News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Thursday October 04, 2012 @08:13PM (#4615097)
Let's be realistic. A civilization so advanced as to be able to capture the entire energy of a star, probably also has energy alternatives, and probably wouldn't want to attract the attention of lesser beings (like us) by trapping a star's output in a detectable way.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by enraged_camel on Thursday October 04, 2012 @08:35PM (#4615152)
I've never understood such assumptions of intelligence. "If a civilization could do X, they could also do Y and Z." Says who? It's not like we're experts in alien intelligence. How can we be, when we have never encountered one?
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:13AM (#4615867)
All true, but applying common sense still has a point. For example, do we want to broadcast the fact of our own existence across interstellar distances? This is actually an active debate topic among those who think about stuff like this.

Ironically, after a brief spell of broadcasting our existence with powerful radio and radar waves, we're gradually shutting down the big transmitters for reasons of economy and efficiency. Satellites allow us to accomplish the same end with much less power than the old high-powered transmitters, and GPS-guided aircraft makes more sense that long-range radars for all but military purposes.

There are those who argue that we should transmit the basic facts of our existence with high-powered radio transmitters and lasers, and await a reply. Others argue that we shouldn't. Both arguments have merit.

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by kamaal on Friday October 05, 2012 @06:05AM (#4616267)
>>do we want to broadcast the fact of our own existence across interstellar distances?

We are already doing it(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecibo_message). We are also sent a probe with heck lot of details on it(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_Golden_Record).

>>This is actually an active debate topic among those who think about stuff like this.

True, but we have always been sending radio signals in space and probably will continue to.

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:18PM (#4619521)
> We are already doing it ...

Yes, absolutely. It is said that, because of radar, we're the brightest object within several light-years in those wavelengths. Add to that the periodic nature of radar, and we're signaling with an obviously unnatural beacon for anyone willing to listen.

I'm just saying the debate goes on, even though we're providing quite a beacon for anyone interested in detecting signs of semi-intelligent life. :)

> True, but we have always been sending radio signals in space and probably will continue to.

I wouldn't say "always". The first reasonably strong, narrow-band radio signals commenced in the 1920s. Not even 100 years. And we're quickly reducing our EM radiation footprint for economic reasons unrelated to anything resembling policy.

I see the point of both arguments -- that we should, and shouldn't, broadcast our existence. I actually prefer the "should" argument overall, considering the difficulty that an alien species would have getting here. We might learn something remarkable from a safe remove.

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by jakeonthemove on Thursday October 04, 2012 @11:34PM (#4615564)
Sure, they could have their own nuclear fusion reactors or even something more sophisticated, but why let a perfectly good source of energy just go to waste?

I don't think they'd care that anyone could detect them if they're that advanced...

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:07AM (#4615858)
> Sure, they could have their own nuclear fusion reactors or even something more sophisticated, but why let a perfectly good source of energy just go to waste?

TO avoid detection by some other warlike species?

Regardless of the alienness of a life form, there are certain principles one can rely on, under average circumstances:

* Resource aren't infinite anywhere, and an intelligent species won't deliberately waste resources.

* No civilization is invulnerable.

* The duration of existence of any lifeform is finite.

There will always be outliers, but if we're after a set of reliable assumptions, these are on the list.

> I don't think they'd care that anyone could detect them if they're that advanced...

If you wrap a star in collection surfaces, thermodynamics dictates that the result will be a much larger surface at a lower temperature. If that isn't true, then the point of the exercise (energy collection) won't pan out.

Obviously this is rank speculation, but knowing what we do about living species, some speculations are more likely than others.

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by maxerickson on Friday October 05, 2012 @08:33AM (#4616575)
The most likely shape of interstellar war is lasergrams that say "We hate you" (but here is some harvestable energy...).

The next most likely is probably relativistic projectiles, which are dangerous in proportion to the energy required to send them (i.e., they aren't that likely a threat).

Direct invasions of civilizations that can shape the matter of an entire solar system seem pretty much destined to failure (I guess you could come in on a ship built from an entire solar system, but I wonder if you are war mongering at that point).

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by aplusbi on Thursday October 04, 2012 @11:56PM (#4615614)
Why wouldn't they want to attract the attention of lesser beings?
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:14AM (#4615870)
> Why wouldn't they want to attract the attention of lesser beings?

Because they might attract the attention of greater beings.

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by kamaal on Friday October 05, 2012 @04:00AM (#4616037)
>>Because they might attract the attention of greater beings.

As a life form we don't seem to be taking any precautions to 'hide' from others.

Why are assuming others would like to 'hide'?

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by Haplo on Friday October 05, 2012 @04:30AM (#4616084)
It could very well be that the only civilizations that still exist are the ones that are good at hiding. All the others (even if they are the big majority) might have been destroyed after giving a signal of life/existence.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by strait on Friday October 05, 2012 @03:33AM (#4615995)
Greater beings are nothing to worry about. They remain undetectable in order to preserve the lesser beings as long as possible.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by strait on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:08AM (#4615859)
I'm guessing that it's not unlike why we don't leave food out when camping in bear country. If the bear realized what we were doing (hiding food from it), then it would surely come to the bear conclusion that our behavior was unreasonable, but we know better.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by apedley on Friday October 05, 2012 @12:43AM (#4615696)
I agree. From my limited knowledge of power sources, I understand that fusion and zero point energy would provide more easily accessible and vaster amounts of energy than one could build with a huge solar collector. Solar can only go to the maximum that the sun outputs in that direction. I would speculate that alien civilizations have found far more efficient means of power than a solar array.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by gibybo on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:09AM (#4615862)
It wouldn't just be one direction, it would be a sphere around the whole star. Stars are essentially just large fusion reactors, so it would take one the size of the star to compete with it (within an order of magnitude or so).
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by grecy on Thursday October 04, 2012 @11:01PM (#4615489)
> also has energy alternatives

What's an "energy alternative" ?

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:15AM (#4615873)
Fusion is an energy alternative to coal. Wind is an energy alternative to solar, and vice versa. Things like that.
Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by grecy on Friday October 05, 2012 @03:35PM (#4618331)
Right. I get that.

Your parent comment implies they would have an "energy alternative" to... energy.

When you say "A civilization so advanced as to be able to capture the entire energy of a star, probably also has energy alternatives".

What "energy alternatives" are you talking about?

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by lutusp on Friday October 05, 2012 @10:25PM (#4619536)
> Your parent comment implies they would have an "energy alternative" to... energy.

No, not at all. A walking alternative is bicycling, not being a double amputee. A coffee alternative is tea, not dehydration.

"Energy Alternatives":

http://www.energyalternative.com/home.html

Wikipedia: Alternative Energy:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_energy

A quote: "Alternative energy is an umbrella term that refers to any source of usable energy intended to replace fuel sources without the undesired consequences of the replaced fuels."

"The energy alternative":

http://www.theenergyalternative.com/

"Alternative Energy News":

http://www.alternative-energy-news.info/

> What "energy alternatives" are you talking about?

Want more links?

Re:The Best Way to Find Aliens: Look for Their Solar Power P... by grecy on Saturday October 06, 2012 @12:00PM (#4620827)
Interestingly, you're talking about an energy alternative to solar. Do you have an example of one of those?

(My understanding is that solar is the alternative to things like coal)