News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by mikkupikku on Saturday December 06, 2025 @09:57AM (#46173802)
Was the kidney donor already dead, from something other than rabies, or were still alive for donation and later died?
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by mistersquid on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:00AM (#46173829)
> Was the kidney donor already dead, from something other than rabies, or were still alive for donation and later died?

FTA

> About five weeks later, the man started to hallucinate, have trouble walking and swallowing, and had a stiff neck, according to the C.D.C. report.

> Two days after his symptoms started, he collapsed of what was presumed to be a heart attack, the report said. The man was unresponsive and taken to a hospital, where he died.

> Several of his organs were donated, including his left kidney.

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by Ekaros on Saturday December 06, 2025 @11:34AM (#46174584)
Seems like there is some part missing in evaluation procedure. If those symptoms were know at time I don't think he was eligible donator material anymore. Or at least to me it sounds like you want to know what was the cause behind those symptoms before harvesting anything.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by spwa4 on Saturday December 06, 2025 @03:16PM (#46176291)
Can't ask an unresponsive patient who then proceeds to die what his symptoms were ...

People seem to think that the TV doctor habits of testing the most out-there diagnoses possible until you get a positive hit are normal in the real world. They're not. Especially not with medical insurer's "advice" now being required for everything.

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by Arwill on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:36AM (#46174126)
I thought only organs of people dying in accidents are donated, and not someone's dying from an illness.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by toast0 on Saturday December 06, 2025 @02:42PM (#46176036)
I think the criteria for donation are most easily met by people who die as a result of something like a vehicle collision, but an otherwise healthy person who experiences sudden heart failure may have viable organs... From the reporting, this donor was not otherwise healthy, but maybe the symptoms were not known at the time or dismissed for some reason.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by spwa4 on Saturday December 06, 2025 @03:34PM (#46176397)
Not really. Organs from people who have died are almost always nonviable. So when it comes to vehicle collision victims, only people who are slowly dieing of internal hemorrhaging are used. Sudden heart failure organs are bad for two reasons: first, if the heart actually fails, you have minutes before organs are nonviable. Second, the medication that's used for trying to keep the heart beating will actually accelerate death, including organ death, if it doesn't work.

Most organs come from from people, usually braindead, who are definitely going to die, but you have days or at least hours before the body actually loses the fight. And even then the extraction process needs to be started quickly, because in the process of dieing the body will, as it's losing blood, ie. power and oxygen, one-by-one cut off blood flow from organs to try to keep the heart, lungs and brain alive. Most organs that have had their blood flow cut off by the body can't be transplanted, so extraction needs to happen before that point.

So that was probably the case here.

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by spwa4 on Monday December 08, 2025 @07:22AM (#46191428)
(wait until you figure out the answer to the other question ... "wait, if organs after death are not used, nonviable, then what happens if I donate my body to science" ?)
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by giarc on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:36AM (#46174130)
Don't have access to NYTimes, but do they mention anything about all the other people that received an organ? I'm assuming they are tracking them down to get them rabies vaccine?
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by cxr on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:46AM (#46174201)
The donor's corneas were used for grafts for three others. The article states:

> The three patients’ grafts were removed, and one tested positive for rabies, the doctors said. None of the three patients had symptoms of rabies, but they were being treated with preventive drugs, the report said.¶ Since 1978, four organ donors have passed rabies to 13 organ recipients, the report said. Of the 13 recipients, six who received treatment for rabies survived. The seven others, who did not receive treatment, died.

Four of those seven were in an incident from May 2004, which you can read about here: <https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa043018>

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by stanski on Saturday December 06, 2025 @02:36PM (#46175999)
> We're gonna need that cornea back.

Not exactly a sentence you would hope to hear...

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by mannykannot on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:38AM (#46174147)
The donor died from rabies, and then several of his organs were donated. Furthermore: "Doctors reviewed records about the kidney donor and learned that the Idaho man’s family had disclosed the skunk scratch to doctors when his organs were being donated, the report said."
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by michael1999 on Tuesday December 09, 2025 @05:35PM (#46211663)
There are financial incentives to find/make organ donors.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by m-hodges on Saturday December 06, 2025 @09:58AM (#46173813)
The first half of the first sentence of the article:

> A man died of rabies after getting a kidney transplant from another man who died of the virus

Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by mikkupikku on Saturday December 06, 2025 @09:59AM (#46173823)
Yeah I phrases that wrong, I'm wondering if the donor was alive or if they harvested organs from somebody that was dead from rabies.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 06, 2025 @10:31AM (#46174076)
They harvested organs from somebody who had died of rabies.
Re:Kidney Recipient Dies After Transplant from Organ Donor W... by toast0 on Saturday December 06, 2025 @02:54PM (#46176125)
That sentence doesn't indicate the sequence of events. Both of the following sequences match the sentence; thus the confusion.

Sequence 1:

Day 0) Donor contributes kidney to donee

Day 10) Donor dies of rabies

Day 15) Donee dies of rabies

Sequence 2 (the incident sequence)

Day 0) Donor shows symptoms of rabies (undiagnosed)

Day 2) Donor dies of rabies (diagnosed as heart failure)

Day 2+?) Donor's kidney is installed in donee

Day N) Donee dies from rabies

Day N+M) Donor's death is reevaluted and rabies is diagnosed