(I'm rusty at this, but when I read 'phase', I think of a time difference between two signals. In this case, there's no time difference.)
Side note - welcome to hacker news! Assuming your the same kortuk from the EE stack exchange I believe we've interacted a few times. My account there is: http://electronics.stackexchange.com/users/1438/mark
You should make hacker news your website on EE? Your account looks some bare there, add some information!
What do you mean by 'dead center in the mix'?
There are a lot of fun things you can do acoustically with stereo sound. Some phasing effects can actually be pretty 'tripy' for lack of a better word.
There are other ways to do this via more complex 3D acoustical modeling. Mostly focusing on modeling of reverberation effects but you don't see that much in music recording. It is used a lot in games though.
Here it happens because when the earphones' ground connection is disconnected from the source, the earpiece drivers remain connected to the L and R hot signals and their former common grounding point floats and leaves them in-series. This means that any signal present equally on L and R results in no current through the transducers. You hear only the difference signal in both ears, although to be precise, one is actually opposite in polarity.