Re:OCaml maintainers reject massive AI-generated pull request
by ErroneousBosh on Saturday November 29, 2025 @02:23PM
(#46090038)
I deal with something similar on about a monthly basis on a couple of projects I work on, where people will just submit a 5-digit-lines PR that's entirely AI slop and often a slightly smug "there that fixes all the problems" attitude to it.
No, it doesn't, and given that I've been a Python developer (albeit not a very good one) for 25 years now - this doesn't mean that I'm some great Python wizard, just that I know what it's pretty much supposed to look like - there's shit in there I can't even begin to decode. Why are so much of the lines of the PR just grafting in huge jumbled strings of characters? It looks like some blindingly obvious attempt to disguise a backdoor.
"Oh I don't understand all of it, I just got <AI of the Week> to do it"
Yeah. Take it out of here. Do you like having knees? Well don't bring anything like this back.
Any engineer who answers "beats me" to any question about code they "authored" should be permanently banned from contacting a compiler ever again. Jesus...
The shameless bragging "I did not write a single line of code" only cements my verdict.
I do applaud Gabriel Scherer (gasche@)'s and David Allsopp (dra27@)'s patience in trying to calmly explain this (https://github.com/ocaml/ocaml/pull/14369#issuecomment-35565..., https://github.com/ocaml/ocaml/pull/14369#issuecomment-35572...), despite clear indications that they are talking to someone with no interest in listening.
After being told that AI is not trustworthy for copyright analysis, Reymont continues unabated with "Here's the AI-written copyright analysis..." and then again with this idiocy: "AI has a very deep understanding of how this code works".
But he does not stop there...
No regard given to maintenance or existing maintainers' thoughts. No sign of introspection as to why multiple projects have already told him to take his 10KLoC AI slop dumps and go pound sand. The sneer at "folks who want thorough discussion"... No shame...I am hereby upgrading my verdict against Reymont from "no access to compilers" to "no access to computers, ever".