News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by ferfumarma on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @10:50AM (#46058614)
> Still far, far too complex to occur "randomly," which is fascinating

Why spend time making this point? Nobody believes that this occurred randomly: it occurred via evolution.

The mutations are a random part of evolution, but the process overall is not random at all - no more so than your immune system (which randomly generates antibodies, then selects against those that target innate epitopes), or stable diffusion (which starts with random noise, then marches up a gradient toward a known target).

It is the selection step that makes similar processes non-random, because a random selection step would just be noise.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by threethirtytwo on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @12:14PM (#46059777)
This is technically random. The entire creationist argument is that complexity cannot come from randomness but evolution is the method in which it does.

Evolution is just a sort of way for low entropy structures to form from randomness. It’s still random all the way down.

The man is just trying to reconcile a belief in god with the scientific reality. He needs to bend the evidence to fit his identity he cannot bend his identity to fit the evidence because that could break his identity. The fact he commented here on this topic is sort of unhinged. It seems like the article presented evidence that is strikingly against his world view and he needed to justify something in order to prevent his identity from rearranging itself according to external reality.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by cozyman on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @01:05PM (#46060478)
I'd like to see some form of evidence that creatures can change kinds, it seems impossible to me, how do you account for that?
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by rcxdude on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @03:43PM (#46062097)
The entire fossil record and the mountains of shared DNA between very different creatures is pretty compelling evidence. Not to mention the idea of changing 'kinds' is an entirely human-derived categorisation, not something that has some natural definition.
[dead]
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by cozyman on Friday November 28, 2025 @11:48AM (#46080284)
This isn't convincing to me, I'm not disputing that mutations exist. Do they become different categories of being?

Macro Evolution has always seemed like a philosophy/ideology/religion to me with a veneer of science.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by threethirtytwo on Saturday November 29, 2025 @03:01PM (#46090303)
Doesn't have to be convincing to you. It's a fact and inescapable conclusion. If you're not convinced, you're wrong.

If mutations can happen, then by logic many mutations can happen, if many mutations can happen then many many mutations can stack up and cause speciation. By believing in mutations, evolution follows via logical induction.

Your DNA can be edited with many many mutations until it becomes indistinguishable from penguin DNA. Take that DNA and insert it into an zygote embryo and you get a penguin, not a human.

This is not a conclusion formed by observation. This is basic logic, 1 + 1 = 2. If the axiom is mutation, evolution is the logical theorem that follows. It is undeniable.

You have to go through a lot of mental gymnastics to deny this logic, but it's worth it if such mental gymnastics formulates a conclusion that remains inline with your religious identity. People without this bias who don't have truth tied to their identity don't need to do this kind of thing.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by fwip on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @05:25PM (#46063064)
"Change kinds" is something that only people who believe in a rather literal view of the Christian bible say, and only because that's the popular fundamentalist argument against evolution.

Fundamentally, it's impossible to reconstruct something from the fossil record that's convincing to these folks, because they will always arbitrarily decide "fossil 1 is kind X, and fossil 2 is kind Y, you need to find me fossil 1.5," no matter how close in time and likeness the fossils are.

So what they actually want is "evolve a lizard species into cats" which fundamentally misrepresents both A) how evolution works (it does not concern itself with human categories) and B) the vast timescale over which small changes accrue.

"Kinds" are just human categories we've mapped onto the results of billions of years of evolution after the fact.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by cozyman on Friday November 28, 2025 @11:44AM (#46080234)
Is there any way to demonstrate it or is it only an unfalsifiable claim that requires unfathomably long timelines?
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by akomtu on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @02:08PM (#46061186)
"It's all random all the way down" is just another religious belief. Besides, has anyone estimated the probability of creating organisms so complex using this random evolution scheme? Another problem is why would randomly-evolved organisms be so geometrically symmetric? I'd expect a random process to create an unholy blob of matter.
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by rcxdude on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @03:42PM (#46062088)
You're lacking imagination and understanding of how these systems form. Symmetry is very commonplace in nature, for very unsurprising reasons, because what's random is how the processes that create those forms change over time, not the entirety of those processes themselves. And yes, there is a huge amount of study of how life could form in the kinds of environments we think existed on earth near the start of life. ATM it's not so much 'how could this happen at all' and more 'what looks like the most likely way that it happened'.
[dead]
Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by threethirtytwo on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:33PM (#46075538)
>Look, the leap from “a human in a lab coat mixed some chemicals and got something that grows and divides” to “therefore no God (or no transcendent intelligence) is necessary for life to exist”

That is not my chain of reasoning, nor has lab created life has ever been created. So what you're saying can never be used as valid proof of creationism. And I certainly did not use that evidence to make such a claim. Additionally I never said god does exist or does not exist.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by api on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @01:25PM (#46060724)
People misread my comment as creationism.

The point I was making was that the complexity curve has to meet the floor at some point, and thinking about how this happens and what that looks like is interesting.

I was familiar with RNA world but wasn't aware of how much progress had been made.

Re:A Cell So Minimal That It Challenges Definitions of Life by andrewflnr on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @06:29PM (#46063500)
Unfortunately your comment is mostly indistinguishable from the kind of "just asking questions" thing actual creationists occasionally post. And you did draw in at least one actual creationist in your replies. Sorry dude. :D Anyway, as a couple of us mentioned, be sure to check out Nick Lane's theories.