News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by buckle8017 on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:12AM (#46103704)
The ACA required health insurers to cover a laundry list of things they didn't previously cover.

It's nearly impossible to buy a legitimate low premium high deductible plan now.

The end result is we all have Cadillac plans that most people don't need.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by mulderc on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:19AM (#46103738)
Have you been on an ACA bronze plan? I wouldn’t consider it a Cadillac plan nor did I find it covering lots of unnecessary things.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by pxmpxm on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:24AM (#46103782)
Bronze plan is shitty catastrophic insurance at like 5x the actuarial cost to try to fund risk pool and all the mandated benefits thst the o/p alluded to
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by fzeroracer on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:27AM (#46103798)
Can you explain what these mandated benefits you think shouldn't be covered?
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by pxmpxm on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:38AM (#46103873)
Off the top of my head maternity/neonatal/family planning type of benefits are mandatory for obamacare compliant plans. That essentially outlawed all the affordable young adult catastrophic plans.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by runako on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:44AM (#46103912)
I have spent some time looking at healthcare costs, but I have not seen maternity/neonatal/family planning as a significant driver of costs. It would be surprising if so, given falling birthrates and growth in the elderly population.

Do you have data that shows this is the case?

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by fzeroracer on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:54AM (#46103981)
What you're, essentially, advocating for is a massive increase in premiums for families so that people without children can get a tax cut. Which would objectively benefit me, but would be incredibly disastrous for American society in general which is already struggling with insane family care costs. I would really hope you could see why the second order effects on such a change would be a bad idea.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by mulderc on Monday December 01, 2025 @08:17PM (#46116080)
I have been on both a Bronze plan and Catastrophic insurance. They are not the same at all.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by fzeroracer on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:19AM (#46103740)
> The end result is we all have Cadillac plans that most people don't need.

That's right, those pesky things the ACA says should be covered like emergency services, ambulances and prescription drugs is definitely the issue here. You've definitely found the problem.

I can't believe people keep repeating this lie. Did no one live prior to the ACA where you could easily go bankrupt because your insurance decided it didn't cover things like hospital bills? Because I sure as fuck remember, considering that's what bankrupted my parents.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by aeontech on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:20AM (#46103743)
You don't need it until you need it, and needing it often comes in the form of a lightning strike from blue sky. The counterargument is that having everyone pay a higher amount makes it feasible to actually have this coverage available, when needed, without bankrupting the insurance companies, because the rare astronomically expensive care is covered by the premiums paid by the vast majority of people who are relatively healthy and are unlikely to need it.

Now whether the on-paper prices for medical care in this country actually have any relationship to objective reality is an entirely separate question of course. In general coming from an outside perspective, combining healthcare and for-profit motives in a single system seems particularly likely to lead to all kinds of perverse incentives, but, it's the system that exists, and it seems unlikely to change any time soon.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by almosthere on Monday December 01, 2025 @01:29AM (#46104190)
What I don't understand however is what IS actually expensive about the care itself?

Doc will get paid his normal rate, $500k per year (maybe more maybe less?) Nurses all get paid something between 100k and 200k (maybe more maybe less?)

Then we hear about these surgeries that cost 100k.

What exactly is costing 100k for 5 hours of knife and time in a bed?

Wildfire, I understand, there is no way to re-materialize a house for less than (what is basically a fortune these days). But time and materials for a surgery seem to me that it should cost 5k at most?

And at those rates, wouldn't everyone just pay like $15 a month? And if the answer to this question is malpractice costs, can we have two plans:

I trust you doc: $15 / month

I might sue the doc after: $1500 / month

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by Retric on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:20AM (#46103746)
> laundry list of

That’s a meaningless statement, look for an actual percentage here.

