It's not about protecting the environment in the abstract. It's about who bears the costs of industrial activity. Loosening environmental reactions doesn't reduce costs, it shifts costs from polluters to the general public, particularly to the poorest people.
Polluting the air you breathe is no different than any other injury--if the government has any function it is to protect your bodily integrity. It is a failure of organized society when a company can profit by physically hurting you, and it's economically inefficient to allow polluting industries to shift the inherent costs of their activity onto other people. It causes companies to pick the technologies that have the most costs that can be passed to other people, not the technologies that are the most absolutely efficient.
The oil, coal, etc, industries were made possible by the intervention of government. Did you know that in the 1600s in American law pollution was basically illegal? E.g. if water ran through your property, it had to leave as clean as it went in. Allowing people to pollute during the industrial revolution was actually a tremendous government subsidy of industry.
That said our perception of air pollution may be a bit exaggerated. Atmospheric aeroforming is a very difficult task -- even if we tried actively for 500 years, I think we might have difficulty changing the composition of the earth's atmosphere significantly. Before air pollution is even a real threat, our technology will have probably progressed far enough naturally (i.e. sans government investment) to handle any problems. Keep in mind there are over 5,000,000,000,000,000,000 (5 Dectillion!) kilograms of atmosphere. Humans produce 2,500,000,000,000 kilograms of CO2 year roughly (2.5 trillion). However, each tree (on average consumes 33 kilos of CO2, and (by NASA estimate) there are roughly 400,000,000,000 trees on earth -- thus trees could consume up to 13,200,000,000,000 (13.2 trillion kilos of CO2), and CO2 is heavier than air so probably a fair amount of it reaches the ground. Even if only 1/5 of the trees processed CO2, we would still be not generating any significant amount of it. Anthropogenic global warming is mostly alarmist theory until we prove humans have a significant effect on the atmosphere (as one scientist pointed out, the earth has warmed and cooled dramatically before human existence, and it will continue to during it, despite our actions).
Also your analysis of air pollution is shockingly bad and you should feel bad. What on earth makes you think pollution mixes perfectly with the whole atmosphere before anyone breathes it in? It's like saying 2+2=cat.
Also, climate change isn't even the big issue here. I'm talking about much more mundane and also much more damaging air and water pollution from factories, cars, etc. We have very solid empirical evidence about that. Did you know that after the EPA's ban on leaded gasoline, blood lead levels in children dropped by a factor of 3-5x in just one decade? See: http://www.epa.gov/ace/body_burdens/b1-graph.html. This corresponds to a multiple IQ-point impact from lead. What's the dollar value of a multiple IQ-point impact on the nation's children (and future workforce)? It's a huge number.
Did you know that a recent Harvard Medical School study concluded that the true price of coal power factoring in the externalized environmental costs is 2-3x as much as the market price? http://www.boston.com/lifestyle/green/greenblog/2011/02/new_.... The same study found the total externalized costs of coal power to be $200-$500 billion/year: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1749-6632.2010..... Here in Chicago we recently shut down two coal-fired power plants that were causing $100 million in health damage per year and only creating 50-60 jobs each.
The total cost of environmental damage being down every year, in terms of quantifiable impact to people is probably into the trillion dollar per year range. People tend to think of environmentalism as being about "soft values" but that couldn't be further from the truth. Even if we assign zero value to the environment itself, we can't avoid putting a dollar figure on the value of the services the environment provides us. When New York manages to avoid building a $6-$8 billion filtration facility by properly managing the Catskills watershed, we can't avoid the inescapable economic conclusion that damage to the Catskills and similar watersheds needs to be valued in the billions of dollars range. We can't avoid the conclusion that when a company dumps waste into those watersheds, it's an economic injury no different than if tore up city streets or caused a bridge to collapse.
It's the government's job to protect us from all this, the same as it's the government's job to protect us from people who steal your car or break into our houses. It goes to the heart of why government exists.
http://articles.latimes.com/2012/jul/23/news/la-mo-who-inven...
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/2012/07/23/...
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=internet-pi...
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/07/wsj-mangles-histo...
And most importantly:
http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57479781-93/no-credit-for-u...
But you did.
> And don't start with arguments about the internet - it was actually Xerox that largely made the internet (sic.) possible:
But you did: "Don't do X - X."
NIST is government funded. Are they also magically excluded from having done good things?
Don't tell these companies, because they sell $10k electric cars right now:
http://www.polaris.com/en-us/gem-electric-car/Pages/Home.asp...
I wouldn't want to drive any of them. I wouldn't want to drive ANY $10k car. But you do not get to pretend "that time is not now."
Edit: overall, I have to concede, it is kind of dumb to attribute the internet to a single entity or person - it was a pretty natural progression of technology - basically the digital evolution of phone lines. Could you imagine trying to patent the internet?
If the government really wants to help out with energy, it should loosen environmental restrictions. I am as much a supporter of green tech and protecting the environment as the next guy, but there is something like 1000x the volume of natural gas under our soil as all the oil in the world combined. The sheer amount of wealth generated from tapping that resource could fund all kinds of green tech, and lessening foreign dependence creates jobs here and makes us stronger politically.