So: first, identify code that cannot be allowed to panic. Within that code, yes, in the rare case that you use [i], you need to at least try to justify why you think it'll be in bounds. But it would be better not to.
There are a couple of attempts at getting the compiler to prove that code can't panic (e.g., the no-panic crate).
I want to ban crates that panic from my dependency chain.
The language could really use an extra set of static guarantees around this. I would opt in.
Something that allows me to tag annotate a function (or my whole crate) as "no panic", and get a compile error if the function or anything it calls has a reachable panic.
This will allow it to work with many unmodified crates, as long as constant propagation can prove that any panics are unreachable. This approach will also allow crates to provide panicking and non panicking versions of their API (which many already do).
On the subject of this, I want more ability to filter out crates in our Cargo.toml. Such as a max dependency depth. Or a frozen set of dependencies that is guaranteed not to change.
Which means banning anything that allocates memory and thousands of stdlib functions/methods.
I'm fine with allocation failures. I don't want stupid unwrap()s, improper slice access, or other stupid and totally preventable behavior.
There are things inside the engineer's control. I want that to not panic.
I don't want dependencies deciding to unwrap() or expect() some bullshit and that causing my entire program to crash because I didn't anticipate or handle the panic.
Code should be written, to the largest extent possible, to mitigate errors using Result<>. This is just laziness.
I want checks in the language to safeguard against lazy Rust developers. I don't want their code in my dependency tree, and I want static guarantees against this.
edit: I just searched unwrap() usage on Github, and I'm now kind of worried/angry:
https://github.com/search?q=unwrap%28%29+language%3ARust&typ...
A lot of this is just pure laziness.
Look at how many lazy cases of this there are in Rust code [1].
Some of these are no doubt tested (albeit impossible to statically guarantee), but a lot of it looks like sloppiness or not leaning on the language's strong error handling features.
It's disappointing to see. We've had so much of this creep into the language that eventually it caused a major stop-the-world outage. This is unlikely to be the last time we see it.
[1] https://github.com/search?q=unwrap%28%29+language%3ARust&typ...
A language DX feature I quite like is when dangerous things are labelled as such. IIRC, some examples of this are `accursedUnutterablePerformIO` in Haskell, and `DO_NOT_USE_OR_YOU_WILL_BE_FIRED_EXPERIMENTAL_CREATE_ROOT_CONTAINERS` in React.js.
I still think we should remove them outright or make production code fail to compile without a flag allowing them. And we also need tools to start cleaning up our dependency tree of this mess.
Unless the language addresses no-panic in its governing design or allows try-catch, not sure how you go about this.
https://github.com/search?q=unwrap%28%29+language%3ARust&typ...
This is ridiculous. We're probably going to start seeing more of these. This was just the first, big highly visible instance.
We should have a name for this similar to "my code just NPE'd". I suggest "unwrapped", as in, "My Rust app just unwrapped a present."
I think we should start advocating for the deprecation and eventual removal of the unwrap/expect family of methods. There's no reason engineers shouldn't be handling Options and Results gracefully, either passing the state to the caller or turning to a success or fail path. Not doing this is just laziness.
For the 5% of cases that are too complex for standard iterators? I never bother justifying why my indexes are correct, but I don't see why not.
You very rarely need SAFETY comments in Rust because almost all the code you write is safe in the first place. The language also gives you the tool to avoid manual iteration (not just for safety, but because it lets the compiler eliminate bounds checks), so it would actually be quite viable to write these comments, since you only need them when you're doing something unusual.