Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns
by jcalvinowens on Friday November 21, 2025 @01:58PM
(#46007641)
I'm simply saying I think the policy you're proposing is bad. It is completely bizarre to me you're trying to frame that as a semantic argument.
Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns
by woodruffw on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:14PM
(#46007818)
I'm not saying it's a semantic argument. I'm saying that the policy isn't universal, whereas your argument appears to hinge on me thinking that it is. But this seems to have run its course.
Re:We should all be using dependency cooldowns
by jcalvinowens on Friday November 21, 2025 @02:20PM
(#46007888)
That's a semantic argument.
Me saying your proposed policy is bad is in no way predicated on any assumption you intended it to be "universal". Quite the opposite: the last thing anybody needs at work is yet another poorly justified bullshit policy they have to constantly request an "exception" to to do their job...
The argument advanced in the post is IMO clear: cooldowns are a sensible default to have, and empirically seem to be effective at mitigating the risk of compromised dependencies. I thought I took sufficient pains to be clear that they're not a panacea.