Healthcare costs have been spiraling for decades in the US, the ACA didn’t impact the long term trends to a noticeable degree. Actual healthcare reform could drive down costs massively, but that would mean a fuck load of people in medical billing getting laid off. Instead you’re paying for your doctor to talk with your insurance provider often for longer than they spend working with you, that’s the ultimate issue with US healthcare costs. Inflation adjusted “healthcare” spending is up from 2,100$/person in 1970 to 14,570 in 2023.

https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/u-s-spe...

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by tired-turtle on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:20AM (#46103747)
That’s how insurance works. You pay for a plan you likely don’t need so everyone older than you is reasonably covered.

If young people elected to get a barebones plan while in good health, who would subsidize them when they grow older?

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dogemaster2028 on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:24AM (#46103783)
That’s not how insurance works. No insurance company coerces you to buy it, as Obama did.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dboreham on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:51AM (#46103964)
You're forced to buy auto insurance.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dogemaster2028 on Monday December 01, 2025 @03:59AM (#46105114)
You aren’t. You are required to buy LIABILITY, which is protection in case you harm SOMEONE ELSE. You are not required to protect YOURSELF.

In some states, if you can post a bond, you aren’t even required to carry liability.

The government does not coerce you to buy a product for yourself.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by nradov on Monday December 01, 2025 @01:24AM (#46104157)
Technically not. In many states you have the option of posting a refundable security deposit with the government to meet the minimum liability requirement as an alternative to purchasing auto insurance.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by nradov on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:20AM (#46103749)
The main point of health insurance is to cover things that most people don't need. Prior to the ACA, most health plans had lifetime coverage limits which could leave patients with serious conditions financially ruined or unable to access care. The ACA removed those limits so naturally coverage is now more expensive.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dogemaster2028 on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:23AM (#46103769)
This is factually incorrect and in fact the opposite of what a Cadillac plan means.

Obamacare plans are actually the opposite: they are high deductible with limited networks.

Obamacare plans typically have deductibles between $5,000 to $9,000, with a narrow selection of networks, and high premiums if unsubsidized.

This is the opposite of what a a Cadillac plan is (or used to be).

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dashundchen on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:27AM (#46103800)
What did the ACA require that shouldn't be part of healthcare in one the wealthiest countries in the world?

Annual check ups? Cancer screenings? Maternity care? Basic mental health? Forcing the insurance companies to accept patients with preexisting conditions?

These services should be available to everyone.

If a developed country cannot provide these things to its citizens it's a failing state in my book.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by dboreham on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:51AM (#46103958)
"ACA required stuff" is a fox news talking point.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by zdragnar on Monday December 01, 2025 @01:32PM (#46111085)
It would be significantly cheaper for my wife and I to have a catastrophic-coverage-only plan, but those are now illegal. Between premiums and deductibles, I think we will have to spend north of $30,000 next year before we break even and insurance actually benefits us in any way whatsoever.

You can get telehealth appointments for many things for pretty cheap via companies like GoodRx, and screenings through dedicated groups as well. My last telehealth visit (and likely my last ever) through my PCP's network charged me+my insurance $300 for a 5 minute phone call to renew a prescription I've been on for years.

ACA just solidified the health system as a quasi-private government organization with its own tax system. We could do so much better, but we're hamstrung by a feckless congress.

Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:30AM (#46103817)
Which are the specific things you think most people don't need coverage for? Prior to the ACA, it was pretty common to hear stories of people not on employer plans who were shocked to discover a coverage gap they have. Most people don't have much expertise in evaluating healthcare coverage and deciding which services they might need.
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by changoplatanero on Monday December 01, 2025 @12:42AM (#46103900)
In California, apparently acupuncture is required to be covered. I’d be happy to give up my acupuncture coverage for a lower premium. https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payer/states-essential-bene...
Re:'A full-blown crisis': Americans brace for a surge in hea... by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 01, 2025 @03:14AM (#46104798)
Same, but it’s hard to imagine these kind of alternative medicine services are driving huge premium increases. Because they don’t work they tend to be pretty cheap to provide.