News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by alberth on Thursday December 04, 2025 @09:49AM (#46148259)
Silly question: how are people negatively impacted by the trademark of "JavaScript"?

Because in practice, isn't this a bit like "Kleenex" - where everyone knows you mean "tissue" (EMCAScript).

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by StableAlkyne on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:00AM (#46148386)
It's less the fact that someone owns JS's trademark, and more that it's specifically Oracle (they got it when they bought Sun).

Oracle is an incredibly litigious company. Their awful reputation in this respect means that the JS ecosystem can never be sure they won't swoop in and attempt to demand rent someday. This is made worse by the army of lawyers they employ; even if they're completely in the wrong, whatever project they go after probably won't be able to afford a defense.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by levkk on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:14PM (#46150034)
That's why courts don't take hypothetical cases. Someone has to be injured to demonstrate actual harm.

Are there any examples of Oracle using their JavaScript trademark to sue anyone? If they did, that petition would have merit.

Unless Demo was, this feels like a marketing project. And it's working, too, so kudos.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by hoten on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:43PM (#46150460)
The other aspect here is that general knowledge (citation needed) says that if a company doesn't actively defend their trademark, they often won't be able to keep it if challenged in court. Or perhaps general knowledge is wrong.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by anematode on Thursday December 04, 2025 @02:15PM (#46151567)
It's the specter of a lawsuit that's the problem.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by wongarsu on Thursday December 04, 2025 @02:26PM (#46151683)
Trademark law is kind of about hypotheticals though. The purpose of a trademark is to prevent theoretical damages from potential confusion, neither of which you ever have to show to be real

In this case the trademark existing and belonging to Oracle is creating more confusion than no trademark existing, so deleting it is morally right. And because Oracle isn't actually enforcing it it is also legally right

Imho this is just the prelude to get better press. "We filed a petition to delete the JavaScript trademark" doesn't sound nearly as good as "We collected 100k signatures for a letter to Oracle and only got silence, now we formally petition the USPTO". It's also a great opportunity to find pro-bono legal council or someone who would help fund the petition

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by amelius on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:39AM (#46148832)
At this point I'm going to assume that adding -Script to a trademarked name allows me to use that name freely.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by riwsky on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:58AM (#46149032)
JavaScriptScript?
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by joshjje on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:22AM (#46149340)
JavaScript-Script
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by underscoremark on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:34AM (#46149510)
Kleenex-Script
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by RiverCrochet on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:44AM (#46149628)
Oracl3Script?
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by amelius on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:58PM (#46150643)
Yeah, that's how I'm going to call my LLM-based law-firm.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by lkjqweflkjh on Thursday December 04, 2025 @01:40PM (#46151185)
Turn it around: Scriptacle.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by tshaddox on Thursday December 04, 2025 @01:17PM (#46150871)
Unless that suffixed version is itself already trademarked, like AppleScript.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by bobbylarrybobby on Thursday December 04, 2025 @04:09PM (#46153108)
iPhoneScript should be fine though?
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by onion2k on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:23AM (#46148651)
Assuming Oracle did decide to go down that route, who would they sue? No one really uses the JavaScript name in anything official except for "JavaScriptCore" that Apple ships with Webkit.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by chuckadams on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:10PM (#46149974)
> who would they sue

Anyone they feel like. Lawnmower gonna mow.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by Orygin on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:28AM (#46148708)
Afaik they already sued Deno: https://deno.com/blog/deno-v-oracle2

Edit: Seems I'm incorrect, see below

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by saghm on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:31AM (#46148747)
I had no idea this was a thing! I'm surprised this didn't attract more attention.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by Orygin on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:35AM (#46148781)
My bad, after reading more it seems Deno is trying to get Oracle's trademark revoked, but I found out that "Rust for Javascript" devs have received a cease and desist from Oracle regarding the JS trademark, which may have triggered Deno to go after Oracle.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by TeaVMFan on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:55AM (#46148997)
The incredibly litigious company here is Deno. Deno sued on a whim, realized they were massively unprepared, then asked the public to fund a legal campaign that will benefit Deno themselves, a for-profit, VC-backed company.

This personal vendetta will likely end with the community unable to use the term JavaScript. Nobody should support this.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by striking on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:20AM (#46149303)
Your comment seems incredibly confused.

1. Oracle is the litigious one here. My favorite example is that time they attacked a professor for publishing less-than-glowing benchmarks of their database: https://danluu.com/anon-benchmark/ What's to stop them from suing anyone using the term JavaScript in a way that isn't blessed by them? That's what Deno is trying to protect against.

2. Deno is filing a petition to cancel the trademark, not claim it themselves. This would return it to the public commons.

It should be obvious from these two facts that any member of the public that uses JavaScript should support this, regardless of what they think of Deno-the-company.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by jakelazaroff on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:03AM (#46149076)
> This personal vendetta will likely end with the community unable to use the term JavaScript. Nobody should support this.

Why would that be the case, if not for Oracle's litigiousness?

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by DonHopkins on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:48PM (#46150519)
Hi Larry Ellison! Will you mow my lawn?
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by rdtsc on Thursday December 04, 2025 @02:18PM (#46151596)
> Oracle is an incredibly litigious company. Their awful reputation in this respect means that the JS ecosystem can never be sure they won't swoop in and attempt to demand rent someday. This is made worse by the army of lawyers they employ; even if they're completely in the wrong, whatever project they go after probably won't be able to afford a defense.

