Furthermore, prestigious universities with powerful alumni networks provide informational advantages, and alumni probably favor fellow alumni in business and recruitment. (That reminds me, maybe I should start reconnecting with college mates to look for a job...)
I don't think the above is cynical - I think it's just realistic.
I did my undergrad from an insignificant public school in a third world country, but secured my masters (by research, no coursework) from one of the top 30 schools from that list and it was an enlightening experience.
To say the truth, I have learned most of the undergrad craps by myself (thanks to our local book markets teeming with pirated/photocopied books) -- in my case, the contribution from the so called "good teachers" is almost none. the "quality of teaching" is a very subtle concept and thers is no apparently good way to measure it. I think it is the "research" that should matter the most. Above all, no one is interested in average GPA of students.
The result of this is I have a significant debt (though less than you get from a US college), and an education which is completely sub par.
Interesting. This is definitely in agreement with the point that many "[research]" universities exist for the research and not for learning/growth outcomes. If only a better solution existed...
The reason I like lots of different rankings using lots of different criteria and weighting is that the tend to dilute the impact of any one single ranking.
The reality is that people pay a lot of attention to rankings. Right now, US News and World Report does have an outsized impact on how people think of universities. And as a lot of people know, not a single public university shows up on their rankings.
For instance, UC schools tend to have very well regarded faculty and graduate programs. The undergraduate programs are good too, but these schools admit large numbers of in-state students. The downside is that admissions standards are lower as a result, the upside is that far more low income students get a crack at an education at a true research university.
US News rewards private research universities with very small undergraduate student bodies for the resulting "eliteness" of undergraduate admissions, which is actually ok. But does Berkeley or UCLA get any credit for enrolling more low income students than the entire ivy league each? No, not a bit, but they do get dinged for the impact on their numbers, which is how a university that is in the top 5 for almost every department still ends up outside the top 2.
Then you have the Washington Monthly rankings, which perhaps over-emphasize this (along with graduate programs in engineering and science) and are stacked with top public research universities - though it doesn't get anywhere close to the US News kind of attention. Honestly, it is a little silly to see Harvard ranked so low. But it underscores how different a conclusion you can reach with very reasonable measurements.
And then you have international rankings like this one, or the USNRC which tend to emphasize scholarship and research, and so forth.
I guess I'd say I'd prefer to see no numerical rankings, but if we have to have them, I'd like so many that it becomes clear that numerical rankings may be measuring very different things and that no single list has an outsized impact on the way people perceive universities.
At best I suppose you could think of it as a kind of pat on the back for universities which do a good job generally. Give them a bit of kudos and publicity etc. That doesn't really do that much for the top-tier schools, but it might give some under-appreciated schools welcome attention.
Whether this ranking is more relevant to researchers or students you'd have to look at the methodology but they are very closely related anyway.
The reason people hate rankings is most people(Bit above 50%)are below average intelligence or go to a below average university hence they hate it when it's pointed out to them.
Even smart people still suffer for thinking they are more intelligent than they are hence they too do not like being rated.
In summary, the truth is yes you are better off going to a higher rated university if external factors are equal. But most people can't handle the truth so it's up to you what you believe.
Sorry, what? Presuming that "intelligence" is normally distributed, then exactly half of the population will be above average and half below. By your thinking the top 50% should love rankings.
I think the problem with rankings is that there's no foolproof metrics of comparison, so there will also be some grumbling.
I very much hope universities aren't shallow and lacking of a reasonable vision and mission to the point of requiring some random generic ranking to motivate efforts to improve.
Many students might, however, be motivated by such things. That is, anyway, until they realize it's probably not a good strategy. Ie. If I want to become a lawyer or politician, I don't go to MIT; if I want to become a software engineer, I don't go to [insert random high ranking university without an engineering related program].
>> ...the truth is yes you are better off going to a higher rated university if external factors are equal.
I'm curious what you mean by "if external factors are equal"? What external factors? Do you mean "if all universities had the same mission and vision, same degree programs, same culture, are located in the same place, attract the same type of students, etc."? I can agree with you then. However, I believe the fact is that the "external factors" are actually very, very different (back to my original comment).
Actually, going to MIT is fine if you want to be a lawyer, as long as you get good grades at MIT and do well on the LSAT.
The LSAT part should be easy. For the kind of person that goes to MIT, the LSAT is a fun test.
Grades might be a problem, as MIT is not, I hear, the place to go for an easy A. However, if you can get good grades there, the MIT background should stand out with the law school admissions people, because they don't see a lot of applicants from MIT. Law touches nearly everything we do, and the top law schools recognize we need lawyers and judges with diverse backgrounds. That MIT degree will be a plus.
Amusing LSAT trivia: Physics and math majors are the highest scoring group on the LSAT, followed by philosophy and religion majors. The lowest scoring group is criminology majors, and second lowest is prelaw majors.
>> Amusing LSAT trivia: Physics and math majors are the highest scoring group on the LSAT, followed by philosophy and religion majors.
Philosophy majors are surprising high on the "Best Undergrad College Degrees By Salary" list (http://www.payscale.com/2008-best-colleges/degrees.asp), with a mid-career median ahead of every other major without a direct technology application.However, my university's ranking is pulled up a lot because it's medical and languages schools are amongst the best in the world. In computer science (the subject I did) it is decent but definitely not as highly ranked. But I still benefit from the "brand" my university has
Ie. Practically what am I supposed to gather by the fact that Caltech is rated #1? Or Stockholm University #117? Should that mean I would benefit from attending Caltech over Stockholm U? Or do these rankings just help see what countries/states are research university superpowers (whatever benefit that brings -- e.g. increased international competition?)?
I'm sure universities love to see themselves ranked well as it could bring them more prestige and attract better/more students. However it's extremely confusing how universities that have extremely varied missions can be measured on the exact same metrics in the exact same way, and from that form a valuable "ranking" that actually has worth.
My understanding of the purpose of measuring is largely to increase feedback to stimulate growth and learning. Do these rankings help with this? I'm not sure.
Perhaps I would be more comfortable if they would rename their ranking or define it less generally. One step forward would be to possibly form categories (or acknowledge existing categories) for universities and have one ranking table per category.
[1] I found this in one of the articles on the site: "The world of higher education is changing, and the rankings help us to make sense of what is happening. These rankings were conceived to be much more than an annual beauty parade or marketing gimmick for university recruitment offices. We are delighted to continue to deliver what we promised we would."
http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-ranki...