News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by dmor on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:15PM (#4613575)
You probably would not get hired.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by kevin_morrill on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:19PM (#4613596)
Actually, people that think about this for a while are the ones I like the most. The people that race right in without thinking about it tend to perform the worst.

One of the very best candidates I saw actually just wrote their outline on the whiteboard from the start. When I asked them a distracting question they paused a second, looked at the whiteboard, and said "Wait a minute, this will stop us from finishing in 5 minutes. Would you like me to answer this or finish?"

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by jamesbritt on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:23PM (#4613617)
You probably would not get hired.

Probably not. But what does that say about this particular technique?

There's the ability to explain something, and there's the ability to perform under sudden pressure.

I would give candidates some period of time (say, 10 minutes, if they needed that long) to select a topic first.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by ctdonath on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:37PM (#4613688)
You've scheduled a half-hour with a candidate (or explain why longer), and you're going to sit in silence for 10 minutes just so s/he can pick a starting point for a 5 minute monolog on any topic?

Given the option to talk about anything, I'd be concerned if the candidate couldn't pick something in 10 seconds. Summary of last book read, semantic difference between method calls in C++ vs Objective-C, sewing, recreational ballistics, sociopolitical solutions to poverty, ... something? I could spend the allotted 5 minutes just reviewing topics I could go on for 5 minutes about.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by jamesbritt on Thursday October 04, 2012 @04:39PM (#4614266)
Given the option to talk about anything, I'd be concerned if the candidate couldn't pick something in 10 seconds.

I'd be concerned if they could. It might suggest they are not all that interested in too many things. Or are hyper-focused on just one thing.

There are two things at work here. Picking something you are interested in, and deciding if you can actually explain it well in five minutes. Figuring out the latter would take me easily more than 10 seconds.

It's not a matter of picking something you can on about for five minutes. It's about be able to explain it to someone with no prior knowledge, and have them understand what the hell you were talking, and what's most important about it, when you are done.

Now that the article is back up, it see it has this:

Take as much time as you want to think it through, and let me know when you want to start.

So another question is, is it better to allow "as much time as you want", or set some time limit in picking the topic?

Practically speaking, if someone is still musing after an hour I think the jig is up, so there's at least some practical upper limit. But how does it influence the candidate to think there is a fixed prep time versus having unlimited time?

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by nerfhammer on Thursday October 04, 2012 @04:08PM (#4614117)
What would you be concerned about?

Giving a spontaneous monologue to someone judging you is something many people actually find quite intimidating, even though some others may find it quite natural. It's something they teach in toastmasters or improv classes.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by ctdonath on Thursday October 04, 2012 @04:35PM (#4614240)
It's part of social success (and business, from development to sales, is a social activity). There WILL be times when a moment will occur where you must take a barely-formed thought and run with it, taking someone else from zero to competence, in mere minutes; to not do so is to miss a valuable opportunity. Be it making an unexpected sales pitch, explaining a non-obvious technical solution that just occurred to you during a design meeting, discussing last night's political debate, or describing your hobby to an attractive new acquaintance, success often depends on succinct explanations without preparation.

The point of the exercise isn't the content per se, it's the demonstration of ability to present concepts (any concept) clearly, and perhaps convincingly, on short notice.

Yes, it can be intimidating. Yes, it's an unplanned speech to a judgmental audience; such is the real world. There's a reason it's taught as a tool for success. I had to figure it out on my own. Survival and success can depend on it.

Heck, here I am taking 5 minutes, unexpectedly, trying to explain to you - a judgmental audience - regarding a random topic. If you get my point (convincing notwithstanding) then I pass the test. If a candidate can't do likewise on the topic of his choice, I can't expect as much when the topic is not.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by nerfhammer on Friday October 05, 2012 @02:05PM (#4617943)
It sounds like you're saying that it seems like it should be diagnostic vaguely of "success" or "survival".

Perhaps it might have negative values as well. Part of the trick seems to be to turn off critical thinking for awhile, not reconsidering your assumptions, turning off self-doubt or sounding confident, or being strategically vague. Skills I would value in a salesperson, but not necessarily an engineer.

Since all of these ideas are introspective and the output variable is unspecific I don't see a good way to make a decision about the usefulness of this test.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by nialo on Thursday October 04, 2012 @03:22PM (#4613891)
Having a thing that you can talk for 5 minutes about and being able to actually _pick just one thing_ under sudden pressure are very different things. I understand the time pressure issues, but understand that you are also testing this other skill of being able to respond with that questions.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by vacri on Thursday October 04, 2012 @09:15PM (#4615243)
It's not "pick a topic to discuss", it's "pick a topic that you can spend five minutes doing a complete lesson on", sprung as a surprise question.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by mason55 on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:58PM (#4613765)
> I would give candidates some period of time (say, 10 minutes, if they needed that long) to select a topic first.

It appears you would not be hired because of your lack of reading comprehension.

The article clearly states that you have as much time as you want to gather your thoughts and it's a bad sign if a candidate starts right away.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by bduerst on Thursday October 04, 2012 @03:08PM (#4613811)
The article is down, is it not?

Edit: NVM, the website is back up.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by jamesbritt on Thursday October 04, 2012 @04:43PM (#4614297)
It was down when I was posting, and I went off a shortened version of the question as summarized in another comment.

People late to the discussion may want to consider reading more comments before sniping at earlier posts.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by mgkimsal on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:29PM (#4613647)
I'm not sure going in to a job interview is 'sudden pressure'. You've often had days or weeks in preparation for that 30-60 minute meeting.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by freehunter on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:50PM (#4613728)
But it's not a common question, and wildly uncommon questions in an interview can cause even great minds to seize. Interviewing for a tech support job years ago was the most difficult interview I'd ever been in, because the manager didn't stick to the script, so to speak. He threw out random questions, completely unrelated to the job, in a rapid fire manner. Just to see if he could throw you off, to see if he could get you to seize. What is your favorite book? I like the Hitchhiker's Gu-What was the last song playing on your drive over here? It was Lola by The Ki-What color shirt are you wearing, without looking down?

You can prepare for an interview. And the interviewer can prepare to surprise you. The sudden pressure is when you're asked an important question that you had no knowledge was going to be asked.

Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by king_magic on Thursday October 04, 2012 @02:29PM (#4613646)
Well, at the same time, I wouldn't be able to do my job if I didn't have the ability to perform under sudden pressure.
Re:The Most Revealing Job Interview Question by vacri on Thursday October 04, 2012 @09:17PM (#4615250)
There are different kinds of pressure. I went to lunch with a coworker who was very good at dealing with the pressure of running the shipping pipeline. Someone started having a seizure in front of us. I stepped in and dealt with it (ex-neuro) while she was paralysed and unable to do anything but watch in horror.