That is why on one level I am surprised by the petition. They are talking to a supercharged litigation monster and are asking it "Dear Oracle, ... We urge you to release the mark into the public domain". You know what a litigation happy behemoth does in that case? It goes asks some AI to write a "Javascript: as She Is Spoke" junk book on Amazon just so they can hang on to the trademark. Before they didn't care but now that someone pointed it out, they'll go out of their way to assert their usage of it.

On the other hand, maybe someone there cares about their image and would be happy to improve it in the tech community's eyes...

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by thayne on Thursday December 04, 2025 @02:39PM (#46151859)
> It goes asks some AI to write a "Javascript: as She Is Spoke" junk book on Amazon just so they can hang on to the trademark.

IANAL, but I don't think that wouldn't be enough to keep the trademark.

Also the petition was a "we'll ask nicely first so we can all avoid the hastle and expense of legal procedings", they are now in the process of getting the trademark invalidated, but Oracle, illogically but perhaps unsurprisingly is fighting it.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by rdtsc on Thursday December 04, 2025 @02:56PM (#46152115)
I was just using it as an example of doing the absolute minimum. They could write a dumb Javascript debugger or something with minimal effort.

But yeah, IANAL either and just guessing, I just know Oracle is shady and if you challenge them legally they'll throw their weight around. And not sure if responding to a challenge with a new "product" is enough to reset the clock on it. Hopefully a the judge will see through their tricks.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by dev0p on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:29AM (#46148721)
The fact that you wrote it wrong is hilariously ironic.

JavaScript is simply the better term, and marketing is everything. Reminds me of Java's POJOs, which was a very simple pattern that no one used, until someone gave them a fancy name.

ECMAScript is a horrible technical name. Might as well call it ACMEScript considering how willie e. coyote it feels to develop with it...

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by DANmode on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:48AM (#46149673)
ACME is actually better, because you can say or read it in under 5 business days.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by echelon on Thursday December 04, 2025 @04:42PM (#46153487)
I've heard people say "Eczema Script" in jest.

ECMAScript is a horrible name. It's worse than Google Bard.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by msgilligan on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:29AM (#46149430)
POJO is one of my favorite acronyms. Along with POTS and COTS.

POTS = Plain Old Telephony System COTS = Commercial Off-The-Shelf

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by garyrob on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:57AM (#46149791)
> POTS = Plain Old Telephony System I worked for NY Telephone for years in the '80s, and it was referred to there as "Plain Old Telephone Service" not System. Not that it's a big deal at this point!
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by seniorThrowaway on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:59PM (#46150646)
I started my career as a telecom tech in the mid Atlantic (late 90's) and can confirm it was that for me too
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by jagged-chisel on Thursday December 04, 2025 @03:57PM (#46152966)
My understanding is that the Service was provided by the System.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by msgilligan on Thursday December 04, 2025 @09:03PM (#46156034)
I was in the ballpark!
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by pwdisswordfishy on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:47AM (#46148891)
> Might as well call it ACMEScript considering how willie e. coyote it feels to develop with it...

And it would feel just the same if it was named something else.

It's just a name, who gives a damn?

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by hshdhdhj4444 on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:05AM (#46149106)
> It's just a name, who gives a damn?

This is extremely ironic given that JavaScript was so named because people do give a damn about names so Netscape/Sun leveraged the Java success to push JS, hence they named it JAVAscript despite it having nothing to do with Java.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by bad_haircut72 on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:19AM (#46149289)
it sounds like eczema - naming your programming language after a skin condition is not a great choice

nothing against people with eczema of course

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by sionisrecur on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:50AM (#46148934)
Call it "Jay Ess". Everyone does already.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by 7bit on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:12PM (#46150011)
> everyone knows

Not everybody knows. People who learn JavaScript don't know. In fact, they must learn this. And from my experience, most learning resources don't mention this, let alone teach this. It took me a really long time to understand what ECMAScript is and how it relates to JavaScript. And the effort I put in this understanding... I would have preferred to not having needed that.

So no, not everybody knows this.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by jama211 on Thursday December 04, 2025 @01:18PM (#46150890)
It’s possible that it also really doesn’t matter that much to the majority of people
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by cachius on Thursday December 04, 2025 @05:35PM (#46154122)
ECMAScript:JavaScript :: You-Know-Who:Lord Voldemort
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by 9rx on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:36AM (#46148794)
> Because in practice, isn't this a bit like "Kleenex"

Maybe. That's what the challenge intends to find out.

Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by jtwaleson on Thursday December 04, 2025 @10:07AM (#46148483)
EMCA -> ECMA
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by mlok on Thursday December 04, 2025 @11:45AM (#46149644)
True. And that's also a reason why "Javascript" is more human friendly tbh.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by recursive on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:25PM (#46150185)
One reason it's less friendly is that lots people think it has anything to do with java.
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by 9rx on Thursday December 04, 2025 @12:55PM (#46150612)
Europe-Canada-Mexico Agreement?
Re:Good news: JavaScript is 30yo today Sad news: its own nam... by Timwi on Thursday December 04, 2025 @05:52PM (#46154303)
“Easy Cancellation” My Ass