the past now. Write your mea culpa about how much you learned from this experience, hit the front page of HN again, sign up a bunch of users, and go get some venture capital. Good luck!
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by AVTizzle on Saturday October 06, 2012 @12:25AM (#4619792)
Couldn't agree more. There is a silver lining here is thick. Leverage it and win.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by justindocanto on Saturday October 06, 2012 @03:39AM (#4620033)
Somebody fund this guys 'how to make lemonade' book right now. Best advice on here.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by jspthrowaway on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:28PM (#4619677)
Contacted a PR person in between the last thread and this one, I'm guessing? That's a rapid 180.

You have a long way to go in my mind, in terms of fixing the initial response. You probably have help now, which is great, but your initial kneejerk demonstrates underlying trouble to me which you need to fix.

You're in a tough spot, too, because you can't delete those godawful comments without looking suspicious.

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by smeagol on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:44PM (#4619718)
huh? you realize this was a pet project right? we're two dudes with no jobs.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by jspthrowaway on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:47PM (#4619728)
You repeatedly write some form of that assertion (we're two nerds) as if it is supposed to excuse something. I honestly couldn't give a rat's ass regarding who you are. I care about your actions and your actions alone. Stop making excuses!

I'd like you to apologize not only for the disclosure, but also to the reporter for how you treated him in the other thread. The entire other thread of your responses is disgusting, and you don't get to write it off because of your gender, quantity, or employment status. Own your comments and stop excusing them with that bullshit line.

I have to admit that I would also be pleased if your service disappeared until you're working with somebody who has a little more experience with secure Web applications; this mistake betrays your experience. Since we all started somewhere, though, I can only hope you fix this on your own.

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by whyleyc on Saturday October 06, 2012 @04:15AM (#4620083)
Why did you share Ryan's email address in a previous comment and why have't you deleted it yet ?
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by hollerith on Saturday October 06, 2012 @07:17AM (#4620272)
On Hacker News, you cannot delete or edit a comment except during the first 2 hours of the comment's existence.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by whyleyc on Saturday October 06, 2012 @09:38AM (#4620481)
Which answers part two of my question but not part one ...
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by hollerith on Saturday October 06, 2012 @11:50AM (#4620808)
Right. We're still waiting for an answer to why he published his critic's email address.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by mintplant on Saturday October 06, 2012 @02:04PM (#4621179)
Knee-jerk reaction?
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by kooshball on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:42PM (#4619713)
To be honest this is a much better response than the previous on in the other thread.

Also, can you explain what "Glacier is built for durability of 99.999999999%" actually means, if not uptime?

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by biot on Saturday October 06, 2012 @03:52AM (#4620049)
Think of durability like the bank telling you that your money is 99.99999999% secure in their vault, but you can only access it from 9 to 5, Monday to Friday. The bank's "uptime" is really low (40 hours / 168 hours * 100%) but your money's "durability" is quite high.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by smeagol on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:46PM (#4619725)
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by anonymouz on Saturday October 06, 2012 @08:46AM (#4620375)
Thanks, I would find it helpful if you could also explain that on your homepage. The statement "Amazon Glacier is designed to provide average annual durability of 99.999999999% for an archive" is quite clear and meaningful, but "Glacier is built for durability of 99.999999999%" just seems like a non-sensical marketing blurb.

If I got my math right, this means that they expect to lose on average about 10 bytes per stored terabyte per year. (Of course these losses, should they occur, would probably be not uniformely distributed).

Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by Evbn on Saturday October 06, 2012 @11:43AM (#4620777)
Yeah, it is more like 1 file in a 100 billion gets lost.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by notatoad on Friday October 05, 2012 @11:51PM (#4619734)
still... developing an application and then bolting on some security over top of it later seems like a recipe for disaster. And pushing it to a public server before any security has been implemented is a very stupid thing to do.
Re:Never Give Your Information To 10 Minute Old Startups by danielweber on Saturday October 06, 2012 @02:47AM (#4619975)
It may have been a prototype they quickly wrote, and planned to do a heartier implementation later. And when they suddenly got onto HN's front page, a whole bunch of excitement happened and they completely forgot that this was just a prototype.

"Pushing it to a public server" is really minor. Mozilla had this issue, too, when they had a new filename technically available on a server and someone jumped the gun and told the whole world that the new version was ready. Well, it wasn't. A bunch of kids whined that it was all Mozilla's fault for having a file available on their public server, but while it's arguable that a service that is reachable by URL has no expectation of privacy, it's a hell of a lot harder to argue that having a service reachable by URL implies a warranty that it is safe to use.

Friends in the 90's would run telnet and web servers with "Username:" "Password:" "Credit Card Number:" prompts. It was funny to watch that some people would type in apparently real data, although we never verified.